Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The House Behind the Cedars, by Charles W. Chesnutt

Some such trite reflection--as apposite to the subject as most random
reflections are--passed through the mind of a young man who came out of
the front door of the Patesville Hotel about nine o'clock one fine
morning in spring, a few years after the Civil War, and started down
Front Street toward the market-house. Arriving at the town late the
previous evening, he had been driven up from the steamboat in a
carriage, from which he had been able to distinguish only the shadowy
outlines of the houses along the street; so that this morning walk was
his first opportunity to see the town by daylight. He was dressed in a
suit of linen duck--the day was warm--a panama straw hat, and patent
leather shoes. In appearance he was tall, dark, with straight, black,
lustrous hair, and very clean-cut, high-bred features. When he paused
by the clerk's desk on his way out, to light his cigar, the day clerk,
who had just come on duty, glanced at the register and read the last
entry:--

 "'JOHN WARWICK, CLARENCE, SOUTH CAROLINA.'

"One of the South Ca'lina bigbugs, I reckon--probably in cotton, or
turpentine." The gentleman from South Carolina, walking down the
street, glanced about him with an eager look, in which curiosity and
affection were mingled with a touch of bitterness. He saw little that
was not familiar, or that he had not seen in his dreams a hundred times
during the past ten years. There had been some changes, it is true,
some melancholy changes, but scarcely anything by way of addition or
improvement to counterbalance them. Here and there blackened and
dismantled walls marked the place where handsome buildings once had
stood, for Sherman's march to the sea had left its mark upon the town.
The stores were mostly of brick, two stories high, joining one another
after the manner of cities. Some of the names on the signs were
familiar; others, including a number of Jewish names, were quite
unknown to him.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The House Behind the Cedars by Charles W. Chesnutt ​

Context of the Source ​

The House Behind the Cedars (1900) is a novel by Charles W. Chesnutt, an African American writer of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Chesnutt, a mixed-race man who could "pass" as white, often explored themes of racial identity, passing, and the legacy of slavery in the post-Civil War South. This novel follows John Warwick, a light-skinned Black man who has been living as a white man in the North but returns to his Southern hometown, Patesville (a fictionalized version of Fayetteville, North Carolina). The excerpt introduces John as he arrives in town, observing the changes wrought by the Civil War and Reconstruction.

The novel is part of the African American literary tradition that examines the psychological and social consequences of racial passing, a theme also explored in works like Nella Larsen’s Passing (1929) and James Weldon Johnson’s The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man (1912). Chesnutt’s work is significant because it challenges racial binaries and exposes the hypocrisy of Jim Crow-era America, where racial identity was often a matter of perception rather than biology.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. The Illusion of Progress in the Post-War South

    • The excerpt opens with John Warwick observing Patesville, a town still scarred by Sherman’s March to the Sea (1864–65), a Union campaign that devastated the Confederate South.
    • The "blackened and dismantled walls" symbolize the physical and economic ruin left by the war, while the "melancholy changes" suggest that Reconstruction has not brought true renewal.
    • The presence of "Jewish names" on storefronts hints at economic shifts—Northern merchants (often Jewish) moving into the South post-war, replacing the old Southern elite.

  2. Racial Passing and Identity

    • John Warwick is light-skinned enough to pass as white, and the hotel clerk assumes he is a "South Ca'lina bigbug" (a wealthy white Southerner).
    • His clothing (linen suit, Panama hat, patent leather shoes) signals wealth and refinement, reinforcing the illusion of whiteness.
    • His "eager look, in which curiosity and affection were mingled with a touch of bitterness" suggests conflicted emotions—nostalgia for home, but also resentment toward the racial oppression that once defined his life there.

  3. Memory and Displacement

    • John recognizes the town from "his dreams a hundred times during the past ten years", implying he has been haunted by his past while living as a white man elsewhere.
    • The familiar yet changed landscape mirrors his own internal conflict—he is both an insider (a native Southerner) and an outsider (now passing as white).

  4. The Myth of the "New South"

    • The text subtly critiques the idea of Southern recovery after the war. While some stores remain, the absence of "addition or improvement" suggests stagnation rather than progress.
    • The economic shift (Jewish merchants replacing old Southern families) reflects the displacement of the plantation aristocracy, but not necessarily an improvement for Black Southerners.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Free Indirect Discourse

    • The narrator blends John’s thoughts with third-person observation, creating intimacy.
    • Example: "Some such trite reflection... passed through the mind of a young man"—this phrasing suggests John’s detached, almost ironic perspective on his own thoughts.

  2. Symbolism

    • The "blackened and dismantled walls" = the destruction of the Old South, but also the incomplete reconstruction of society.
    • John’s clothing = a mask of whiteness, concealing his true identity.
    • The "market-house" = a place of commerce and slavery auctions, linking past and present economic systems.

  3. Irony

    • The clerk’s assumption that John is a "bigbug... probably in cotton, or turpentine" is doubly ironic:
      • John is not white, despite appearances.
      • His family’s wealth likely came from cotton—produced by enslaved people, a system he now rejects.
    • The "fine morning in spring" contrasts with the melancholy ruins, highlighting the gap between nature’s renewal and human stagnation.

  4. Imagery & Sensory Details

    • Visual: The "shadowy outlines" of houses at night vs. the harsh daylight reality of ruin.
    • Tactile: The "warm" day contrasts with the cold reality of racial divisions.
    • Emotional: The "touch of bitterness" in John’s gaze suggests unresolved trauma.

  5. Foreshadowing

    • John’s conflicted emotions (curiosity, affection, bitterness) foreshadow his internal struggle—will he reclaim his Black identity or continue passing?
    • The absence of improvement in Patesville hints that racial progress is equally stalled.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. Historical Realism

    • Chesnutt accurately depicts the post-Civil War South, where physical reconstruction (rebuilding towns) did not equal social reconstruction (racial equality).
    • The economic shifts (Jewish merchants, new names on stores) reflect the rise of a new commercial class replacing the old slaveholding elite.

  2. Psychological Depth of Passing

    • John’s observant, detached demeanor masks deep emotional turmoil.
    • His return to Patesville is not just a homecoming but a confrontation with his past and identity.

  3. Critique of Racial Performativity

    • The scene exposes how race is performed—John’s clothing, mannerisms, and even his name ("Warwick") are tools of passing.
    • The clerk’s immediate racial assumption shows how whiteness is a default privilege, while Blackness is erased or ignored.

  4. The Unreliable Narrative of Progress

    • The "fine morning in spring" suggests hope, but the ruined buildings undermine it.
    • Chesnutt challenges the "New South" narrative, which claimed the region was moving forward while racial oppression persisted.

Conclusion: Why This Excerpt Matters ​

This passage is a microcosm of the novel’s central tensions:

  • Personal vs. Public Identity (John’s passing)
  • Memory vs. Reality (the town as he remembers it vs. how it is now)
  • Progress vs. Stagnation (the illusion of a "New South")

Chesnutt does not romanticize the past or the present—instead, he exposes the contradictions of a society still grappling with race. John Warwick’s walk through Patesville is not just a physical journey but a psychological one, forcing him (and the reader) to confront the cost of racial passing and the lingering scars of slavery.

The excerpt sets the stage for the novel’s exploration of race, class, and identity, making it a powerful introduction to Chesnutt’s critique of post-Reconstruction America.