Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Persuasion, by Jane Austen

“Yes, I have, presently. But here comes a friend, Captain Brigden; I
shall only say, ‘How d’ye do?’ as we pass, however. I shall not stop.
‘How d’ye do?’ Brigden stares to see anybody with me but my wife. She,
poor soul, is tied by the leg. She has a blister on one of her heels,
as large as a three-shilling piece. If you look across the street, you
will see Admiral Brand coming down and his brother. Shabby fellows,
both of them! I am glad they are not on this side of the way. Sophy
cannot bear them. They played me a pitiful trick once: got away with
some of my best men. I will tell you the whole story another time.
There comes old Sir Archibald Drew and his grandson. Look, he sees us;
he kisses his hand to you; he takes you for my wife. Ah! the peace has
come too soon for that younker. Poor old Sir Archibald! How do you like
Bath, Miss Elliot? It suits us very well. We are always meeting with
some old friend or other; the streets full of them every morning; sure
to have plenty of chat; and then we get away from them all, and shut
ourselves in our lodgings, and draw in our chairs, and are as snug as
if we were at Kellynch, ay, or as we used to be even at North Yarmouth
and Deal. We do not like our lodgings here the worse, I can tell you,
for putting us in mind of those we first had at North Yarmouth. The
wind blows through one of the cupboards just in the same way.”

When they were got a little farther, Anne ventured to press again for
what he had to communicate. She hoped when clear of Milsom Street to
have her curiosity gratified; but she was still obliged to wait, for
the Admiral had made up his mind not to begin till they had gained the
greater space and quiet of Belmont; and as she was not really Mrs
Croft, she must let him have his own way. As soon as they were fairly
ascending Belmont, he began—

“Well, now you shall hear something that will surprise you. But first
of all, you must tell me the name of the young lady I am going to talk
about. That young lady, you know, that we have all been so concerned
for. The Miss Musgrove, that all this has been happening to. Her
Christian name: I always forget her Christian name.”

Explanation ​

Detailed Analysis of the Excerpt from Persuasion by Jane Austen ​

1. Context of the Excerpt ​

This passage is from Jane Austen’s Persuasion (1817), her final completed novel, which explores themes of second chances, social class, naval life, and the consequences of persuasion in matters of love and duty. The novel follows Anne Elliot, a quiet, overlooked woman of 27 who, eight years prior, was persuaded by her family to break off her engagement to Frederick Wentworth, a naval officer with no fortune. Now, Wentworth has returned wealthy and successful, while Anne remains unmarried, still in love with him.

The excerpt occurs in Bath, a fashionable resort city where Anne’s vain and status-obsessed family has relocated. She is walking with Admiral Croft, a kindly but garrulous naval officer who, along with his wife Sophy, has rented Kellynch Hall (the Elliot family estate) from Anne’s father, Sir Walter. The Admiral is about to reveal crucial news—likely concerning Louisa Musgrove, a young woman who had recently suffered a serious accident (a fall from a sea wall in Lyme) while under Wentworth’s indirect care.

2. Themes in the Excerpt ​

A. Naval Life vs. Aristocratic Society ​

  • The Admiral’s casual, conversational style contrasts sharply with the formal, self-important demeanor of the Elliot family (particularly Sir Walter, who despises the navy as a "vulgar" profession).
  • His anecdotes about naval officers ("Shabby fellows," "got away with some of my best men") highlight the camaraderie and competition in naval circles, which Austen portrays as more merit-based than the hereditary snobbery of the gentry.
  • The Admiral’s praise for Bath’s social scene ("always meeting with some old friend") mirrors the superficial sociability of the Elliots, but his warmth and lack of pretension set him apart.

B. Gender and Marriage ​

  • The Admiral’s offhand remark about his wife Sophy ("tied by the leg" due to a blister) is humorous but revealing—it suggests a practical, affectionate marriage where Sophy is his equal, unlike the loveless, status-driven marriages in Anne’s family.
  • His mistaking Anne for Mrs. Croft ("he takes you for my wife") subtly underscores Anne’s invisibility—she is so unremarkable in her family’s eyes that even a stranger assumes she must be someone’s wife rather than an unmarried woman of standing.

C. Social Observation and Satire ​

  • Austen satirizes the triviality of Bath society through the Admiral’s gossipy, meandering speech. His judgments on people’s appearances ("Shabby fellows," "poor old Sir Archibald") reflect the superficial values of the time.
  • The contrast between the Admiral’s warmth and Sir Walter’s coldness reinforces Austen’s critique of aristocratic vanity—the Crofts are happy and content in modest lodgings, while the Elliots are miserable despite their wealth.

