Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Captain of the Polestar, and Other Tales, by Arthur Conan Doyle

 [Being an extract from the singular journal of JOHN<br />
 M’ALISTER RAY, student of medicine.]

September 11th.--Lat. 81 degrees 40’ N.; long. 2 degrees E. Still
lying-to amid enormous ice fields. The one which stretches away to the
north of us, and to which our ice-anchor is attached, cannot be smaller
than an English county. To the right and left unbroken sheets extend
to the horizon. This morning the mate reported that there were signs of
pack ice to the southward. Should this form of sufficient thickness
to bar our return, we shall be in a position of danger, as the food, I
hear, is already running somewhat short. It is late in the season, and
the nights are beginning to reappear.

This morning I saw a star twinkling just over the fore-yard, the first
since the beginning of May. There is considerable discontent among the
crew, many of whom are anxious to get back home to be in time for the
herring season, when labour always commands a high price upon the Scotch
coast. As yet their displeasure is only signified by sullen countenances
and black looks, but I heard from the second mate this afternoon that
they contemplated sending a deputation to the Captain to explain their
grievance. I much doubt how he will receive it, as he is a man of fierce
temper, and very sensitive about anything approaching to an infringement
of his rights. I shall venture after dinner to say a few words to him
upon the subject. I have always found that he will tolerate from me what
he would resent from any other member of the crew. Amsterdam Island,
at the north-west corner of Spitzbergen, is visible upon our starboard
quarter--a rugged line of volcanic rocks, intersected by white seams,
which represent glaciers. It is curious to think that at the present
moment there is probably no human being nearer to us than the Danish
settlements in the south of Greenland--a good nine hundred miles as the
crow flies. A captain takes a great responsibility upon himself when he
risks his vessel under such circumstances. No whaler has ever remained
in these latitudes till so advanced a period of the year.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Captain of the Polestar, and Other Tales by Arthur Conan Doyle ​

Context of the Source ​

The Captain of the Polestar, and Other Tales (1890) is a collection of short stories by Arthur Conan Doyle, best known as the creator of Sherlock Holmes. While Doyle is primarily associated with detective fiction, he also wrote adventure, horror, and maritime tales. "The Captain of the Polestar" (from which this excerpt is taken) is a gothic horror story set in the Arctic, blending elements of psychological tension, supernatural mystery, and the harsh realities of 19th-century whaling expeditions.

The story is presented as a found manuscript—the journal of John M’Alister Ray, a medical student serving as a ship’s surgeon aboard a whaling vessel. This framing device adds authenticity and immediacy, making the narrative feel like a firsthand account. The excerpt provided is an early entry, establishing the setting, mood, and emerging conflicts aboard the ship.

Analysis of the Excerpt ​

1. Setting and Atmosphere ​

The passage opens with a precise geographical and temporal setting:

  • Latitude 81°40’ N, Longitude 2°E – The ship is deep in the Arctic, near Spitzbergen (Svalbard), an archipelago known for its treacherous ice and isolation.
  • Late in the season (September 11th) – The crew is lingering dangerously late in polar waters, where winter is approaching, and ice is reforming.
  • "The nights are beginning to reappear" – A reference to the polar night, when the sun remains below the horizon for months, plunging the region into darkness.

The descriptions of ice are vivid and oppressive:

  • The ice field is "not smaller than an English county" – A staggering comparison that emphasizes the vast, inescapable nature of the Arctic.
  • "Unbroken sheets extend to the horizon" – The ice is not just a barrier but a prison, reinforcing the crew’s entrapment.
  • "Signs of pack ice to the southward" – If the ice thickens, the ship may be trapped, cutting off any chance of escape.

This claustrophobic, desolate setting is a hallmark of Arctic horror, a subgenre that exploits the psychological terror of isolation (seen also in works like Frankenstein and The Terror by Dan Simmons).

2. Foreshadowing and Tension ​

The excerpt hints at multiple impending crises:

  • Food shortages – The crew is already running low on supplies, a practical threat that could lead to mutiny or starvation.
  • Crew discontent – The men are anxious to return for the herring season, where they can earn high wages. Their sullen looks and plans to confront the captain suggest brewing conflict.
  • The captain’s volatile temper – He is "a man of fierce temper, sensitive about infringements of his rights", implying that any challenge to his authority could escalate violently.

The first star in months is a small but symbolic detail:

  • Stars were crucial for navigation, but their reappearance also marks the return of darkness, both literally (the polar night) and metaphorically (the crew’s growing despair).
  • The star could also foreshadow supernatural elements later in the story (Doyle often blends realism with the uncanny).

3. Themes ​

Several key themes emerge in this passage:

  • Isolation and Entrapment – The ship is surrounded by ice, with no hope of rescue. The mention of Amsterdam Island (a barren, volcanic rock) and the 900-mile distance to Greenland underscores their extreme remoteness.
  • Human vs. Nature – The Arctic is an indifferent, hostile force. The captain’s decision to stay so late in the season is a gamble with nature’s wrath.
  • Authority and Mutiny – The captain’s tyrannical leadership contrasts with the crew’s growing resentment, setting up a potential power struggle.
  • Economic Pressure – The men’s desire to return for the herring season reflects the harsh economic realities of 19th-century whalers, who risked their lives for meager wages.

4. Literary Devices ​

Doyle employs several stylistic and narrative techniques to enhance the passage’s impact:

  • Journal Format – The first-person, diary-style narration creates immediacy and intimacy, making the reader feel as if they are experiencing the events alongside Ray.
  • Precise, Technical Language – Terms like "lying-to" (a sailing maneuver), "ice-anchor", and "pack ice" ground the story in realistic maritime detail, adding authenticity.
  • Imagery of Confinement – Phrases like "unbroken sheets of ice" and "no human being nearer" reinforce the sense of being trapped.
  • Foreshadowing Through Dialogue – The second mate’s warning about the crew’s planned deputation hints at future conflict.
  • Juxtaposition of Beauty and Danger – The "white seams" of glaciers on the volcanic rocks are visually striking but also deadly, mirroring the Arctic’s dual nature as both majestic and lethal.

5. Significance of the Passage ​

This excerpt serves multiple purposes in the story:

  1. Establishes the Arctic as a Character – The ice is not just a setting but an active, malevolent force that will shape the crew’s fate.
  2. Introduces Key Conflicts –
    • Man vs. Nature (the ice, the coming winter)
    • Man vs. Man (crew vs. captain)
    • Man vs. Himself (Ray’s role as a mediator, his observations hinting at deeper anxieties)
  3. Sets Up the Supernatural – While this entry is grounded in realism, later entries in the journal descend into madness and ghostly visions, making this early passage a baseline of sanity before the horror unfolds.
  4. Reflects 19th-Century Whaling Realities – The economic pressures, the captain’s authority, and the perils of Arctic exploration were real concerns for whalers, adding historical weight to the fiction.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is a masterclass in slow-building tension. Doyle uses realistic details to create an atmosphere of dread, where the true horror is not yet supernatural but the creeping realization of helplessness. The isolation, the ice, the captain’s temper, and the crew’s discontent all converge to form a pressure cooker of anxiety, setting the stage for the psychological and supernatural horrors to come.

By framing the story as a journal, Doyle also blurs the line between fact and fiction, making the reader question: Is this a true account? Is Ray a reliable narrator? This uncertainty enhances the uncanny, a technique that would later define his Sherlock Holmes mysteries—where logic and the irrational often collide.

In essence, this passage is not just about a ship trapped in ice—it’s about the fragility of human control in the face of nature’s indifference, and the thin line between order and chaos.