Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Merry Men, and Other Tales and Fables, by Robert Louis Stevenson

CHAPTER I.
EILEAN AROS.

It was a beautiful morning in the late July when I set forth on foot
for the last time for Aros. A boat had put me ashore the night before
at Grisapol; I had such breakfast as the little inn afforded, and,
leaving all my baggage till I had an occasion to come round for it by
sea, struck right across the promontory with a cheerful heart.

I was far from being a native of these parts, springing, as I did, from
an unmixed lowland stock. But an uncle of mine, Gordon Darnaway, after
a poor, rough youth, and some years at sea, had married a young wife in
the islands; Mary Maclean she was called, the last of her family; and
when she died in giving birth to a daughter, Aros, the sea-girt farm,
had remained in his possession. It brought him in nothing but the means
of life, as I was well aware; but he was a man whom ill-fortune had
pursued; he feared, cumbered as he was with the young child, to make a
fresh adventure upon life; and remained in Aros, biting his nails at
destiny. Years passed over his head in that isolation, and brought
neither help nor contentment. Meantime our family was dying out in the
lowlands; there is little luck for any of that race; and perhaps my
father was the luckiest of all, for not only was he one of the last to
die, but he left a son to his name and a little money to support it. I
was a student of Edinburgh University, living well enough at my own
charges, but without kith or kin; when some news of me found its way to
Uncle Gordon on the Ross of Grisapol; and he, as he was a man who held
blood thicker than water, wrote to me the day he heard of my existence,
and taught me to count Aros as my home. Thus it was that I came to
spend my vacations in that part of the country, so far from all society
and comfort, between the codfish and the moorcocks; and thus it was
that now, when I had done with my classes, I was returning thither with
so light a heart that July day.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Merry Men, and Other Tales and Fables by Robert Louis Stevenson ​

Context of the Work ​

The Merry Men, and Other Tales and Fables (1882) is a collection of short stories by Robert Louis Stevenson, a Scottish author best known for Treasure Island (1883) and Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886). The collection includes adventure tales, supernatural stories, and historical fiction, often set in Scotland or the South Seas. "Eilean Aros" (later titled "The Merry Men") is the first story in the collection and introduces a gothic, atmospheric tale of isolation, fate, and moral ambiguity, blending adventure with psychological depth.

The excerpt provided is the opening chapter of "Eilean Aros", setting the stage for a narrative that will unfold on a remote Scottish island. The protagonist (whose name we later learn is Charles Darnaway) recounts his journey to Aros, a small, isolated island inherited by his uncle. The story will later involve shipwrecks, hidden treasures, and moral dilemmas, but this opening establishes themes of inheritance, fate, and the weight of the past.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. Isolation and Fate

    • The narrator describes Aros as a "sea-girt farm"—a place cut off from the world, both geographically and emotionally. His uncle, Gordon Darnaway, is trapped there, "biting his nails at destiny", suggesting a man resigned to his unfortunate lot in life.
    • The narrator himself is without "kith or kin" (family or friends), reinforcing the theme of loneliness and the search for belonging. His journey to Aros is not just physical but also a quest for connection—to his uncle, his heritage, and perhaps his own future.

  2. Inheritance and Legacy

    • The island Aros is passed down through Mary Maclean, the last of her family, to Gordon Darnaway, and now implicitly to the narrator. This chain of inheritance carries with it bad luck and stagnation—Gordon is unable to escape his circumstances, and the narrator, though educated and free, is still drawn back to this place of decay and limitation.
    • The lowland family’s decline ("our family was dying out in the lowlands; there is little luck for any of that race") suggests a cursed or doomed lineage, a common gothic trope.

  3. Contrast Between Freedom and Constraint

    • The narrator is a student in Edinburgh, a city of learning and progress, yet he is drawn back to the primitive, isolated Aros. His "light heart" contrasts with his uncle’s bitterness, showing how the same place can represent both freedom and imprisonment depending on one’s perspective.
    • The sea (a recurring symbol in Stevenson’s work) represents both opportunity and danger—Gordon’s years at sea brought him nothing but hardship, while the narrator’s journey by sea is (for now) one of optimism.

  4. The Supernatural and Fate

    • While not yet overtly supernatural, the excerpt hints at an inescapable destiny. The uncle’s resignation ("he feared to make a fresh adventure upon life") suggests that Aros is not just a place but a force—one that pulls people into its orbit.
    • The later story involves ghostly omens and moral choices, so this opening sets up the idea that some places (and bloodlines) are cursed.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. First-Person Narration & Unreliable Perspective

    • The story is told in first-person, which creates intimacy but also uncertainty. The narrator is young, optimistic, and somewhat naive—his "light heart" may blind him to the darker truths of Aros.
    • Stevenson often uses unreliable or limited narrators (e.g., in Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde), making the reader question what is truly happening.

