Article #370-1 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from The Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Famous Moll Flanders, by Daniel Defoe

When I came he made several proposals for my placing my money in the
bank, in order to my having interest for it; but still some difficulty
or other came in the way, which he objected as not safe; and I found
such a sincere disinterested honesty in him, that I began to muse with
myself, that I had certainly found the honest man I wanted, and that I
could never put myself into better hands; so I told him with a great
deal of frankness that I had never met with a man or woman yet that I
could trust, or in whom I could think myself safe, but that I saw he
was so disinterestedly concerned for my safety, that I said I would
freely trust him with the management of that little I had, if he would
accept to be steward for a poor widow that could give him no salary.

He smiled and, standing up, with great respect saluted me. He told me
he could not but take it very kindly that I had so good an opinion of
him; that he would not deceive me, that he would do anything in his
power to serve me, and expect no salary; but that he could not by any
means accept of a trust, that it might bring him to be suspected of
self-interest, and that if I should die he might have disputes with my
executors, which he should be very loth to encumber himself with.

I told him if those were all his objections I would soon remove them,
and convince him that there was not the least room for any difficulty;
for that, first, as for suspecting him, if ever I should do it, now
is the time to suspect him, and not put the trust into his hands, and
whenever I did suspect him, he could but throw it up then and refuse
to go any further. Then, as to executors, I assured him I had no
heirs, nor any relations in England, and I would have neither heirs
nor executors but himself, unless I should alter my condition before
I died, and then his trust and trouble should cease together, which,
however, I had no prospect of yet; but I told him if I died as I was,
it should be all his own, and he would deserve it by being so faithful
to me as I was satisfied he would be.

Explanation

**Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Famous Moll Flanders by Daniel Defoe**

Context of the Work

Daniel Defoe’s Moll Flanders (1722) is a picaresque novel that follows the life of its eponymous protagonist, a woman who navigates poverty, crime, marriage, and survival in 17th- and early 18th-century England. The novel is framed as Moll’s first-person confession, written in retrospect, detailing her moral ambiguities, financial struggles, and relationships. The excerpt provided occurs later in the novel, after Moll has accumulated some wealth (likely through illicit means) and is seeking a trustworthy steward to manage her money.

At this point in the story, Moll is a widow (having been married multiple times) and is financially independent but distrustful of others due to her past experiences with deception and betrayal. The man she speaks to in this passage is likely the Lancashire Husband (her fifth husband), though the text does not explicitly name him. Their interaction reveals Moll’s cunning, her desperate need for security, and the power dynamics in financial and personal trust.

Themes in the Excerpt

Trust and Deception
- Moll’s life has been marked by betrayal—she has been abandoned, swindled, and forced to rely on her own wits. Her speech here is a mix of genuine vulnerability ("I had never met with a man or woman yet that I could trust") and calculated manipulation. She presents herself as a helpless widow to appeal to the man’s sense of honor, while also subtly pressuring him into compliance.
- The man’s refusal is framed as moral ("he could not by any means accept of a trust"), but his objections may also be strategic—he could be testing Moll’s sincerity or avoiding legal complications.
Financial Anxiety and Survival
- Moll’s wealth is precarious—she has no heirs, no legal protections, and fears losing her money. Her proposal to make the man her sole executor (and potential heir) is both a test of his loyalty and a way to bind him to her financially.
- The discussion of banks and interest reflects the rising capitalist economy of Defoe’s time, where financial security was uncertain, and trust was a rare commodity.
Gender and Power Dynamics
- As a woman in the 18th century, Moll has limited legal and financial autonomy. Her attempt to place her money in a man’s hands is both a necessity (since women could not easily manage property independently) and a risk.
- She uses flattery ("sincere disinterested honesty") and emotional appeal ("a poor widow") to manipulate the man, reversing the usual power dynamic where men control women’s finances.
Moral Ambiguity
- Moll’s offer to leave her entire estate to the man if she dies is generous but also self-serving—it ensures his loyalty while she lives. Her claim that she has "no prospect" of changing her marital status is ironic, given her history of serial marriages.
- The man’s refusal could be read as genuine integrity or as a negotiation tactic—he may be waiting for a better offer or avoiding legal entanglements.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Analysis

First-Person Narration & Unreliable Perspective
- Moll’s account is subjective and self-justifying. She presents herself as a victim ("a poor widow") while omitting her own deceptive past. The reader must question whether her trust in the man is sincere or another scheme.
- Her speech is persuasive and rhetorical, using parallel structure ("first… then…") to systematically dismantle the man’s objections.
Irony & Dramatic Tension
- Dramatic Irony: The reader knows Moll’s history of deception (she has stolen, lied, and manipulated men before), so her protestations of trust ring hollow. The man, however, does not know this.
- Situational Irony: Moll, a master of deception, is now seeking an "honest man—a rare figure in her world. Her faith in his integrity may be genuine, or it may be another con.
Dialogue as Power Play
- Moll’s lines are long, reasoned, and dominant, while the man’s responses are brief and deferential. This reflects her attempt to control the conversation.
- She uses flattery ("disinterestedly concerned for my safety") and logical appeals ("if ever I should suspect him, now is the time") to wear down his resistance.
Economic & Legal Language
- Terms like "bank," "interest," "trust," "executors," and "salary" ground the scene in the mercantile world of Defoe’s time, where financial transactions were both opportunities and threats.
- Moll’s proposal to make the man her heir is legally precarious—it could be seen as a bribe or an attempt to bind him to her permanently.
Foreshadowing & Suspense
- The man’s hesitation ("it might bring him to be suspected of self-interest") hints at future complications—will he later betray her? Or is he truly honorable?
- Moll’s assertion that she has "no prospect" of remarrying is foreshadowing—she will marry again (the Lancashire Husband), and this financial arrangement will have consequences.

