Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Worldly Ways & Byways, by Eliot Gregory

A man who, after fighting through our late war, had succeeded in amassing
a fortune, naturally wished his son to follow him on the only road in
which it had ever occurred to him that success was of any importance. So
beyond giving the boy a college education, which he had not enjoyed, his
ambition rarely went; his idea being to make a practical business man of
him, or a lawyer, that he could keep the estate together more
intelligently. In thousands of cases, of course, individual taste and
bent over-ruled this influence, and a career of science or art was
chosen; but in the mass of the American people, it was firmly implanted
that the pursuit of wealth was the only occupation to which a reasonable
human being could devote himself. A young man who was not in some way
engaged in increasing his income was looked upon as a very undesirable
member of society, and sure, sooner or later, to come to harm.

Millionaires declined to send their sons to college, saying they would
get ideas there that would unfit them for business, to Paterfamilias the
one object of life. Under such fostering influences, the ambitions in
our country have gradually given way to money standards and the false
start has been made! Leaving aside at once the question of money in its
relation to our politics (although it would be a fruitful subject for
moralizing), and confining ourselves strictly to the social side of life,
we soon see the results of this mammon worship.

In England (although Englishmen have been contemptuously called the shop-
keepers of the world) the extension and maintenance of their vast empire
is the mainspring which keeps the great machine in movement. And one
sees tens of thousands of well-born and delicately-bred men cheerfully
entering the many branches of public service where the hope of wealth can
never come, and retiring on pensions or half-pay in the strength of their
middle age, apparently without a regret or a thought beyond their
country's well-being.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Worldly Ways & Byways by Eliot Gregory ​

Context of the Source ​

Eliot Gregory (1854–1915) was an American journalist, editor, and social commentator. His work Worldly Ways & Byways (1902) is a collection of essays critiquing contemporary American and European society, particularly the growing obsession with wealth, materialism, and social conformity in the post-Civil War era (late 19th to early 20th century). This period, known as the Gilded Age, was marked by rapid industrialization, extreme wealth inequality, and a cultural shift toward Social Darwinism—the belief that financial success was a measure of moral and intellectual superiority.

The excerpt reflects Gregory’s concern over the commercialization of American values, where wealth accumulation was increasingly seen as the sole marker of success, eclipsing intellectual, artistic, or civic pursuits.

Breakdown of the Excerpt ​

1. The Father’s Ambition and the Son’s Expected Path ​

"A man who, after fighting through our late war, had succeeded in amassing a fortune, naturally wished his son to follow him on the only road in which it had ever occurred to him that success was of any importance."

  • Historical Context: The "late war" refers to the American Civil War (1861–1865), a conflict that reshaped American society. Many self-made men (often veterans) became wealthy through industry, railroads, or finance in the post-war economic boom.
  • Parental Expectations: The father, having achieved wealth through business, assumes that financial success is the only meaningful form of achievement. His worldview is narrow—he cannot conceive of other paths (art, science, public service) as valid.
  • Irony: The father, who likely lacked formal education, sends his son to college—but only as a practical stepping stone to business or law, not for intellectual growth.

"So beyond giving the boy a college education, which he had not enjoyed, his ambition rarely went; his idea being to make a practical business man of him, or a lawyer, that he could keep the estate together more intelligently."

  • Utilitarian View of Education: College is not for enlightenment but for instrumental purposes—to make the son a more effective wealth manager.
  • Limited Vision of Success: The father’s definition of success is material preservation—keeping the family fortune intact—rather than personal fulfillment or societal contribution.

2. The Dominance of Wealth as a Social Ideal ​

"In thousands of cases, of course, individual taste and bent over-ruled this influence, and a career of science or art was chosen; but in the mass of the American people, it was firmly implanted that the pursuit of wealth was the only occupation to which a reasonable human being could devote himself."

  • Acknowledgment of Exceptions: Gregory concedes that some resist this pressure (e.g., artists, scientists), but the dominant cultural narrative still equates reasonableness with wealth-seeking.
  • Cultural Critique: The phrase "the mass of the American people" suggests a homogenization of values, where dissenters are seen as irrational or impractical.
  • Social Darwinism Influence: The belief that financial success is the natural order implies that those who don’t pursue wealth are weak or flawed.

"A young man who was not in some way engaged in increasing his income was looked upon as a very undesirable member of society, and sure, sooner or later, to come to harm."

  • Moral Judgment: Not pursuing wealth is not just unconventional—it’s socially dangerous. The implication is that poverty or non-materialism leads to ruin.
  • Fear-Based Conformity: Society pressures individuals into wealth accumulation out of fear of failure, not genuine desire.

3. The Rejection of Higher Education by the Elite ​

"Millionaires declined to send their sons to college, saying they would get ideas there that would unfit them for business, to Paterfamilias the one object of life."

  • Anti-Intellectualism: The wealthy elite distrust education because it might inspire idealism, creativity, or criticism of capitalism—qualities seen as detrimental to business.
  • "Paterfamilias": A Latin term meaning "father of the family," emphasizing patriarchal control over the son’s future. The father’s authority is absolute, and his only goal is financial perpetuation.
  • Satirical Tone: Gregory mocks the short-sightedness of these millionaires, who see knowledge as a threat rather than an asset.

