Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Lamplighter, by Charles Dickens

‘I mean to say I believe in Tom Grig,’ replied the chairman. ‘Whether I
believe in Murphy, or not, is a matter between me and my conscience; and
whether Murphy believes in himself, or not, is a matter between him and
his conscience. Gentlemen, I drink your healths.’

The lamplighter who did the company this honour, was seated in the
chimney-corner of a certain tavern, which has been, time out of mind, the
Lamplighters’ House of Call. He sat in the midst of a circle of
lamplighters, and was the cacique, or chief of the tribe.

If any of our readers have had the good fortune to behold a lamplighter’s
funeral, they will not be surprised to learn that lamplighters are a
strange and primitive people; that they rigidly adhere to old ceremonies
and customs which have been handed down among them from father to son
since the first public lamp was lighted out of doors; that they
intermarry, and betroth their children in infancy; that they enter into
no plots or conspiracies (for who ever heard of a traitorous
lamplighter?); that they commit no crimes against the laws of their
country (there being no instance of a murderous or burglarious
lamplighter); that they are, in short, notwithstanding their apparently
volatile and restless character, a highly moral and reflective people:
having among themselves as many traditional observances as the Jews, and
being, as a body, if not as old as the hills, at least as old as the
streets. It is an article of their creed that the first faint glimmering
of true civilisation shone in the first street-light maintained at the
public expense. They trace their existence and high position in the
public esteem, in a direct line to the heathen mythology; and hold that
the history of Prometheus himself is but a pleasant fable, whereof the
true hero is a lamplighter.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Lamplighter by Charles Dickens ​

This passage from The Lamplighter (1838), an early work by Charles Dickens, offers a satirical yet affectionate portrayal of lamplighters—a marginalized but essential working-class group in 19th-century London. While the text is humorous and exaggerated, it also reflects Dickens’ broader social commentary on class, tradition, and the dignity of labor. Below is a breakdown of the excerpt, focusing on its context, themes, literary devices, and significance, with an emphasis on close textual analysis.

1. Context of the Excerpt ​

  • Source & Publication: The Lamplighter was one of Dickens’ early sketches, published in The Monthly Magazine (1838) before being collected in Sketches by Boz (1839). These sketches were Dickens’ first major published works, showcasing his keen observational humor and social critique.
  • Historical Background: In the early 19th century, lamplighters were responsible for lighting and extinguishing gas street lamps—a dangerous, low-paying, but vital job. They were part of London’s working-class underbelly, often overlooked despite their role in maintaining public order (literally illuminating the streets).
  • Dickens’ Perspective: Dickens frequently wrote about the lives of the poor and laboring classes, blending humor with pathos. Here, he elevates lamplighters to a quasi-mythical status, mocking both their self-importance and society’s tendency to romanticize or ignore them.

2. Summary of the Passage ​

The excerpt describes a gathering of lamplighters in their traditional tavern, where their "chief" (the cacique) presides. The chairman makes a toast, playfully dodging a question about his belief in a fellow lamplighter named Murphy, before the narrator launches into a mock-ethnographic description of lamplighters as a "strange and primitive people" with ancient customs, moral purity, and a mythological origin story tied to Prometheus.

Key moments:

  1. The Chairman’s Toast – A humorous, evasive remark about belief and conscience.
  2. The Lamplighters’ Tavern – Their "House of Call" (a pub where they congregate) is framed as a sacred, timeless space.
  3. The Myth of the Lamplighters – They are portrayed as a noble, almost tribal group with rigid traditions, no history of crime, and a direct line to civilization itself.

3. Themes ​

A. Class and Social Hierarchy ​

  • Dickens satirizes how society views (or ignores) the working class. Lamplighters are both essential (they bring light to the streets) and invisible (they are poor, uneducated laborers).
  • The passage elevates them to mythic status—comparing them to the Jews (with their traditions) and even to Prometheus (the Titan who gave fire to humanity). This is ironic because, in reality, lamplighters were barely respected.
  • The tavern as a "House of Call" suggests a parallel to guilds or aristocratic clubs, but for the working poor. Their "chief" (cacique) is a joke—lamplighters have no real power, yet they mimic structures of authority.

B. Tradition and Ritual ​

  • The lamplighters are described as rigidly adhering to old customs, betrothing children in infancy, and having no traitors among them. This is exaggerated folklore, playing on Victorian fascination with "primitive" cultures (e.g., gypsies, rural communities).
  • The claim that they commit no crimes is humorous hyperbole—Dickens is poking fun at the idea that manual laborers are either noble savages or incapable of vice.
  • Their belief that street lights mark the dawn of civilization is a joke about how working-class people might mythologize their own labor to find dignity in it.

C. Satire and Social Commentary ​

  • Dickens mocks the romanticization of the poor. The lamplighters’ "high position in public esteem" is ironic—most people barely noticed them.
  • The Prometheus comparison is absurd: while Prometheus defied the gods to bring fire to humans, lamplighters merely light gas lamps for a wage. Yet, the joke implies that even the most menial labor has a kind of heroism.
  • The chairman’s evasive toast ("whether I believe in Murphy… is a matter between me and my conscience") suggests working-class skepticism and camaraderie—they don’t take each other too seriously, but they stick together.

