Article #178-2 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from Confidence, by Henry James

by Henry James

CHAPTER I

It was in the early days of April; Bernard Longueville had been spending
the winter in Rome. He had travelled northward with the consciousness of
several social duties that appealed to him from the further side of the
Alps, but he was under the charm of the Italian spring, and he made a
pretext for lingering. He had spent five days at Siena, where he had
intended to spend but two, and still it was impossible to continue his
journey. He was a young man of a contemplative and speculative turn, and
this was his first visit to Italy, so that if he dallied by the way he
should not be harshly judged. He had a fancy for sketching, and it was
on his conscience to take a few pictorial notes. There were two old
inns at Siena, both of them very shabby and very dirty. The one at which
Longueville had taken up his abode was entered by a dark, pestiferous
arch-way, surmounted by a sign which at a distance might have been read
by the travellers as the Dantean injunction to renounce all hope. The
other was not far off, and the day after his arrival, as he passed
it, he saw two ladies going in who evidently belonged to the large
fraternity of Anglo-Saxon tourists, and one of whom was young and
carried herself very well. Longueville had his share--or more than his
share--of gallantry, and this incident awakened a regret. If he had
gone to the other inn he might have had charming company: at his own
establishment there was no one but an aesthetic German who smoked bad
tobacco in the dining-room. He remarked to himself that this was always
his luck, and the remark was characteristic of the man; it was charged
with the feeling of the moment, but it was not absolutely just; it was
the result of an acute impression made by the particular occasion;
but it failed in appreciation of a providence which had sprinkled
Longueville’s career with happy accidents--accidents, especially, in
which his characteristic gallantry was not allowed to rust for want of
exercise. He lounged, however, contentedly enough through these bright,
still days of a Tuscan April, drawing much entertainment from the high
picturesqueness of the things about him. Siena, a few years since, was
a flawless gift of the Middle Ages to the modern imagination. No other
Italian city could have been more interesting to an observer fond
of reconstructing obsolete manners. This was a taste of Bernard
Longueville’s, who had a relish for serious literature, and at one time
had made several lively excursions into mediaeval history. His friends
thought him very clever, and at the same time had an easy feeling about
him which was a tribute to his freedom from pedantry. He was clever
indeed, and an excellent companion; but the real measure of his
brilliancy was in the success with which he entertained himself. He was
much addicted to conversing with his own wit, and he greatly enjoyed his
own society. Clever as he often was in talking with his friends, I am
not sure that his best things, as the phrase is, were not for his
own ears. And this was not on account of any cynical contempt for the
understanding of his fellow-creatures: it was simply because what I have
called his own society was more of a stimulus than that of most other
people. And yet he was not for this reason fond of solitude; he was, on
the contrary, a very sociable animal. It must be admitted at the outset
that he had a nature which seemed at several points to contradict
itself, as will probably be perceived in the course of this narration.

Explanation

**Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Confidence by Henry James**

Henry James’s Confidence (1879) is a novel of manners, romance, and psychological subtlety, exploring themes of love, deception, social performance, and self-awareness. The excerpt from Chapter I introduces the protagonist, Bernard Longueville, a young American man of leisure traveling in Italy. The passage establishes his character, his relationship with his surroundings, and the narrative’s tone—observant, ironic, and psychologically nuanced. Below is a close reading of the text, focusing on its themes, literary devices, character portrayal, and significance within the broader context of James’s work.

1. Context of the Excerpt

Confidence is one of James’s earlier novels, written during his expatriate years in Europe. It reflects his fascination with:

The "international theme" (the cultural and social tensions between Americans and Europeans).
The psychology of perception (how characters observe and misinterpret one another).
The aesthetics of travel and art (Italy as a space of romantic and intellectual inspiration).

The novel follows Bernard Longueville and his friend Gordon Wright as they navigate love, friendship, and the complexities of social performance. The excerpt introduces Bernard in Siena, a medieval Italian city that serves as a backdrop for his introspective, somewhat self-absorbed nature.

2. Themes in the Excerpt

A. The Flâneur and the Aesthetic Traveler

Bernard is a contemplative observer, a type James often explores—the American abroad who is both enchanted and detached from European culture. His lingering in Siena (despite social obligations) suggests:

A romantic attachment to Italy as a land of beauty and history ("the Italian spring," "the high picturesqueness of the things about him").
A resistance to duty—he is supposed to be traveling north for "social duties," but he indulges in artistic and intellectual pleasures instead.
The flâneur’s gaze: He sketches, reconstructs "obsolete manners," and derives entertainment from his surroundings rather than human interaction.

This aligns with 19th-century aestheticism (e.g., Walter Pater’s idea of art for art’s sake) and the Grand Tour tradition, where young men of means traveled Europe to cultivate taste.