4. The Consequences of "Mammon Worship" ​

"Under such fostering influences, the ambitions in our country have gradually given way to money standards and the false start has been made!"

  • "Mammon": A biblical term for wealth as a false god (Matthew 6:24: "You cannot serve both God and mammon."). Gregory frames American society as idolizing money.
  • "False start": The pursuit of wealth as the primary national goal is a moral and cultural mistake, leading to long-term societal decay.
  • Prophetic Warning: Gregory suggests that this materialism will have dire consequences, though he does not elaborate here (he excludes politics, but the implication is corruption).

5. Contrast with England: Public Service vs. Private Gain ​

"In England (although Englishmen have been contemptuously called the shop-keepers of the world) the extension and maintenance of their vast empire is the mainspring which keeps the great machine in movement."

  • Historical Context: The phrase "shop-keepers of the world" was a French insult (from Napoleon) suggesting the English were mere merchants, not noble imperialists. Gregory reclaims the term ironically—even if England is commercial, it still values public duty.
  • Contrast with America: While America is obsessed with individual wealth, England’s elite serve the state and empire, often in low-paying but prestigious roles (military, civil service, diplomacy).

"And one sees tens of thousands of well-born and delicately-bred men cheerfully entering the many branches of public service where the hope of wealth can never come, and retiring on pensions or half-pay in the strength of their middle age, apparently without a regret or a thought beyond their country's well-being."

  • Selfless Service: English aristocrats and gentlemen sacrifice personal gain for national glory, accepting modest pensions.
  • Cultural Difference: America’s individualism vs. England’s collectivist imperial duty.
  • Implied Criticism: Gregory suggests that America’s lack of a similar civic ethos makes it morally inferior—a society that values money over country.

Key Themes ​

  1. The Commercialization of American Values

    • Wealth is the sole measure of success, eclipsing intellectual, artistic, or civic aspirations.
    • Education is devalued unless it serves financial goals.

  2. Generational Control and Conformity

    • Fathers impose their materialistic worldview on sons, stifling individuality.
    • Social pressure ensures that deviating from wealth-seeking is seen as failure.

  3. Anti-Intellectualism Among the Elite

    • The rich fear education because it might inspire non-conformist ideas.
    • Practicality over principle dominates American ambition.

  4. Moral Decay from Mammon Worship

    • The idolization of money leads to a hollow, fear-driven society.
    • Gregory warns of a cultural "false start" with long-term consequences.

  5. Contrast Between American Individualism and English Civic Duty

    • America: Wealth = personal success.
    • England: Service = national greatness.
    • Gregory criticizes America’s lack of a higher purpose beyond materialism.

Literary Devices ​

  1. Irony

    • The father sends his son to college (which he disliked) but only for practical reasons.
    • England, despite being called "shop-keepers," has a nobler cultural ideal than America.

  2. Satire

    • Mocking the short-sightedness of millionaires who see education as a threat.
    • Criticizing America’s obsession with wealth as a false religion ("mammon worship").

  3. Juxtaposition

    • America (greed) vs. England (duty)—highlighting cultural differences.
    • Individual ambition vs. collective good.

  4. Hyperbole

    • "the only occupation to which a reasonable human being could devote himself"—exaggerates the extremity of American materialism.

  5. Biblical Allusion ("Mammon")

    • Frames wealth as a false god, reinforcing the moral critique.

Significance of the Excerpt ​

  1. Critique of the Gilded Age

    • Gregory’s essay reflects widespread anxiety about America’s moral decline due to unchecked capitalism.
    • Similar concerns were raised by other critics like Mark Twain, Henry Adams, and Thorstein Veblen (who coined "conspicuous consumption").

  2. Relevance to Modern Capitalism

    • The pressure to prioritize wealth over passion or public service remains a contemporary issue.
    • The devaluation of humanities education in favor of "practical" degrees echoes today’s debates.

  3. Cultural Comparison

    • Gregory’s England vs. America contrast raises questions about national identity:
      • Is America only about money, or can it develop a higher civic purpose?
      • Does individualism prevent collective progress?

  4. Warning Against Materialism

    • The excerpt serves as a cautionary tale—societies that worship wealth risk losing intellectual, artistic, and moral depth.

Conclusion: Gregory’s Core Argument ​

Eliot Gregory laments that post-Civil War America has lost its moral compass, replacing intellectual, artistic, and civic ideals with a narrow, fear-driven pursuit of wealth. While England’s elite serve their empire with selfless duty, America’s millionaires distrust education and enforce a materialistic worldview on the next generation. The result is a society where non-conformists are stigmatized, ambition is reduced to profit, and cultural greatness is sacrificed for financial security.

His critique remains provocative today, challenging readers to consider:

  • What does success truly mean?
  • Is a society obsessed with wealth sustainable?
  • Can a nation thrive without valuing art, science, and public service?

Gregory’s answer is clear: A country that worships mammon has already taken a false step—and may never recover.