Article #537-1 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from Tales of Terror and Mystery, by Arthur Conan Doyle

"These were the thoughts in my head as I climbed that monstrous,
inclined plane with the wind sometimes beating in my face and sometimes
whistling behind my ears, while the cloud-land beneath me fell away to
such a distance that the folds and hummocks of silver had all smoothed
out into one flat, shining plain. But suddenly I had a horrible and
unprecedented experience. I have known before what it is to be in what
our neighbours have called a tourbillon, but never on such a scale as
this. That huge, sweeping river of wind of which I have spoken had, as
it appears, whirlpools within it which were as monstrous as itself.
Without a moment's warning I was dragged suddenly into the heart of
one. I spun round for a minute or two with such velocity that I almost
lost my senses, and then fell suddenly, left wing foremost, down the
vacuum funnel in the centre. I dropped like a stone, and lost nearly a
thousand feet. It was only my belt that kept me in my seat, and the
shock and breathlessness left me hanging half-insensible over the side
of the fuselage. But I am always capable of a supreme effort--it is my
one great merit as an aviator. I was conscious that the descent was
slower. The whirlpool was a cone rather than a funnel, and I had come
to the apex. With a terrific wrench, throwing my weight all to one
side, I levelled my planes and brought her head away from the wind. In
an instant I had shot out of the eddies and was skimming down the sky.
Then, shaken but victorious, I turned her nose up and began once more
my steady grind on the upward spiral. I took a large sweep to avoid
the danger-spot of the whirlpool, and soon I was safely above it. Just
after one o'clock I was twenty-one thousand feet above the sea-level.
To my great joy I had topped the gale, and with every hundred feet of
ascent the air grew stiller. On the other hand, it was very cold, and
I was conscious of that peculiar nausea which goes with rarefaction of
the air. For the first time I unscrewed the mouth of my oxygen bag and
took an occasional whiff of the glorious gas. I could feel it running
like a cordial through my veins, and I was exhilarated almost to the
point of drunkenness. I shouted and sang as I soared upwards into the
cold, still outer world.

"It is very clear to me that the insensibility which came upon
Glaisher, and in a lesser degree upon Coxwell, when, in 1862, they
ascended in a balloon to the height of thirty thousand feet, was due to
the extreme speed with which a perpendicular ascent is made. Doing it
at an easy gradient and accustoming oneself to the lessened barometric
pressure by slow degrees, there are no such dreadful symptoms. At the
same great height I found that even without my oxygen inhaler I could
breathe without undue distress. It was bitterly cold, however, and my
thermometer was at zero, Fahrenheit. At one-thirty I was nearly seven
miles above the surface of the earth, and still ascending steadily. I
found, however, that the rarefied air was giving markedly less support
to my planes, and that my angle of ascent had to be considerably
lowered in consequence. It was already clear that even with my light
weight and strong engine-power there was a point in front of me where I
should be held. To make matters worse, one of my sparking-plugs was in
trouble again and there was intermittent misfiring in the engine. My
heart was heavy with the fear of failure.

"It was about that time that I had a most extraordinary experience.
Something whizzed past me in a trail of smoke and exploded with a loud,
hissing sound, sending forth a cloud of steam. For the instant I could
not imagine what had happened. Then I remembered that the earth is for
ever being bombarded by meteor stones, and would be hardly inhabitable
were they not in nearly every case turned to vapour in the outer layers
of the atmosphere. Here is a new danger for the high-altitude man, for
two others passed me when I was nearing the forty-thousand-foot mark.
I cannot doubt that at the edge of the earth's envelope the risk would
be a very real one.

Explanation

**Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Tales of Terror and Mystery by Arthur Conan Doyle**

This passage is from "The Horror of the Heights" (1913), one of Arthur Conan Doyle’s lesser-known but fascinating short stories, blending adventure, early aviation, and cosmic horror. The narrative is presented as a first-person account by an unnamed aviator who pushes the limits of high-altitude flight, only to encounter terrifying and unexplained phenomena. The story reflects early 20th-century anxieties about the unknown frontiers of science and exploration, as well as Doyle’s interest in speculative fiction (he also wrote The Lost World and The Poison Belt).

Below is a text-focused analysis, breaking down the excerpt’s narrative structure, themes, literary devices, and significance, while grounding the discussion in the actual words of the passage.

1. Context Within the Story

The excerpt describes the narrator’s perilous ascent into the upper atmosphere, where he battles natural forces (whirlwinds, thin air, mechanical failures) and encounters an eerie, otherworldly threat (meteorites—or something else?). The story builds toward a climax where the pilot discovers something far more horrifying than mere physical dangers—hinting at unseen, possibly extraterrestrial, entities lurking in the sky.

This passage serves as a transition from mundane aviation hazards to supernatural dread, foreshadowing the story’s later revelations. The narrator’s scientific detachment gradually gives way to awe and terror, a shift mirrored in the prose.

