Article #386-1 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from Virginibus Puerisque, and Other Papers, by Robert Louis Stevenson

NOTE.—To this essay I must in honesty append a word or two of
qualification; for this is one of the points on which a slightly greater
age teaches us a slightly different wisdom:

A youth delights in generalities, and keeps loose from particular
obligations; he jogs on the footpath way, himself pursuing butterflies,
but courteously lending his applause to the advance of the human species
and the coming of the kingdom of justice and love. As he grows older, he
begins to think more narrowly of man’s action in the general, and perhaps
more arrogantly of his own in the particular. He has not that same
unspeakable trust in what he would have done had he been spared, seeing
finally that that would have been little; but he has a far higher notion
of the blank that he will make by dying. A young man feels himself one
too many in the world; his is a painful situation: he has no calling; no
obvious utility; no ties, but to his parents. and these he is sure to
disregard. I do not think that a proper allowance has been made for this
true cause of suffering in youth; but by the mere fact of a prolonged
existence, we outgrow either the fact or else the feeling. Either we
become so callously accustomed to our own useless figure in the world, or
else—and this, thank God, in the majority of cases—we so collect about us
the interest or the love of our fellows, so multiply our effective part
in the affairs of life, that we need to entertain no longer the question
of our right to be.

And so in the majority of cases, a man who fancies himself dying, will
get cold comfort from the very youthful view expressed in this essay.
He, as a living man, has some to help, some to love, some to correct; it
may be, some to punish. These duties cling, not upon humanity, but upon
the man himself. It is he, not another, who is one woman’s son and a
second woman’s husband and a third woman’s father. That life which began
so small, has now grown, with a myriad filaments, into the lives of
others. It is not indispensable; another will take the place and
shoulder the discharged responsibility; but the better the man and the
nobler his purposes, the more will he be tempted to regret the extinction
of his powers and the deletion of his personality. To have lived a
generation, is not only to have grown at home in that perplexing medium,
but to have assumed innumerable duties. To die at such an age, has, for
all but the entirely base, something of the air of a betrayal. A man
does not only reflect upon what he might have done in a future that is
never to be his; but beholding himself so early a deserter from the
fight, he eats his heart for the good he might have done already. To
have been so useless and now to lose all hope of being useful any
more—there it is that death and memory assail him. And even if mankind
shall go on, founding heroic cities, practising heroic virtues, rising
steadily from strength to strength; even if his work shall be fulfilled,
his friends consoled, his wife remarried by a better than he; how shall
this alter, in one jot, his estimation of a career which was his only
business in this world, which was so fitfully pursued, and which is now
so ineffectively to end?

Explanation

Robert Louis Stevenson’s Virginibus Puerisque (1881) is a collection of essays exploring youth, aging, love, and mortality. The title, Latin for "For Maidens and Youths," reflects its focus on the perspectives and struggles of young people, though the essays often contrast youthful idealism with the sobering realities of maturity. The excerpt provided comes from the essay "Crabbed Age and Youth" (sometimes titled "Youth and Age"), in which Stevenson reflects on the shifting self-perception of individuals as they transition from youth to middle age. Below is a detailed analysis of the passage, emphasizing its textual nuances, themes, literary devices, and significance.

Context and Overview

Stevenson wrote Virginibus Puerisque in his early 30s, a period when he was grappling with illness (he suffered from tuberculosis) and the awareness of his own mortality. The essay contrasts the carefree, abstract idealism of youth with the weighted responsibilities and regrets of adulthood. The excerpt begins with a qualification—Stevenson acknowledges that his earlier youthful views on death and purpose have evolved with age, setting the stage for a meditation on how time alters one’s relationship to existence, duty, and legacy.

