Article #306-1 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from The Early Short Fiction of Edith Wharton — Part 2, by Edith Wharton

As Tony advanced in years and experience this childish mumming lost
its magic; but not so the early imaginings it had excited. For the old
picture had been but the spring-board of fancy, the first step of a
cloud-ladder leading to a land of dreams. With these dreams the name
of Venice remained associated; and all that observation or report
subsequently brought him concerning the place seemed, on a sober
warranty of fact, to confirm its claim to stand midway between
reality and illusion. There was, for instance, a slender Venice glass,
gold-powdered as with lily-pollen or the dust of sunbeams, that,
standing in the corner cabinet betwixt two Lowestoft caddies, seemed,
among its lifeless neighbours, to palpitate like an impaled butterfly.
There was, farther, a gold chain of his mother’s, spun of that same
sun-pollen, so thread-like, impalpable, that it slipped through the
fingers like light, yet so strong that it carried a heavy pendant which
seemed held in air as if by magic. MAGIC! That was the word which the
thought of Venice evoked. It was the kind of place, Tony felt, in which
things elsewhere impossible might naturally happen, in which two and two
might make five, a paradox elope with a syllogism, and a conclusion give
the lie to its own premiss. Was there ever a young heart that did not,
once and again, long to get away into such a world as that? Tony, at
least, had felt the longing from the first hour when the axioms in
his horn-book had brought home to him his heavy responsibilities as a
Christian and a sinner. And now here was his wish taking shape before
him, as the distant haze of gold shaped itself into towers and domes
across the morning sea!

The Reverend Ozias Mounce, Tony’s governor and bear-leader, was just
putting a hand to the third clause of the fourth part of a sermon
on Free-Will and Predestination as the Hepzibah B.’s anchor rattled
overboard. Tony, in his haste to be ashore, would have made one plunge
with the anchor; but the Reverend Ozias, on being roused from his
lucubrations, earnestly protested against leaving his argument in
suspense. What was the trifle of an arrival at some Papistical
foreign city, where the very churches wore turbans like so many
Moslem idolators, to the important fact of Mr. Mounce’s summing up his
conclusions before the Muse of Theology took flight? He should be happy,
he said, if the tide served, to visit Venice with Mr. Bracknell the next
morning.

The next morning, ha!--Tony murmured a submissive “Yes, sir,” winked at
the subjugated captain, buckled on his sword, pressed his hat down
with a flourish, and before the Reverend Ozias had arrived at his next
deduction, was skimming merrily shoreward in the Hepzibah’s gig.

Explanation

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Early Short Fiction of Edith Wharton

Context & Source

This passage is from Edith Wharton’s early short fiction, likely part of a story (possibly "The Pelican" or another unpublished work) that explores themes of youthful idealism, escapism, and the clash between rigid doctrine and imaginative freedom. Wharton, known for her sharp social commentary and psychological depth (The Age of Innocence, Ethan Frome), often contrasted stifling societal expectations with the longing for beauty and transcendence. Here, she portrays a young man, Tony, whose romanticized vision of Venice symbolizes his desire to escape the oppressive intellectual and religious constraints imposed by his guardian, the Reverend Ozias Mounce.

Themes

Escapism & the Power of Imagination
- Tony’s childhood fascination with Venice is not just nostalgia but a metaphor for freedom. The city represents a realm where logic is suspended ("two and two might make five"), and magic—both literal and metaphorical—reigns. His longing reflects a universal youthful desire to break free from dogma (here, the "axioms in his horn-book" that burden him as a "Christian and a sinner").
- The Venetian glass and gold chain symbolize this magic: they are fragile yet enduring, defying physical laws (the chain holds a heavy pendant "as if by magic"). These objects embody Venice’s dual nature—both real and illusory, like Tony’s dreams.
Religious Dogma vs. Personal Freedom
- The Reverend Mounce embodies Puritanical rigidity. His sermon on Free-Will and Predestination (a Calvinist paradox) mirrors his control over Tony. Mounce dismisses Venice as a "Papistical foreign city" with "churches [wearing] turbans," framing it as heretical and exotic—a threat to his doctrinal worldview.
- Tony’s rebellion (sneaking ashore) is a rejection of Mounce’s authority. His winking at the "subjugated captain" and dramatic exit ("buckled on his sword") frame his escape as a chivalric quest, contrasting Mounce’s dry theology with romantic adventure.
The Illusion of Paradise
- Venice is described as a liminal space ("midway between reality and illusion"), a place where contradictions coexist. Wharton critiques the danger of idealization: Tony’s Venice is a projection of his desires, not the real city. His arrival may shatter the illusion, but the passage focuses on the ecstasy of anticipation—the moment before disillusionment.
Youth vs. Age
- Tony’s youthful vitality ("skimming merrily shoreward") opposes Mounce’s stagnation (lost in his "lucubrations," or pedantic writings). The generational clash highlights how institutional authority (religion, education) often stifles creativity.