  2. Foreshadowing

    • The uncle’s bitterness ("biting his nails at destiny") foreshadows tragedy or conflict ahead.
    • The family’s bad luck ("little luck for any of that race") suggests that the narrator’s optimism may be misplaced.
    • The isolation of Aros hints at secrets, danger, or supernatural events (which indeed appear later in the story).

  3. Imagery & Atmosphere

    • Natural Imagery: The "beautiful morning in late July" contrasts with the dark fate of the characters, creating irony. The sea, moorcocks (grouse), and codfish emphasize the harsh, primitive life of Aros.
    • Gothic Tone: Words like "isolation," "ill-fortune," "dying out" create a sense of decay and doom, typical of gothic fiction.

  4. Symbolism

    • Aros Island: Represents both a refuge and a trap—a place of inheritance but also of stagnation and bad luck.
    • The Sea: Symbolizes fate, adventure, and danger. Gordon’s time at sea brought him misfortune, while the narrator’s journey is (so far) hopeful.
    • Baggage Left Behind: The narrator leaves his luggage to be picked up later, symbolizing his temporary freedom—he is not yet burdened by Aros, but he will be.

  5. Irony

    • The narrator’s cheerful heart is ironic given the dark history of Aros and his family’s misfortunes. His optimism may be short-lived.

Significance of the Excerpt ​

  1. Establishing the Setting & Mood

    • The opening immerses the reader in a remote, almost mythic landscape—Aros is not just a place but a character in itself, with its own history and curse.
    • The contrasts (beauty vs. decay, freedom vs. trap) create tension that will drive the story forward.

  2. Introducing Key Themes

    • Fate vs. Free Will: The narrator believes he is choosing to return to Aros, but the weight of inheritance suggests he may have no real choice.
    • Isolation & Madness: The uncle’s bitterness and resignation hint at the psychological toll of living in such a place—later, the story explores how isolation warps the mind.

  3. Characterization of the Narrator

    • The narrator is young, educated, and optimistic, but his lack of awareness about the dark history of Aros makes him a potentially tragic figure.
    • His connection to the island through blood (rather than choice) suggests that he is bound to its fate.

  4. Stevenson’s Gothic & Adventure Style

    • Stevenson blends realism with gothic elements—the remote Scottish setting is real, but the sense of doom is supernatural.
    • The slow build-up of tension is classic Stevenson—he lures the reader in with beauty before revealing darkness.

Connection to the Larger Story ​

The full story of "The Merry Men" (originally "Eilean Aros") involves:

  • The narrator’s discovery of a shipwreck and a hidden treasure.
  • A moral dilemma—whether to save a drowning man (who may be a criminal) or let him die for the sake of the treasure.
  • Supernatural elements, including ghostly omens and a cursed ship.
  • The uncle’s descent into madness and the narrator’s own moral corruption.

This opening sets up all of these elements by:

  • Establishing Aros as a place of fate and doom.
  • Introducing the family’s cursed history.
  • Creating a contrast between the narrator’s hope and the island’s darkness.

Final Analysis: Why This Excerpt Matters ​

This passage is a masterclass in atmospheric storytelling. Stevenson does not rely on immediate action but instead builds dread through setting, heritage, and subtle foreshadowing. The beauty of the morning contrasts with the weight of the past, making the reader uneasy even before anything supernatural occurs.

The narrator’s journey to Aros is not just a physical trip but a descent into a world where fate, morality, and madness intertwine. By the end of the story, his optimism will be tested, and the true nature of Aros—as a place of both refuge and ruin—will be revealed.

Stevenson’s genius lies in making the ordinary seem ominous—a simple walk to an island becomes the first step into a gothic nightmare.

Questions ​

Question 1 ​

The narrator’s description of his uncle as "biting his nails at destiny" serves primarily to:

A. evoke a sense of resigned fatalism that undermines the narrator’s own optimistic outlook.
B. illustrate the physical toll of manual labour on the uncle’s ageing body.
C. foreshadow the uncle’s eventual descent into literal madness later in the narrative.
D. contrast the uncle’s superstitious worldview with the narrator’s rational education.
E. emphasise the economic hardship of farming in the Hebrides during the 19th century.

Question 2 ​

The phrase "between the codfish and the moorcocks" functions most effectively as:

A. a metaphor for the narrator’s divided loyalties between land and sea.
B. an example of Stevenson’s use of Scots dialect to authenticate the setting.
C. a synecdoche encapsulating the stark, primitive existence of Aros.
D. a biblical allusion to the scarcity of resources on the island.
E. an ironic juxtaposition of the narrator’s urban sophistication with rural simplicity.

Question 3 ​

The narrator’s decision to leave his baggage "till I had an occasion to come round for it by sea" is most thematically resonant with:

A. his uncle’s reluctance to abandon Aros despite its hardships.
B. the lowland family’s gradual dissipation of wealth and influence.
C. the transient, unburdened nature of his current optimism.
D. the codfish’s role as a staple food source in island life.
E. the moorcocks’ inability to migrate from the isolated promontory.

