Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Holiday Romance, by Charles Dickens

Under the desperate circumstances of the case, the active brain of the
colonel, combining with his lawless pursuit (he is a pirate), suggested
an attack with fireworks. This, however, from motives of humanity, was
abandoned as too expensive.

Lightly armed with a paper-knife buttoned up under his jacket, and waving
the dreaded black flag at the end of a cane, the colonel took command of
me at two P.M. on the eventful and appointed day. He had drawn out the
plan of attack on a piece of paper, which was rolled up round a
hoop-stick. He showed it to me. My position and my full-length portrait
(but my real ears don’t stick out horizontal) was behind a corner
lamp-post, with written orders to remain there till I should see Miss
Drowvey fall. The Drowvey who was to fall was the one in spectacles, not
the one with the large lavender bonnet. At that signal I was to rush
forth, seize my bride, and fight my way to the lane. There a junction
would be effected between myself and the colonel; and putting our brides
behind us, between ourselves and the palings, we were to conquer or die.

The enemy appeared,—approached. Waving his black flag, the colonel
attacked. Confusion ensued. Anxiously I awaited my signal; but my
signal came not. So far from falling, the hated Drowvey in spectacles
appeared to me to have muffled the colonel’s head in his outlawed banner,
and to be pitching into him with a parasol. The one in the lavender
bonnet also performed prodigies of valour with her fists on his back.
Seeing that all was for the moment lost, I fought my desperate way hand
to hand to the lane. Through taking the back road, I was so fortunate as
to meet nobody, and arrived there uninterrupted.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Holiday Romance by Charles Dickens ​

Context of the Source ​

Holiday Romance (1868) is a lesser-known work by Charles Dickens, written late in his career. It is a collection of four whimsical, semi-autobiographical stories narrated by children, blending humor, adventure, and satire. The excerpt provided comes from the first story, "Romance. From the Pen of the Younger Norseman" (often simply called "Holiday Romance"), which follows the imaginative exploits of a group of children—including the narrator, a boy who fancies himself a "Norseman" (a Viking-like figure), and his friend "the colonel," a self-proclaimed pirate.

The story is framed as a child’s exaggerated, melodramatic account of a mock battle to "kidnap" two girls (the "Drowveys")—a playful parody of adult romantic and military tropes. Dickens, who often explored childhood perspective (e.g., in David Copperfield or Great Expectations), uses this piece to satirize both juvenile grandiosity and the absurdities of adult conventions (courtship, warfare, heroism).

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. Childhood Imagination vs. Reality

    • The children’s "battle" is a hyperbolic, theatrical performance of adult concepts (piracy, war, romance). Their "weapons" (a paper-knife, a cane with a flag) and "strategy" (a plan rolled on a hoop-stick) highlight the gap between their dramatic aspirations and the triviality of their actual means.
    • The narrator’s insistence on details (e.g., specifying which Drowvey to kidnap—"the one in spectacles, not the one with the large lavender bonnet") mimics adult precision but is comically undercut by the absurdity of the scenario.

  2. Satire of Romantic and Military Tropes

    • The "attack" parodies swashbuckling adventure stories and chivalric romances. The colonel’s "dreaded black flag" and the narrator’s orders to "seize my bride" mock the melodrama of pirate tales and knightly quests.
    • The "conquer or die" mentality is undercut by the reality: the boys are easily overpowered by girls with parasols and fists, exposing the fragility of their "heroic" posturing.

  3. Gender and Power Dynamics

    • The boys’ plan assumes dominance ("putting our brides behind us"), but the Drowveys subvert this by fighting back fiercely. The lavender-bonneted Drowvey’s "prodigies of valour" with her fists invert traditional gender roles, humorously deflating the boys’ machismo.
    • The narrator’s retreat ("fought my desperate way hand to hand to the lane") is framed as heroic, but the lack of actual resistance (he "met nobody") reveals his cowardice.

  4. Class and Social Satire

    • The Drowveys’ names (a play on "dowager," suggesting older, wealthy widows) and their accessories (spectacles, lavender bonnets) hint at upper-class pretension. The boys’ "piracy" is a childish rebellion against adult social norms, but their failure underscores the futility of their defiance.

Literary Devices ​

  1. Hyperbole and Overstatement

    • The colonel’s "active brain" and "lawless pursuit" are exaggerated to comic effect—his "plan of attack" is scribbled on paper and rolled around a hoop-stick.
    • Phrases like "conquer or die" and "prodigies of valour" inflate the stakes of a petty childhood game.