4. Literary Devices ​

A. Irony & Hyperbole ​

  • "Highly moral and reflective people": Lamplighters were likely seen as rough, uneducated men, so this is sarcastic praise.
  • "No instance of a murderous or burglarious lamplighter": An exaggerated claim—of course some laborers committed crimes, but Dickens plays up their supposed purity.
  • "As old as the streets": A hyperbolic origin story, suggesting lamplighters are an ancient, almost eternal class.

B. Mock-Ethnography ​

  • The passage imitates an anthropological study, as if lamplighters are a newly discovered tribe. Phrases like:
    • "a strange and primitive people"
    • "rigidly adhere to old ceremonies"
    • "as many traditional observances as the Jews"
    • "not as old as the hills, at least as old as the streets"
    • All of this is fake scholarship, parodying how the Victorian middle class might exoticize the poor.

C. Allusion & Mythological Comparison ​

  • Prometheus: The Greek Titan who stole fire from the gods. Comparing lamplighters to him is ridiculously grand—yet it also suggests that even humble workers contribute to progress.
  • Jewish traditions: The comparison to Jewish customs (betrothals in infancy, strict observances) is both complimentary and stereotyping, reflecting Victorian attitudes toward "ancient" cultures.

D. Humor & Wordplay ​

  • "Cacique": A Spanish term for a Native American chief—an absurdly grand title for a lamplighter.
  • "House of Call": A pun—it’s both a pub and a symbolic gathering place for their "tribe."
  • The chairman’s evasive toast is a comic dodge, typical of Dickens’ witty dialogue.

5. Significance of the Passage ​

A. Dickens’ Early Style ​

  • This sketch shows Dickens’ knack for blending humor with social observation, a trait that would define his later novels (Pickwick Papers, Oliver Twist).
  • The mock-serious tone prefigures his satire in The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club (1836–37), where he similarly pokes fun at eccentric groups.

B. Working-Class Dignity ​

  • While the passage is funny, it also humanizes lamplighters. By giving them a mythic backstory, Dickens suggests that even the lowest jobs have value.
  • The tavern scene reinforces the idea of working-class solidarity—they may be poor, but they have their own culture and pride.

C. Critique of Victorian Attitudes ​

  • Dickens mocks the middle-class tendency to either ignore or romanticize the poor.
  • The Prometheus joke implies that society takes labor for granted—lamplighters are like modern-day fire-bringers, yet no one notices.

D. Historical Insight ​

  • The passage gives a glimpse into 19th-century urban life, where street lighting was a new and vital service.
  • The lamplighters’ tavern reflects the importance of pubs as social hubs for working men.

6. Close Reading of Key Lines ​

  1. "I mean to say I believe in Tom Grig… whether I believe in Murphy, or not, is a matter between me and my conscience."

    • The chairman’s evasive, humorous response sets the tone—lamplighters are skeptical but loyal.
    • The mention of conscience is ironic, as if their moral debates are as weighty as philosophical ones.

  2. "a strange and primitive people… rigidly adhere to old ceremonies"

    • The mock-anthropological language makes them seem exotic, when in reality, they’re just working men.
    • "Primitive" is a loaded term—Victorians often used it to describe non-European cultures, so applying it to London laborers is satirical.

  3. "the first faint glimmering of true civilisation shone in the first street-light maintained at the public expense."

    • A joke about progress—lamplighters humorously claim that their job is the foundation of civilization.
    • This is working-class pride mixed with self-deprecating humor.

  4. "they trace their existence… to the heathen mythology; and hold that the history of Prometheus… is but a pleasant fable, whereof the true hero is a lamplighter."

    • The absurd comparison highlights how myths are often about everyday heroes.
    • It’s also a dig at how society undervalues labor—if Prometheus were alive today, he’d probably be a lamplighter.

7. Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is more than just a funny sketch—it’s a microcosm of Dickens’ social commentary. By elevating lamplighters to mythic status, he:

  • Exposes the absurdity of class hierarchies (why are some jobs valued more than others?).
  • Celebrates working-class culture (their traditions, humor, and solidarity).
  • Critiques Victorian hypocrisy (the middle class ignores laborers unless they’re romanticized).

The passage also showcases Dickens’ early talent for blending humor, satire, and pathos—a style that would make him one of the greatest novelists of the 19th century. While The Lamplighter is not as famous as Oliver Twist or Great Expectations, it captures the essence of Dickens’ genius: finding dignity in the overlooked and laughter in the struggles of ordinary life.

Final Thought ​

If you ever walk past a streetlamp at night, think of Dickens’ lamplighters—unsung heroes of the city, lighting the way while remaining in the shadows. This passage reminds us that even the most mundane jobs have their own quiet epicness.