2. Themes

A. The Sublime and Human Insignificance

The passage is steeped in the Romantic and Gothic tradition of the sublime—the overwhelming, terrifying beauty of nature that dwarf human scale. Key phrases emphasize this:

"monstrous, inclined plane" – The sky is not just vast but actively hostile, a living force.
"cloud-land beneath me fell away... into one flat, shining plain" – The earth becomes abstract, distant, and unreal, reducing human existence to a speck.
"I dropped like a stone" – The narrator is at the mercy of forces beyond his control, a common trope in adventure and horror (e.g., Melville’s Moby-Dick, Poe’s Descent into the Maelström).

The whirlpool (tourbillon) is a particularly potent symbol. In literature, whirlpools often represent chaos, fate, or the inescapable pull of the unknown (e.g., Edgar Allan Poe’s A Descent into the Maelström). Here, it’s a cosmic vortex, suggesting that the higher one climbs, the more one risks being consumed by forces beyond human comprehension.

B. The Limits of Science and Exploration

Doyle, writing in 1913 (just a decade after the Wright brothers’ first flight), taps into the early 20th-century fascination—and fear—of aviation. The narrator is a pioneer, but his journey is fraught with:

Physical dangers: "the rarefied air was giving markedly less support to my planes" – Technology fails at the edges of human endurance.
Psychological strain: "my heart was heavy with the fear of failure" – The pressure to conquer the unknown weighs on him.
Uncharted threats: "Something whizzed past me in a trail of smoke" – The meteorites (or are they?) introduce an existential risk, suggesting that the sky is not empty but populated by unseen dangers.

The reference to Glaisher and Coxwell’s 1862 balloon ascent (a real historical event where the aeronauts nearly died from altitude sickness) grounds the story in scientific plausibility, making the later supernatural elements more unsettling.

C. The Thrill and Peril of the Unknown

The narrator’s emotions oscillate between exhilaration and terror:

"I shouted and sang as I soared upwards into the cold, still outer world." – A moment of transcendence, almost religious ecstasy.
"My heart was heavy with the fear of failure." – The burden of ambition.
"a new danger for the high-altitude man" – The unexpected threat of meteorites (or something worse) reinforces the idea that the universe is indifferent, if not hostile, to human curiosity.

This duality—awe and dread—is central to weird fiction (e.g., Lovecraft’s cosmic horror), where exploration leads not to mastery but to the realization of human fragility.

3. Literary Devices

A. Imagery and Sensory Language

Doyle’s prose is visceral and immersive, placing the reader in the pilot’s seat:

Tactile/Kinesthetic: "the shock and breathlessness left me hanging half-insensible over the side of the fuselage" – The physical toll is palpable.
Auditory: "whistling behind my ears", "loud, hissing sound" – Sound amplifies the chaos.
Visual: "the folds and hummocks of silver had all smoothed out into one flat, shining plain" – The earth becomes surreal, almost dreamlike.

The contrast between beauty and terror is striking:

"silver" clouds vs. "monstrous whirlpool"
"glorious gas" (oxygen) vs. "bitterly cold"

B. Simile and Metaphor

"I dropped like a stone" – Emphasizes the sudden, helpless plunge.
"that huge, sweeping river of wind" – The wind is personified as a living, unpredictable force.
"the vacuum funnel in the centre" – The whirlpool is a vortex of annihilation, a common metaphor for the unknown (e.g., black holes in later sci-fi).

C. Foreshadowing and Suspense

The mechanical failures ("one of my sparking-plugs was in trouble") hint at the fragility of human technology in the face of nature.
The meteorites are introduced as a "new danger", but their description ("whizzed past me in a trail of smoke") is vague enough to suggest something more sinister—a hint of the story’s later reveal (spoiler: the pilot encounters sky-dwelling creatures).
The oxygen high ("exhilarated almost to the point of drunkenness") contrasts with the later horror, creating a false sense of security.

D. First-Person Narration and Unreliable Perspective

The first-person POV makes the account feel immediate and personal, but it also raises questions:

Is the narrator reliable? His euphoria ("I shouted and sang") could be hypoxia-induced hallucination.
The meteorites are described ambiguously—are they really meteorites, or something else? The narrator assumes they are, but the reader is left wondering.

This uncertainty is a hallmark of weird fiction, where the unexplained lingers.

4. Significance of the Passage

A. Historical Context: Early Aviation and the Unknown

In 1913, aviation was in its infancy. Pilots like the narrator were daring the impossible, and the upper atmosphere was a mystery. Doyle’s story reflects:

The public fascination with flight (the Wright brothers’ first flight was in 1903; by 1913, planes were still novel).
The fear of the unseen—what lies beyond human reach? (A theme that would later define Lovecraftian horror.)

B. Literary Influence: Proto-Cosmic Horror

While Doyle is best known for Sherlock Holmes, this story aligns with weird fiction and cosmic horror:

The indifferent universe (later a Lovecraftian trope).
The horror of the heights (a reversal of the traditional "horror of the depths").
The unreliable narrator whose perceptions may be altered by extreme conditions.