B. Self-Awareness and Self-Contradiction

James introduces Bernard as a man of paradoxes:

He is "sociable" yet enjoys his own company more than others’.
He is "clever" but not pedantic—his intelligence is playful, self-amusing.
He regrets missing social opportunities (the two ladies at the other inn) but is content in solitude.
He fancies himself unlucky in love ("this was always his luck") but has actually had many "happy accidents."

This self-contradiction is key to James’s characterization—Bernard is introspective but not entirely self-aware. He narrates his own life with wit, yet his observations are selective, ignoring his own privileges (e.g., his ability to linger in Italy while others must rush).

C. The Illusion of Control and Chance

Bernard believes himself at the mercy of fate ("this was always his luck"), yet the narrator undermines this:

His "providence" has actually given him many opportunities for gallantry (contradicting his self-pity).
His delay in Siena is framed as passive ("it was impossible to continue his journey"), but it’s really a choice—he prefers aesthetic pleasure over duty.

This tension between agency and passivity is a recurring Jamesian theme. Characters often believe they are acting freely, but their actions are shaped by social expectations, personal whims, or unseen forces.

D. The Role of the Observer vs. the Participant

Bernard is more comfortable as an observer than a participant:

He sketches (taking "pictorial notes") rather than engaging deeply with people.
He reconstructs medieval history in his mind but does not fully immerse himself in the present.
His regret about the two ladies is more about missed narrative potential ("charming company") than genuine longing.

This reflects James’s own authorial stance—he was a master of psychological realism, where characters are both subjects and objects of observation.

3. Literary Devices and Style

James’s prose is dense, nuanced, and layered with irony. Key devices in this excerpt:

A. Free Indirect Discourse

James blends Bernard’s thoughts with the narrator’s voice, creating a subjective yet ironic perspective:

"He had a fancy for sketching, and it was on his conscience to take a few pictorial notes." → The phrase "on his conscience" is Bernard’s self-justification, but the narrator’s tone suggests it’s a light obligation, not a true moral burden.
"He remarked to himself that this was always his luck, and the remark was characteristic of the man..." → The narrator undermines Bernard’s self-pity by pointing out his actual good fortune.

This technique exposes the gap between how Bernard sees himself and how he is seen.

B. Irony and Understatement

Bernard’s inn is described as "shabby and dirty," yet he stays there by choice, romanticizing his solitude.
The Dantean reference ("renounce all hope") is darkly humorous—the inn is hardly Hell, but Bernard enjoys the dramatic framing.
His regret about the ladies is undercut by the fact that he does nothing to seek them out.

James often uses irony to reveal character flaws—Bernard’s self-satisfaction is gently mocked.

C. Imagery and Symbolism

Siena as a Medieval Relic: The city is a "flawless gift of the Middle Ages", symbolizing Bernard’s romantic, historical imagination. He prefers the past to the present, aesthetics to real human connection.
The Two Inns: Represent choice and missed opportunity. The other inn (with the ladies) symbolizes social engagement, while Bernard’s inn (with the "aesthetic German") represents isolation and self-indulgence.
Sketching as Metaphor: His "pictorial notes" suggest that he views life as a composition, something to be framed and observed, not lived spontaneously.

D. Psychological Realism

James excels at rendering the fluctuations of consciousness:

Bernard’s mood shifts—from contentment to regret to self-justification—are naturalistic.
His internal monologue reveals his vanity ("his best things were for his own ears") and self-deception (he thinks himself unlucky despite evidence to the contrary).

This stream-of-consciousness-like style was innovative for the time, influencing later modernists like Woolf and Joyce.

4. Significance of the Excerpt

A. Introduction to Bernard’s Character

This passage establishes Bernard as:

A man of leisure and taste, but also self-absorbed.
Charming but unreliable—his gallantry is performative.
More interested in the idea of love than its reality (his regret is aesthetic, not emotional).

His contradictions foreshadow his later romantic entanglements, where his indecisiveness and self-regard will create complications.

**B. Themes That Recur in Confidence and James’s Work**

The American in Europe: Bernard embodies the cultural and social ambiguities of Americans abroad—both enchanted and detached from European life.
The Gap Between Appearance and Reality: Bernard sees himself as unlucky, but the narrator reveals his actual privilege.
The Art of Observation vs. Participation: James often contrasts those who watch life (like Bernard) with those who live it (like the more impulsive characters he will encounter).
The Role of Chance and Choice: Bernard frames his delays as fate, but they are deliberate choices, reflecting James’s interest in how people narrate their own lives.