Themes

Youth vs. Maturity
- Stevenson frames youth as a time of generalities and detachment: the young man is a "spectator" to life, chasing fleeting pleasures ("pursuing butterflies") while vaguely applauding grand ideals like "the kingdom of justice and love." His existence feels superfluous—he is "one too many in the world," untethered by obligations.
- Maturity, by contrast, is marked by particularity and entanglement. The older man is bound by "innumerable duties" to specific people (mother, wife, children) and recognizes his indispensability in their lives, even if he is theoretically replaceable.
The Burden of Responsibility
- Youth suffers from uselessness, but age suffers from incomplete usefulness. The young man’s pain stems from feeling irrelevant; the older man’s regret lies in the unfulfilled potential of his roles. Death becomes a "betrayal" because it severs these filaments of connection before their work is done.
- The passage underscores how identity is relational: a man is defined not just by his own actions but by his place in the lives of others ("one woman’s son and a second woman’s husband and a third woman’s father").
Mortality and Legacy
- Stevenson rejects the consolation that humanity will progress without the individual. Even if "mankind shall go on" building "heroic cities," the dying man’s personal career—his "only business in this world"—remains unfinished and ineffectual. The focus is on the subjective experience of failure, not objective progress.
- The essay critiques the Romantic idea of a "noble death" by emphasizing the mundane, personal grief of leaving tasks undone and loved ones unguided.
The Illusion of Indispensability
- While the older man recognizes that "another will take the place," he still grapples with the egoistic fear of erasure. His regret is not just for the world’s loss but for his own extinction as a conscious agent.

Literary Devices and Stylistic Features

Metaphor and Imagery
- "Filaments": The image of life growing into others like tendrils suggests organic, interconnected growth—but also fragility (filaments can be severed).
- "Deserter from the fight": Death is framed as a moral failing, a abandonment of duty, which heightens the emotional weight.
- "Eats his heart": A visceral phrase combining physical and emotional pain, evoking both hunger (for unfulfilled purpose) and self-consumption (regret).
Parallel Structure and Contrast
- Stevenson juxtaposes youth and age through parallel clauses:
  - Youth: "he has no calling; no obvious utility; no ties."
  - Age: "some to help, some to love, some to correct; it may be, some to punish."
- The shift from negation ("no") to affirmation ("some") mirrors the transition from emptiness to burdened fullness.
Rhetorical Questions and Hypotheticals
- "How shall this alter, in one jot, his estimation of a career...": The question is rhetorical, emphasizing the inevitability of personal regret despite collective progress.
- "Even if his work shall be fulfilled...": The hypothetical concedes the possibility of replacement but undermines its comfort, focusing on the individual’s irreparable loss.
Irony and Understatement
- "Thank God, in the majority of cases": The parenthetical gratitude is ironic, as the essay’s tone is largely melancholic. It acknowledges that most people do find meaning, but the focus remains on those who don’t—or who face death before they can.
- "Fitfully pursued": The adverb downplays the man’s efforts, suggesting his life was haphazard, which deepens the tragedy of its premature end.
Syntax and Pacing
- The long, winding sentences (e.g., "That life which began so small...") mimic the accumulation of duties over time, while the short, blunt clauses ("There it is that death and memory assail him") deliver the emotional punch of realization.
- The anaphora ("A man does not only reflect... but beholding himself...") builds momentum toward the climax of regret.

Significance and Interpretation

Existential Weight of Ordinary Life
- Stevenson elevates the mundane—parenthood, marriage, daily responsibilities—into matters of cosmic significance. The essay argues that meaning is found not in grand ideals (youth’s "kingdom of justice") but in specific, personal bonds.
- This aligns with Victorian anxieties about individual purpose in an industrializing, impersonal world.
Rejection of Romantic Consolation
- Unlike Romantic poets (e.g., Keats’s "When I have fears that I may cease to be"), Stevenson denies the solace of artistic or spiritual legacy. The dying man’s grief is pragmatic: he mourns the practical good he could have done, not the poems he might have written.
- The passage is anti-transcendental, grounding fear of death in earthly relationships rather than abstract immortality.
The Paradox of Maturity
- Maturity brings both connection and regret: the man is more needed but also more aware of his limitations. The "higher notion of the blank he will make by dying" is a double-edged realization—his life matters, but its end is irreversible.
- This reflects Stevenson’s own struggle with illness and his preoccupation with unfulfilled potential (he died at 44).
Universal vs. Personal Time
- The essay contrasts historical progress ("rising steadily from strength to strength") with individual finitude. The dying man’s career is his "only business", and its incompletion is unredeemable by humanity’s broader advancements.
- This tension speaks to the modern condition: how to reconcile personal meaning with the indifference of time.