C. Psychological and Philosophical Undertones

The passage explores:

Human hubris: The pilot’s supreme effort to conquer the whirlpool is both admirable and foolish—nature (or the cosmos) cannot be fully mastered.
The cost of knowledge: The higher he goes, the more he risks losing himself (literally and metaphorically).
Isolation: At 40,000 feet, he is utterly alone, a theme that resonates with existentialist literature.

5. Key Takeaways from the Text Itself

The Whirlpool as a Metaphor for Chaos
- The sudden, unpredictable vortex mirrors the uncontrollable forces of nature and fate.
- The pilot’s struggle to escape is a microcosm of human resilience—and fragility.
The Duality of Flight: Freedom and Peril
- Flying is liberating ("I shouted and sang") but also deadly ("I dropped like a stone").
- The oxygen high is a false triumph—soon replaced by cold, mechanical failure, and unseen threats.
The Uncanny in the Mundane
- The meteorites seem ordinary at first, but their timing and description make them feel sinister.
- The realization that the sky is not empty foreshadows the story’s horror elements.
The Pilot’s Character: Bravery and Vulnerability
- He prides himself on his "supreme effort" as an aviator, yet he is terrified of failure.
- His scientific detachment ("It is very clear to me that the insensibility...") contrasts with his emotional reactions ("my heart was heavy"), making him a relatable but flawed narrator.

6. Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters

This excerpt is a masterclass in building tension through:

Vivid, sensory prose that immerses the reader in the pilot’s ordeal.
Themes of human limitation in the face of the sublime.
Foreshadowing that blends real-world dangers (altitude sickness, mechanical failure) with supernatural hints (the meteorites, the later reveal of sky creatures).

Doyle takes the adventure story and infuses it with cosmic dread, making "The Horror of the Heights" a bridge between early sci-fi and weird horror. The passage’s power lies in its duality—the thrill of exploration and the terror of the unknown, both rendered in gripping, immediate prose.

Final Thought:

If this were a modern story, it might be classified as sci-fi horror—but in 1913, it was pioneering, blending real aviation science with Gothic terror. The whirlpool, the failing engine, the eerie meteorites—all serve to ask: How far can humanity go before the universe pushes back?

Questions

Question 1

The narrator’s description of the whirlpool as a "vacuum funnel" and his subsequent escape from it serve primarily to:

A. illustrate the mechanical precision required to pilot an aircraft in extreme conditions.
B. contrast the beauty of high-altitude flight with the brutality of natural forces.
C. underscore the inevitability of human failure when confronting the sublime.
D. foreshadow the narrator’s eventual psychological unraveling due to hypoxia.
E. embody the tension between human agency and the indifferent, overwhelming power of nature.

Question 2

The narrator’s reaction to inhaling oxygen—"exhilarated almost to the point of drunkenness"—is most effectively read as:

A. a moment of triumph over the physiological limitations of high-altitude flight.
B. an ironic counterpoint to the mechanical failures plaguing his aircraft.
C. a fleeting, illusory sense of control that masks the precarity of his situation.
D. a literal description of oxygen toxicity, grounding the passage in scientific realism.
E. a metaphor for the euphoria of exploration, untainted by the dangers he has faced.

Question 3

The phrase "a new danger for the high-altitude man" is most thematically resonant because it:

A. introduces a tangible, verifiable threat that disrupts the narrative’s speculative tone.
B. reflects the narrator’s growing paranoia, undermining his credibility as a reliable observer.
C. serves as a historical footnote, linking the story to documented risks of early aviation.
D. transforms the sky from a frontier of human conquest into an alien, hostile environment.
E. highlights the narrator’s scientific rigor in cataloging previously unrecognized hazards.

Question 4

The structural shift from the whirlpool episode to the meteorite encounter functions to:

A. accentuate the narrator’s resilience by presenting escalating but surmountable challenges.
B. transition from physical peril to psychological horror, signaling the story’s genre shift.
C. juxtapose the predictable dangers of aviation with the randomness of cosmic phenomena.
D. deepen the passage’s existential undertones by expanding the scope of threat beyond the terrestrial.
E. undermine the narrator’s authority by suggesting his perceptions are increasingly unreliable.

Question 5

The narrator’s assertion that "doing it at an easy gradient" mitigates altitude sickness is most effectively interpreted as:

A. a rejection of historical precedent in favor of personal empirical evidence.
B. an attempt to rationalize his survival while implicitly acknowledging the fragility of human endurance.
C. a critique of Glaisher and Coxwell’s methodological flaws in their 1862 ascent.
D. a moment of hubris that foreshadows his later encounter with insurmountable dangers.
E. an objective observation that temporarily restores the narrative’s scientific credibility.

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: E

Why E is most correct: The whirlpool episode is not merely a physical obstacle but a symbolic confrontation between the narrator’s skill ("supreme effort") and the indifferent, overwhelming force of nature ("huge, sweeping river of wind"). The passage emphasizes the tension between human agency (his ability to "level my planes") and the cosmic scale of the threat (the whirlpool’s "monstrous" proportions). This duality is central to the story’s exploration of human limits in the face of the sublime.