C. Connection to James’s Broader Oeuvre

The "International Novel": Like Daisy Miller (1878) and The Portrait of a Lady (1881), Confidence explores cultural clashes and the American expatriate experience.
Psychological Depth: James’s focus on inner conflict and self-deception anticipates his later masterpieces (The Wings of the Dove, The Golden Bowl).
The Unreliable Narrator: While not first-person, the narrator’s ironic distance from Bernard’s perspective creates a layered, ambiguous storytelling style.

5. Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters

This excerpt is a masterclass in character introduction. In just a few paragraphs, James:

Establishes Bernard’s personality—clever, sociable, but ultimately self-centered.
Sets the novel’s tone—observant, ironic, psychologically acute.
Introduces key themes—the tension between aesthetic pleasure and social duty, the illusion of control, and the gap between self-perception and reality.
Foreshadows the novel’s conflicts—Bernard’s indecisiveness and love of performance will drive the plot.

James’s subtle prose rewards close reading. The passage seems simple—a man lingering in Italy—but it is rich with implication, revealing as much about human nature as it does about Bernard Longueville.

Final Thought

Bernard is both a product of his time (a leisureed American tourist in Europe) and a timeless type—the intelligent but flawed observer who prefers the idea of life to its messier realities. His charm and self-deception make him a compelling protagonist, and James’s ironic, psychologically precise narration ensures that we see him more clearly than he sees himself.

This dynamic—between how we present ourselves and how we are truly seen—is at the heart of Confidence and much of James’s greatest work.

Questions

Question 1

The passage’s depiction of Bernard Longueville’s regret over missing the "charming company" of the two ladies primarily serves to:

A. illustrate his genuine longing for romantic connection, which his solitary habits have thus far denied him.
B. expose the superficiality of his social desires, as his regret is fleeting and does not prompt any action.
C. contrast his aesthetic sensibilities with the practical concerns of the Anglo-Saxon tourists.
D. highlight the inferiority of his current lodging, which lacks the refinement he associates with female companionship.
E. reveal his tendency to dramatize minor disappointments as emblematic of a broader, self-mythologizing narrative about his own misfortune.

Question 2

The narrator’s assertion that Bernard’s remark about his "luck" is "characteristic of the man" is best understood as an example of:

A. dramatic irony, since the reader knows Bernard’s social life is far more successful than he admits.
B. direct characterization, as the narrator explicitly labels Bernard’s habit of self-pity.
C. stream-of-consciousness technique, blending Bernard’s voice with the narrator’s omniscience.
D. indirect characterization, where the narrator’s phrasing undermines Bernard’s self-perception while appearing to endorse it.
E. authorial intrusion, where James steps outside the narrative to moralize about Bernard’s flaws.

Question 3

The "aesthetic German who smoked bad tobacco" functions in the passage primarily as:

A. a symbolic representation of the artistic but socially inept European, contrasting with Bernard’s American charm.
B. a narrative device to emphasize the squalor of Bernard’s inn, reinforcing his justification for lingering.
C. a foil to the Anglo-Saxon ladies, underscoring the cultural divide between Continental and Anglo tourists.
D. a subtle indictment of Bernard’s selective sociability, as he tolerates the German’s presence without seeking better company.
E. an allegorical figure for the decay of medieval Europe, mirroring Siena’s "flawless gift" to modernity.

Question 4

Bernard’s "lively excursions into mediaeval history" are most closely analogous to his:

A. sketching, as both are attempts to preserve the past in a tangible, artistic form.
B. lingering in Siena, in that both reflect a preference for reconstructed romance over present obligations.
C. regret over the two ladies, since both stem from an idealized vision of what might have been.
D. conversation with his own wit, as both are solitary, self-amusing intellectual exercises.
E. gallantry, because they demonstrate his performative engagement with cultural expectations.

Question 5

The passage’s closing observation—that Bernard’s nature "seemed at several points to contradict itself"—is thematically resonant with the broader novel Confidence in its exploration of:

A. the tension between American pragmatism and European romanticism.
B. the unreliability of first-person narration in psychological realism.
C. the ways in which social performance masks true intention.
D. the conflict between artistic temperament and bourgeois responsibility.
E. the gap between self-perception and external reality, particularly in matters of love and social identity.

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: E

Why E is most correct: The passage emphasizes Bernard’s habit of transforming minor setbacks into a grander narrative of personal misfortune ("this was always his luck"). His regret over the ladies is not genuine longing (A) but a momentary, performative lament that aligns with his self-mythologizing tendency. The narrator undermines this by noting his actual "happy accidents," making E the most defensible choice. The regret is theatrical, not substantive, and fits his pattern of dramatizing trivial disappointments to reinforce a self-image of being star-crossed.