Literary Devices

Imagery & Symbolism
- Venice as a Dream: Described via golden, ethereal imagery ("gold-powdered glass," "sun-pollen," "dust of sunbeams"). The butterfly (impaled yet palpitating) suggests beauty trapped by reality—a foreshadowing of Tony’s potential disillusionment.
- The Chain & Glass: Symbolize fragile strength—like Tony’s dreams, they seem insubstantial but endure. The chain’s magic ("held in air") mirrors Venice’s defiance of logic.
- Turbans on Churches: Mounce’s xenophobic metaphor (Venice as "Moslem idolators") reveals his bigotry and fear of the exotic.
Contrast & Juxtaposition
- Magic vs. Dogma: Tony’s Venice ("things elsewhere impossible might happen") vs. Mounce’s sermon ("Free-Will and Predestination").
- Movement vs. Stasis: Tony’s dynamic escape ("skimming merrily") vs. Mounce’s static intellectualizing ("putting a hand to the third clause").
- Light vs. Darkness: The golden haze of Venice vs. the heavy responsibilities of Tony’s upbringing.
Tone & Diction
- Whimsical & Lyrical: Descriptions of Venice use poetic diction ("cloud-ladder," "palpitate like an impaled butterfly") to evoke wonder.
- Satirical: Mounce’s dialogue is pomposity personified ("the Muse of Theology took flight"). His dismissal of Venice as "Papistical" underscores his narrow-mindedness.
- Irony: Tony’s submissive "Yes, sir" masks his defiance, highlighting the performative nature of obedience.
Foreshadowing
- The butterfly’s palpitation hints at Tony’s vulnerability—his dreams may be as fragile as the glass.
- The anchor’s rattle symbolizes both arrival and constraint, suggesting Tony’s escape may be temporary.

Significance of the Passage

Psychological Realism Wharton captures the universal adolescent struggle between conformity and self-discovery. Tony’s Venice is a personal myth, a coping mechanism against the weight of expectation (religious, social).
Critique of Puritanism Mounce represents doctrinaire oppression, a common Wharton target. His dismissal of Venice as "Papistical" reflects 19th-century Protestant distrust of Catholicism, which Wharton (a skeptic of dogma) critiques as life-denying.
The Art of Illusion The passage explores how beauty and meaning are constructed. Venice’s magic exists because Tony believes in it—Wharton questions whether such illusions are necessary for survival or delusions to be outgrown.
Narrative Tension The clash between Tony and Mounce sets up a coming-of-age conflict. Will Tony’s Venice survive contact with reality? Wharton often denies her characters happy endings, suggesting his dreams may dissolve—like the "distant haze of gold" solidifying into mere "towers and domes."

Line-by-Line Analysis of Key Moments

"the old picture had been but the spring-board of fancy"
- Tony’s childhood image of Venice was a catalyst, not the destination. His imagination transcended the original, showing how art (or memory) spawns greater dreams.
"a gold chain... spun of that same sun-pollen, so thread-like, impalpable, that it slipped through the fingers like light"
- The chain’s elusiveness mirrors Tony’s grasp on his dreams. It’s beautiful but intangible, suggesting his idealized Venice may slip away.
"Was there ever a young heart that did not, once and again, long to get away into such a world as that?"
- Wharton universalizes Tony’s yearning, inviting readers to recall their own escapist fantasies. The rhetorical question implicates the audience in the theme.
"the very churches wore turbans like so many Moslem idolators"
- Mounce’s xenophobic language reveals his fear of the unknown. His inability to see beauty in difference contrasts with Tony’s embrace of the exotic.
"before the Reverend Ozias had arrived at his next deduction, was skimming merrily shoreward"
- The comic timing (Tony escapes mid-sermon) underscores his rejection of authority. His physical vigor ("skimming") opposes Mounce’s mental paralysis.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters

This excerpt encapsulates Wharton’s signature themes: the conflict between imagination and convention, the allure of escape, and the fragility of dreams. Tony’s Venice is a metaphor for any idealized refuge—whether artistic, romantic, or spiritual—that promises liberation from oppressive structures. Wharton’s lyrical prose and sharp irony make the passage both poignant and critical, asking:

Can we ever truly escape the "heavy responsibilities" of reality?
Is the magic we seek external, or a projection of our own desires?
What is lost when we outgrow our illusions?