  2. Irony and Bathos

    • The shift from grand declarations ("waving the dreaded black flag") to mundane reality ("a paper-knife buttoned up under his jacket") creates bathos (anticlimax).
    • The narrator’s "full-length portrait" behind a lamp-post is undercut by his admission that his "real ears don’t stick out horizontal"—a self-aware jab at his own unreliable narration.

  3. Parody and Intertextuality

    • The scene mocks adventure serials (like those in The Penny Dreadfuls), pirate stories, and romantic comedies. The "black flag" and "brides" evoke clichés of both piracy and forced marriages in melodramas.
    • The "hoop-stick" plan parodies military strategy, reducing it to a child’s doodle.

  4. Juxtaposition

    • The contrast between the boys’ self-seriousness and the absurdity of their actions (e.g., the colonel’s head "muffled" in his own flag by a girl with a parasol) highlights the gap between perception and reality.

  5. Unreliable Narration

    • The narrator’s dramatic tone ("the eventful and appointed day") clashes with the triviality of the event, inviting readers to question his credibility. His focus on minor details (ear shape, bonnet color) betrays his childish perspective.

Significance of the Excerpt ​

  1. Dickens’ Exploration of Childhood

    • The passage captures the earnestness of children’s play, where mundane objects (a cane, a paper-knife) become props in epic narratives. Dickens, who often wrote about childhood (e.g., Oliver Twist), uses this to critique adult dismissiveness toward children’s inner lives.

  2. Critique of Adult Pretensions

    • The boys’ game mirrors adult folly—war, romance, and social posturing are revealed as performative and hollow. The Drowveys’ resistance suggests that women, often passive in such narratives, are more formidable than the boys assume.

  3. Metafictional Playfulness

    • Dickens, writing in the voice of a child, exposes the artificiality of storytelling. The narrator’s asides (about his ears) break the illusion, reminding readers that this is a constructed tale.

  4. Humor and Pathos

    • The humor lies in the disparity between the boys’ grand plans and their inept execution. Yet there’s a touch of pathos in their desperation to emulate adults, only to fail comically.

Line-by-Line Analysis ​

  1. "Under the desperate circumstances of the case..."

    • The opening mimics a military dispatch, but "desperate circumstances" are a child’s exaggerated stakes. The colonel’s "lawless pursuit" (piracy) is undercut by the absurdity of his solution: "an attack with fireworks," abandoned for being "too expensive"—a child’s practical concern.

  2. "Lightly armed with a paper-knife..."

    • The "weapons" are harmless (a paper-knife, a cane with a flag), yet the narrator describes them with gravitas. The "dreaded black flag" is a playful nod to pirate lore, but its attachment to a cane makes it ridiculous.

  3. "He had drawn out the plan of attack on a piece of paper..."

    • The "plan" is a child’s drawing, rolled around a hoop-stick (a toy). The narrator’s "full-length portrait" behind a lamp-post is a self-aggrandizing detail, immediately undermined by his ear comment—a reminder of his physical imperfections.

  4. "The enemy appeared,—approached."

    • The abrupt shift to action parodies adventure serials. The Drowveys are cast as villains, but their "prodigies of valour" (hitting the colonel with a parasol and fists) reveal the boys’ vulnerability.

  5. "Seeing that all was for the moment lost..."

    • The narrator’s retreat is framed as heroic ("fought my desperate way"), but the lack of opposition ("met nobody") exposes his cowardice. The "back road" suggests he’s avoiding conflict, not escaping it.

Conclusion: Why This Matters ​

This excerpt exemplifies Dickens’ ability to blend humor, satire, and social commentary through a child’s voice. The passage is both a celebration of childhood imagination and a critique of adult posturing. By parodying romantic and military tropes, Dickens reveals how seriously children take their play—and how absurdly adults take their own "serious" endeavors. The humor lies in the collision of grand language with petty reality, a hallmark of Dickens’ later, more experimental works.

The scene also reflects Dickens’ broader themes: the performativity of social roles, the gap between aspiration and achievement, and the resilience (or folly) of human ambition—even in its most juvenile forms. In Holiday Romance, the children’s failures are funny, but they also mirror the adult world’s own delusions of grandeur.