Key Takeaways from the Text Itself

Youth’s Pain: The young man’s suffering is philosophical—he feels useless because he lacks ties. His identity is unformed.
Age’s Pain: The older man’s suffering is moral—he feels like a deserter because his identity is entangled with others’ needs.
The Core Fear: Not just death, but dying with one’s "business" unfinished—the gap between intention and action.
Stevenson’s Honesty: The qualification at the start ("a slightly greater age teaches us a slightly different wisdom") frames the essay as a confession of changed perspective, making the regret more poignant.

Conclusion

This excerpt is a lyrical meditation on the weight of living—how time transforms our relationship to purpose, from the lightness of youthful irrelevance to the heavy responsibility of adulthood, and finally to the bitter awareness of mortality. Stevenson’s prose weaves psychological insight with moral urgency, arguing that the true tragedy of death lies not in ceasing to exist, but in failing those who depend on us. The passage’s power lies in its unflinching realism: it offers no easy consolation, only the raw, human struggle to matter in a world that will outlast us.

Questions

Question 1

The passage suggests that the primary shift in self-perception between youth and maturity is best characterised by which of the following transformations?

A. From idealistic detachment to pragmatic resignation
B. From existential angst to stoic acceptance
C. From communal solidarity to individualistic ambition
D. From abstract moralising to concrete ethical action
E. From a sense of superfluity to an awareness of relational indebtedness

Question 2

The phrase "the blank that he will make by dying" (paragraph 2) primarily serves to underscore the older man’s:

A. fear of being forgotten by history
B. resentment toward the inevitability of mortality
C. anxiety about the moral inadequacy of his successors
D. recognition of his irreplaceable, if limited, significance to specific others
E. despair over the futility of all human endeavour

Question 3

The passage’s treatment of the "heroic cities" and "heroic virtues" (paragraph 4) functions chiefly as:

A. a rhetorical concession that ultimately fails to mitigate the individual’s sense of personal failure
B. an ironic critique of societal progress as a hollow substitute for individual achievement
C. a reassuring counterpoint to the dying man’s regret, emphasising continuity over loss
D. a metaphorical extension of the "filaments" imagery, suggesting collective growth as organic and inevitable
E. an invocation of classical ideals to elevate the man’s private struggles to a universal scale

Question 4

Which of the following best captures the logical relationship between the two bolded statements in the passage? I. "A young man feels himself one too many in the world; his is a painful situation: he has no calling; no obvious utility; no ties."II. "To die at such an age, has, for all but the entirely base, something of the air of a betrayal."

A. II presents a direct contradiction of I by asserting that death in youth is morally worse than living.
B. II reframes the suffering described in I as a moral failing rather than an existential condition.
C. II extends the logic of I by arguing that the young man’s uselessness is compounded by premature death.
D. II inverts the perspective of I: where I laments uselessness in life, II laments the loss of potential usefulness in death.
E. II dismisses the concerns of I as trivial compared to the gravitas of facing mortality.

Question 5

The passage’s closing lines—"how shall this alter, in one jot, his estimation of a career which was his only business in this world, which was so fitfully pursued, and which is now so ineffectively to end?"—primarily serve to:

A. condemn the man’s lack of discipline in pursuing his goals
B. suggest that objective progress is irrelevant to subjective regret
C. imply that the man’s career was inherently flawed from its inception
D. contrast the certainty of death with the uncertainty of life’s purpose
E. assert that personal failure cannot be redeemed by external consolation

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: E

Why E is most correct: The passage explicitly contrasts the young man’s sense of being "one too many in the world" (a feeling of superfluity) with the older man’s recognition that his life has "grown, with a myriad filaments, into the lives of others." This shift is not merely about resignation (A) or action (D), but about the relational indebtedness—the duties and ties that bind him to specific individuals (e.g., as son, husband, father). The older man’s regret stems from the betrayal of these obligations, not just his own unfulfilled potential.