D. Suspense and Narrative Tension ​

  • The Admiral’s delay in revealing his news ("You shall hear something that will surprise you") builds anticipation, a technique Austen uses to engage the reader in Anne’s emotional state.
  • His forgetting Louisa Musgrove’s name ("Her Christian name: I always forget") is ironic—given that her accident was a pivotal moment in the novel, affecting Wentworth’s feelings toward Anne.

3. Literary Devices ​

A. Free Indirect Discourse ​

  • Austen blends the Admiral’s voice with the narrator’s, creating a natural, conversational tone that immerses the reader in the scene.
  • Example: "Shabby fellows, both of them! I am glad they are not on this side of the way." → The exclamatory style and colloquial phrasing ("d’ye do," "ay") reflect the Admiral’s naval, no-nonsense personality.

B. Irony ​

  • Dramatic Irony: The reader knows Anne’s deep emotional investment in Wentworth’s life, while the Admiral unwittingly teases her with delayed information.
  • Situational Irony: The Admiral, a man of action, is comically long-winded, delaying his revelation in a way that frustrates the reserved, patient Anne.

C. Stream of Consciousness (Proto-Modernist Technique) ​

  • The Admiral’s rambling, associative speech ("There comes old Sir Archibald Drew and his grandson… the wind blows through one of the cupboards just in the same way") mimics realistic conversation, foreshadowing later modernist techniques (e.g., Virginia Woolf).

D. Symbolism ​

  • Bath as a Microcosm: The city represents social performance and artifice, where people judge each other by appearances (e.g., the Admiral’s comments on Sir Archibald’s kiss).
  • The Wind in the Cupboard: A small, homely detail that contrasts with the grandeur the Elliots crave, symbolizing the Crofts’ contentment in simplicity.

E. Character Foil ​

  • The Admiral foils Sir Walter Elliot:
    • Admiral Croft: Warm, practical, unpretentious, values loyalty and experience.
    • Sir Walter: Cold, vain, obsessed with rank, values appearances and lineage.
  • His easy camaraderie with Anne (treating her as an equal) contrasts with her family’s neglect.

4. Significance of the Excerpt ​

A. Advancing the Plot ​

  • The Admiral’s delayed revelation (about Louisa Musgrove’s engagement to Captain Benwick) is crucial:
    • It removes Louisa as a romantic obstacle between Anne and Wentworth.
    • It sets up Wentworth’s emotional availability, leading to the climactic letter scene where he declares his renewed love for Anne.

B. Reinforcing Anne’s Character ​

  • Anne’s patience and quiet persistence ("Anne ventured to press again") highlight her inner strength, contrasting with her family’s selfishness.
  • Her tolerance of the Admiral’s rambling shows her kindness and emotional resilience, qualities that make her worthy of Wentworth’s love.

C. Social Commentary ​

  • Austen critiques the rigidity of class structures by showing the Admiral’s superiority in character over the aristocratic Elliots.
  • The excerpt subtly champions the navy as a meritocratic alternative to the decadent gentry, reflecting post-Napoleonic War Britain’s shifting social dynamics.

D. Narrative Technique ​

  • The passage demonstrates Austen’s mastery of dialogue—using realistic speech patterns to develop character and tension.
  • The delayed gratification (withholding key information) is a hallmark of Austen’s storytelling, keeping readers engaged.

5. Connection to Broader Themes in Persuasion ​

  • Second Chances: The Admiral’s news paves the way for Anne and Wentworth’s reunion, reinforcing the novel’s hopeful message about redemption.
  • The Value of Constancy: Anne’s steady endurance (waiting for the Admiral to speak) mirrors her years of quiet love for Wentworth.
  • The Navy vs. the Gentry: The Admiral embodies the virtues of the naval class (loyalty, hard work, humility), which Austen contrasts favorably with the vanity of the aristocracy.

6. Conclusion: Why This Excerpt Matters ​

This seemingly minor conversation is rich in subtext:

  • It advances the plot toward the novel’s romantic resolution.
  • It deepens Austen’s social critique, contrasting authentic human connection (Admiral Croft) with empty social posturing (the Elliots).
  • It showcases Austen’s narrative skill, using dialogue, irony, and suspense to engage the reader emotionally.

Ultimately, the excerpt reinforces Persuasion’s central theme: true worth lies in character, not rank, and love, when genuine, can endure even the longest separations.

Would you like any further analysis on specific aspects, such as the Admiral’s role as a comic relief character or the significance of Bath in the novel?