Significance of the Passage

Character Development
- This scene reveals Moll’s duality: she is both a victim of circumstance (a widow in a patriarchal society) and a manipulator who uses her wit to survive.
- Her desperation for security contrasts with her distrust of others, showing how her past has shaped her paranoia.
Social Commentary on 18th-Century England
- The passage critiques the instability of wealth in a capitalist society—banks are distrusted, inheritances are contested, and women have little legal protection.
- Moll’s situation reflects the precariousness of female independence; she must rely on a man’s mercy, even as she tries to outsmart him.
Moral & Philosophical Questions
- Can Moll ever truly trust someone, given her own dishonesty?
- Is the man’s refusal noble or cowardly? Does he fear being complicit in her possibly ill-gotten wealth?
- The scene forces the reader to question who is conning whom—a central theme in Moll Flanders.
Narrative Function
- This interaction sets up future conflicts—will the man accept her offer later? Will Moll’s wealth be lost or stolen?
- It also deepens the novel’s tension between honesty and deception, a recurring motif in Moll’s life.

Conclusion: Moll’s Gambit

This excerpt is a microcosm of Moll’s entire life strategy: she appears vulnerable to gain advantage, tests others’ honesty while hiding her own dishonesty, and uses financial leverage to secure her survival. The man’s resistance makes the scene dramatically tense—will he be the one honest figure in her life, or will he, too, prove untrustworthy?

Defoe’s genius lies in making the reader complicit in Moll’s schemes—we root for her even as we recognize her manipulations. The passage is not just about money; it’s about the cost of trust in a world where everyone is a potential con artist.

Would you like a deeper dive into any specific aspect, such as the historical context of banking in Defoe’s time or a comparison with other picaresque novels?

Questions

Question 1

The narrator’s assertion that she has “never met with a man or woman yet that I could trust” serves primarily to:

A. establish her as a naive victim of societal corruption, underscoring the novel’s critique of 18th-century moral decay.
B. justify her past deceits by framing them as necessary survival tactics in an untrustworthy world.
C. create a rhetorical leverage point to manipulate the man’s perception of her vulnerability and his own moral obligation.
D. highlight the gendered power imbalance that forces women to rely on male benevolence for financial security.
E. foreshadow her eventual betrayal by the man, who will exploit her trust despite his initial protestations.

Question 2

The man’s refusal to accept the trust on the grounds that it “might bring him to be suspected of self-interest” is most plausibly interpreted as:

A. a genuine ethical stance, revealing his adherence to Enlightenment ideals of disinterested virtue.
B. a legal precaution, given the lack of formal contracts to protect him from future disputes over her estate.
C. a strategic deflection, allowing him to negotiate for more favorable terms while maintaining an appearance of integrity.
D. an expression of patriarchal condescension, implying that a woman’s financial affairs are inherently risky to manage.
E. a subconscious admission of guilt, suggesting he has previously engaged in similar acts of financial misconduct.

Question 3

The narrator’s claim that “if ever I should suspect him, now is the time to suspect him” employs which of the following rhetorical strategies as its primary mechanism of persuasion?

A. Reductio ad absurdum, by demonstrating that his objections collapse under their own logic if her initial trust is sincere.
B. Apophasis, by drawing attention to the possibility of suspicion while ostensibly dismissing it.
C. Ethos, by appealing to her established reputation for prudence in financial matters.
D. Procatalepsis, by preemptively addressing and refuting his potential counterarguments.
E. Hyperbole, by exaggerating the stakes of trust to emotionally overwhelm his resistance.

Question 4

Which of the following best describes the tone of the narrator’s proposal to make the man her sole executor and heir?

A. Melancholic resignation, as she concedes the inevitability of male control over her assets.
B. Calculated generosity, using financial incentives to bind him to her while minimizing her own risk.
C. Desperate supplication, revealing her fear of solitude and abandonment in old age.
D. Ironic detachment, since her offer presumes a stability in their relationship that her past undermines.
E. Legalistic precision, as she methodically outlines the terms to prevent future ambiguity.

Question 5

The passage’s exploration of trust and financial management is most thematically aligned with which of the following broader concerns in Moll Flanders?

A. The incompatibility of personal morality and economic survival in a pre-industrial capitalist society.
B. The redemptive power of female solidarity in a world dominated by patriarchal financial systems.
C. The performative nature of honesty, where trust is a transactional illusion rather than a genuine virtue.
D. The inevitability of betrayal as a consequence of human nature’s inherent corruptibility.
E. The legal vulnerabilities of widows, whose financial autonomy is perpetually contingent on male approval.

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: C

Why C is most correct: The narrator’s statement is not merely descriptive but strategic. By declaring her universal distrust, she positions herself as uniquely vulnerable to the man’s rare honesty, leveraging his ego and moral self-image to overcome his resistance. This aligns with her broader pattern of manipulation, where she exploits others’ perceptions of her helplessness (e.g., as a “poor widow”) to gain control. The line is less about her actual distrust of the world than about creating a scenario where he must prove himself trustworthy—a classic Moll Flanders tactic.