Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Twilight Stories, by Unknown Author

Tommy stood aghast! for, really and truly, he wasn't quite so
stony-hearted a little mortal as he appeared to be; he had been secretly
rather sorry for Dick, but--he wanted Daisy to think that he himself was
big and manly, and he had the opinion that this was just the way to win
her admiration. But all this time HE DIDN'T KNOW WHAT DAISY DID--that
Dick's pockets were full of sugar-plums; tiptop ones too, for Daisy had
tasted them, and knew that little packets of them would from time to
time find their way into her chubby hand.

All the rest of the morning Tommy kept thinking, thinking, thinking.
One thing was certain: the present situation was not to be endured
one moment longer than was absolutely necessary. But what could he do?
Should he fight Dicky? This plan was rejected at once, on high, moral
grounds. Well, then, supposing some dark night he should see Daisy on
the street, just grab her, hold on tight and say: "Now, Daisy Rivers, I
won't let you go till you promise you'll like me a great deal betterer
than you do Dick Ray." There seemed something nice about this plan, very
nice; the more Tommy thought of it, the better he liked it; only there
were two objections to it. Firstly: Daisy never by any chance ventured
out doors after dark. Secondly: Neither did Tom.

Both objections being insurmountable, this delightful scheme was
reluctantly abandoned, and the thinking process went on harder than
ever, till at last--oh, oh! if he only dared! What a triumph it would
be! But then he couldn't--yes, he could too. Didn't she say that she
"wouldn't be one bit s'prised if he hollered so loud that they would
hear him way down in Colorado?" Colorado, indeed! He'd show her there
was one boy in the school who wasn't a girl-cry-baby!

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Twilight Stories ​

Context & Source ​

This excerpt is from Twilight Stories, a collection of children’s literature likely written in the late 19th or early 20th century (the exact author is unknown). The story follows Tommy, a young boy struggling with jealousy, pride, and unrequited affection for a girl named Daisy, who seems to favor another boy, Dick. The passage captures Tommy’s internal conflict as he grapples with how to win Daisy’s admiration while maintaining his self-image as "big and manly."

The tone is lighthearted yet psychologically insightful, blending humor with a child’s earnest emotional turmoil. The story reflects Victorian or Edwardian-era children’s literature, where moral lessons about honesty, bravery, and self-awareness were often embedded in playful narratives.

Themes ​

  1. Childhood Jealousy & Competition

    • Tommy is secretly envious of Dick because Daisy favors him (especially since Dick has sugar-plums, a symbol of his generosity and Daisy’s affection).
    • His pride prevents him from admitting his true feelings, leading to internal conflict.

  2. Performative Masculinity

    • Tommy believes that being "big and manly" means hiding vulnerability (e.g., rejecting the idea of crying, even when Daisy teases him about it).
    • His rejection of fighting Dick on "moral grounds" is ironic—he wants to appear noble, but his real motivation is fear (of losing, of looking weak).

  3. Wishful Thinking vs. Reality

    • Tommy’s fantasies (kidnapping Daisy, proving his bravery by not crying) are grand but impractical.
    • The humor comes from how his childish logic (e.g., "I won’t let you go till you like me betterer") clashes with real-world limitations (neither he nor Daisy goes out at night).

  4. The Power of Small Gestures

    • Dick’s sugar-plums (candy) symbolize simple, effective kindness—something Tommy, in his pride, overlooks.
    • Daisy’s affection is earned through generosity, not dramatic displays.

  5. Self-Deception & Growth

    • Tommy thinks he’s being strategic, but the reader sees his immature reasoning.
    • The passage hints at potential growth—will he realize that authenticity (not forced bravery) wins Daisy’s respect?

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Free Indirect Discourse

    • The narrator blends Tommy’s thoughts with third-person narration, creating intimacy.
      • "HE DIDN’T KNOW WHAT DAISY DID" (italics emphasize his ignorance).
      • "like me a great deal betterer" (childish grammar reflects his voice).

  2. Irony & Humor

    • Dramatic Irony: The reader knows Daisy likes Dick because he shares candy, while Tommy assumes it’s about strength.
    • Situational Irony: Tommy’s "dark night kidnapping plan" is absurd because neither child goes out after dark.
    • Hyperbole: "hollered so loud they’d hear him in Colorado"—Daisy’s teasing exposes Tommy’s fragile ego.

  3. Symbolism

    • Sugar-plums = affection, generosity (Dick’s kindness vs. Tommy’s empty posturing).
    • Darkness = fear/unknown (Tommy’s reluctance to act in the dark mirrors his emotional avoidance).

  4. Repetition for Effect

    • "thinking, thinking, thinking" → obsessive, cyclical thoughts of a child stuck in his own head.
    • "He couldn’t—yes, he could too" → internal debate, showing his wavering confidence.

  5. Exclamation & Informal Diction

    • "Tommy stood aghast!", "Colorado, indeed!" → exaggerated reactions fit a child’s dramatic perspective.
    • "betterer" (non-standard) → authentic child speech, adding realism.

Significance & Deeper Meaning ​

  1. Childhood as a Microcosm of Adult Struggles

    • Tommy’s pride and insecurity mirror adult romantic competition—his performance of masculinity is a learned behavior.
    • The story suggests that true confidence comes from self-awareness, not posturing.

  2. Critique of Toxic Masculinity

    • Tommy equates manliness with suppression of emotion (rejecting crying, considering fighting).
    • The absurdity of his plans highlights how performative toughness is unproductive.

  3. The Value of Simplicity

    • Dick wins Daisy’s favor through small, kind acts (sharing candy), while Tommy overcomplicates everything.
    • The lesson: Genuine connections are built through consistency, not grand gestures.

  4. Humor as a Tool for Moral Lessons

    • The comical tone makes the story engaging for children, but the underlying message (about honesty, humility) is serious.
    • Tommy’s failed schemes serve as gentle satire of childish (and adult) vanity.

Line-by-Line Breakdown of Key Moments ​

  1. "he wasn't quite so stony-hearted a little mortal as he appeared to be"

    • Contrast between appearance and reality—Tommy acts tough but feels secret sorrow for Dick.

  2. "he wanted Daisy to think that he himself was big and manly"

    • Motivation revealed: His actions are for Daisy’s approval, not genuine strength.

  3. "Dick's pockets were full of sugar-plums; tiptop ones too"

    • Symbolic detail: Dick’s generosity (vs. Tommy’s selfish scheming) is what wins Daisy over.

  4. "supposing some dark night he should see Daisy on the street, just grab her"

    • Childish fantasy—his plan is romanticized kidnapping, revealing his lack of understanding of consent or real affection.

  5. "Colorado, indeed! He'd show her there was one boy in the school who wasn't a girl-cry-baby!"

    • Defensive pride: Daisy’s teasing triggers his insecurity—he overcompensates by rejecting vulnerability entirely.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is a masterclass in child psychology through literature. It captures:

  • The universal experience of childhood jealousy.
  • The absurdity of performative masculinity.
  • The contrast between empty pride and genuine kindness.

The humor and irony make it entertaining, but the underlying themes—about authenticity, emotional honesty, and the folly of pride—give it lasting relevance. Tommy’s internal struggle is relatable at any age, making this more than just a children’s story—it’s a satirical, heartfelt exploration of human nature.

Final Thought: The real "twilight" here isn’t the time of day—it’s the dawn of Tommy’s self-awareness, if only he’d stop scheming long enough to see it.