Question 4 ​

Which of the following best describes the narrative effect of the passage’s temporal structure (e.g., "Years passed over his head in that isolation")?

A. It accelerates the pacing to mirror the narrator’s eagerness to reach Aros.
B. It creates a sense of cyclical time, reinforcing the inescapability of fate.
C. It highlights the uncle’s physical decline as a result of his sedentary lifestyle.
D. It compresses decades of stagnation into a single image of suspended suffering.
E. It contrasts the narrator’s youthful vitality with his uncle’s premature ageing.

Question 5 ​

The passage’s treatment of inheritance is most accurately characterised by which of the following tensions?

A. The conflict between legal ownership (Aros as property) and emotional detachment (the narrator’s light heart).
B. The disparity between the narrator’s education and his uncle’s lack of formal learning.
C. The paradox of Aros as both a legacy of belonging and a burden of misfortune.
D. The generational shift from superstitious fatalism (uncle) to enlightened pragmatism (narrator).
E. The contrast between the Maclean family’s extinction and the Darnaway line’s survival.

Solutions and Explanations ​

1) Correct answer: A ​

Why A is most correct: The phrase "biting his nails at destiny" is a visceral metaphor for helpless resignation, not mere physical decay or superstition. It directly undercuts the narrator’s "cheerful heart" by introducing a counterpoint of fatalism—suggesting that the uncle’s (and perhaps the narrator’s own) optimism is misplaced in the face of an inescapable, bleak fate. This tension between hope and doom is central to the passage’s gothic undertones.

Why the distractors are less supported:

  • B: The imagery is psychological, not physical; the focus is on destiny, not manual labour.
  • C: While the uncle’s madness is foreshadowed later in the full story, this phrase alone does not explicitly signal mental collapse—it’s about resignation, not derangement.
  • D: The passage does not frame the uncle as superstitious; his fatalism is existential, not irrational.
  • E: Economic hardship is implied but not the primary effect of the phrase, which is emotional and thematic.

2) Correct answer: C ​

Why C is most correct:"Codfish and moorcocks" are metonymies for the island’s meagre resources—the former representing the sea, the latter the land. Together, they synecdochically encapsulate the entirety of Aros’s harsh, primitive existence. The phrase is not dialectal (both terms are standard English) nor biblical, but a concrete distillation of survival.

Why the distractors are less supported:

  • A: The narrator shows no divided loyalties; the phrase is descriptive, not psychological.
  • B: The terms are not Scots dialect (e.g., "moorcock" is a standard term for red grouse).
  • D: There is no biblical reference to cod or grouse as symbols of scarcity.
  • E: The narrator’s urban sophistication is irrelevant here; the phrase is objective, not ironic.

3) Correct answer: C ​

Why C is most correct: Leaving his baggage behind symbolises the narrator’s current unburdened state—both physically and emotionally. His optimism is transient, untethered to the weight of Aros’s history (unlike his uncle). The act foreshadows that this lightness may not last once he fully inherits the island’s legacy.

Why the distractors are less supported:

  • A: The uncle’s reluctance is static; the narrator’s action is dynamic and temporary.
  • B: The family’s dissipation is background context, not the focus of the baggage symbolism.
  • D: Codfish are irrelevant to the symbolic act of leaving luggage.
  • E: Moorcocks’ migration is not analogous; the narrator’s baggage is a conscious choice, not a biological constraint.

4) Correct answer: D ​

Why D is most correct: The phrase "Years passed over his head in that isolation" compresses decades of stagnation into a single, suspended image. The uncle’s suffering is not linear but frozen, reinforcing the timeless, inescapable nature of his fate. This aligns with the gothic theme of time as a trap.

Why the distractors are less supported:

  • A: The pacing is not accelerated; the effect is slow, heavy, and oppressive.
  • B: While cyclical time is implied, the phrase emphasises stasis, not repetition.
  • C: The uncle’s physical decline is secondary to the psychological and temporal stagnation.
  • E: The contrast is not the focus; the phrase is about the uncle’s isolated suffering, not the narrator’s vitality.

5) Correct answer: C ​

Why C is most correct: Aros is simultaneously a legacy of belonging (the narrator’s "home") and a burden of misfortune (the family’s "little luck"). This paradox drives the passage’s tension: inheritance is both a gift and a curse, a theme central to gothic literature.

Why the distractors are less supported:

  • A: The tension is not between legal ownership and emotional detachment—the narrator feels connected, but the connection is fraught.
  • B: Education vs. lack thereof is not the core tension; the focus is on heritage, not learning.
  • D: The narrator is not framed as "enlightened"—his optimism may be naive, not pragmatic.
  • E: The contrast between families is present but peripheral; the primary tension is within the inheritance itself.