The passage’s power lies in its ambiguity: it celebrates Tony’s rebellion while hinting at the inevitability of disillusionment—a tension that defines much of Wharton’s work.

Questions

Question 1

The passage’s depiction of Venice as a place where “two and two might make five” and “a paradox elope with a syllogism” serves primarily to:

A. critique the irrationality of religious dogma by positioning Venice as a space where logic is deliberately subverted.
B. illustrate the cognitive dissonance Tony experiences as he reconciles his childhood fantasies with adult skepticism.
C. underscore the decadence of Venetian culture, which the Reverend Mounce associates with moral and intellectual corruption.
D. embody the transformative potential of imagination, where conventional boundaries dissolve to accommodate desire and wonder.
E. foreshadow Tony’s eventual disillusionment, as the passage suggests that such logical inconsistencies cannot endure in reality.

Question 2

The Reverend Ozias Mounce’s characterization in the passage is most effectively developed through:

A. the juxtaposition of his pedantic preoccupations with Tony’s impulsive vitality, revealing a clash between stagnant doctrine and youthful rebellion.
B. his explicit condemnation of Venice as a “Papistical foreign city,” which exposes his xenophobic and theologically rigid worldview.
C. the symbolic weight of his unfinished sermon, which represents the incompleteness of his moral authority over Tony.
D. the ironic contrast between his self-importance as a theologian and his inability to recognize the spiritual significance of Venice.
E. his physical inaction (e.g., being “roused from his lucubrations”), which mirrors the intellectual paralysis imposed by his dogmatic beliefs.

Question 3

The “gold chain” and “Venice glass” function in the passage as:

A. concrete symbols of the fragile yet enduring nature of Tony’s idealized Venice, embodying both its beauty and its susceptibility to shattering.
B. metaphors for the superficial allure of material wealth, which Tony mistakenly conflates with the deeper magic he seeks.
C. literal objects that ground the passage’s fantastical elements in tangible reality, preventing Tony’s dreams from becoming wholly abstract.
D. ironic counterpoints to the Reverend Mounce’s austere theology, as their delicacy highlights the brutality of his doctrinal constraints.
E. foreshadowing devices that suggest Tony’s eventual entrapment, as both objects are described in terms that evoke capture (“impaled butterfly”).

Question 4

Tony’s exclamation “ha!” and his subsequent actions (“winked at the subjugated captain, buckled on his sword”) are most significantly intended to:

A. emphasize his immaturity, as his defiance is framed as a childish tantrum rather than a principled act of rebellion.
B. convey a triumphant, almost theatrical rejection of authority, aligning his escape with the romanticized chivalry of his Venetian fantasies.
C. highlight the performative nature of his rebellion, suggesting that his defiance is more about appearances than genuine independence.
D. underscore the futility of his escape, as the passage implies that his actions are impulsive and lack a sustainable plan.
E. contrast his physical agility with the Reverend Mounce’s intellectual rigidity, reinforcing the theme of youth versus age.

Question 5

The passage’s closing image—Tony “skimming merrily shoreward” while the Reverend Mounce remains absorbed in his sermon—primarily serves to:

A. solidify the thematic opposition between liberation and constraint, leaving the reader to question whether Tony’s joy is fleeting or foundational.
B. resolve the narrative tension by confirming Tony’s successful escape, thereby validating his rejection of Mounce’s authority.
C. critique Tony’s impulsiveness, as his hasty departure suggests a lack of foresight that may undermine his dreams.
D. symbolize the inevitability of generational conflict, with Tony’s actions representing an irreversible break from tradition.
E. evoke a sense of tragic irony, as the reader infers that Tony’s arrival in Venice will only deepen his disillusionment.

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: D

Why D is most correct: The passage frames Venice as a realm where imagination suspends the rules of logic (“two and two might make five”), not to critique irrationality (A) or foreshadow disillusionment (E), but to celebrate the liberating power of fancy. The “paradox eloping with a syllogism” is a playful, subversive image that aligns with Tony’s longing for a world where desire trumps dogma. This interpretation is supported by the passage’s lyrical tone (“cloud-ladder leading to a land of dreams”) and its focus on Venice as a symbol of transformative possibility, not moral corruption (C) or cognitive dissonance (B).