Article #393-1 | Gutenberg Articles

Excerpt

Excerpt from The Blue Lagoon: A Romance, by H. De Vere Stacpoole

Stacpoole spent the summer of 1898 in Sommerset, where he took over the
medical practice of an ailing country doctor. So peaceful were his days
in this pastoral setting that he had time to write The Doctor (1899), a
novel about an old-fashioned physician practicing medicine in rural
England. “It is the best book I have written,” Stacpoole declared more
than forty years later. He could also say, in retrospect, that the
book’s weak sales were a disguised blessing, “for I hadn’t ballast on
board in those days to stand up to the gale of success, which means
incidentally money.” He would be spared the gale of success for nine
more years, during which he published seven books, including a
collection of children’s stories and two collaborative novels with his
friend William Alexander Bryce.

In 1907, two events occurred that altered the course of Stacpoole’s
life: he wrote The Blue Lagoon and he married Margaret Robson. Unable
to sleep one night, he found himself thinking about and envying the
caveman, who in his primitiveness was able to marvel at such
commonplace phenomena as sunsets and thunderstorms. Civilized,
technological man had unveiled these mysteries with his telescopes and
weather balloons, so that they were no longer “nameless wonders” to be
feared and contemplated. As a doctor, Stacpoole had witnessed countless
births and deaths, and these events no longer seemed miraculous to him.
He conceived the idea of two children growing up alone on an island and
experiencing storms, death, and birth in almost complete ignorance and
innocence. The next morning, he started writing The Blue Lagoon. The
exercise was therapeutic because he was able to experience the wonders
of life and death vicariously through his characters.

The Blue Lagoon is the story of two cousins, Dicky and Emmeline
Lestrange, stranded on a remote island with a beautiful lagoon. As
children, they are cared for by Paddy Button, a portly sailor who
drinks himself to death after only two and a half years in paradise.
Frightened and confused by the man’s gruesome corpse, the children flee
to another part of Palm Tree Island. Over a period of five years, they
grow up and eventually fall in love. Sex and birth are as mysterious
to them as death, but they manage to copulate instinctively and
conceive a child. The birth is especially remarkable: fifteen-year-old
Emmeline, alone in the jungle, loses consciousness and awakes to find a
baby boy on the ground near her. Naming the boy Hannah (an example of
Stacpoole’s penchant for gender reversals), the Lestranges live in
familial bliss until they are unexpectedly expelled from their tropical
Eden.

Explanation

**Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Blue Lagoon: A Romance by H. De Vere Stacpoole**

Context of the Excerpt and the Novel

The provided passage is not a direct excerpt from The Blue Lagoon but rather a biographical and critical introduction to the novel, explaining its origins, themes, and Stacpoole’s motivations for writing it. However, it provides essential context for understanding the novel’s philosophical and thematic concerns, particularly its romantic primitivism, critique of modernity, and exploration of innocence versus experience.

The Blue Lagoon (1908) is a Robinsonade—a genre of survival narrative where characters are stranded in an isolated, often paradisiacal setting (e.g., Robinson Crusoe). Unlike Defoe’s rational, industrious castaway, however, Stacpoole’s protagonists, Dicky and Emmeline Lestrange, are children who grow up in complete ignorance of civilization, experiencing life’s fundamental mysteries (birth, death, love, and nature) with unmediated wonder.

The novel was written during a period when European imperialism, industrialization, and scientific rationalism were dismantling traditional romantic ideals of nature and human purity. Stacpoole, a physician, was disillusioned by how modern knowledge had stripped the world of its mystery—sunsets, storms, and even birth and death were no longer awe-inspiring but dissected, explained, and controlled. His novel is a nostalgic fantasy of returning to a state of primal innocence, where human beings encounter the world with childlike wonder rather than jaded understanding.

Key Themes in the Excerpt (and the Novel)

Primitivism and the Noble Savage Ideal
- Stacpoole envies the "caveman" who could marvel at sunsets and thunderstorms as nameless wonders, unlike modern man who has demystified nature through science.
- This reflects Rousseau’s concept of the "noble savage"—the idea that humans in a state of nature are purer, happier, and more in tune with the world than those corrupted by civilization.
- The novel’s island setting is a tropical Eden, free from the constraints of society, where Dicky and Emmeline rediscover the awe of existence.
Innocence vs. Experience (The Fall from Eden)
- The children’s ignorance of death, sex, and childbirth mirrors the biblical Adam and Eve before the Fall—they live in blissful unawareness until forced into knowledge.
- Paddy Button’s drunken death is their first encounter with mortality, and they flee in terror, symbolizing the loss of innocence.
- Their instinctive sexual union and Emmeline’s unconscious childbirth suggest that human nature is inherently pure, uncorrupted by societal taboos.
Critique of Modernity and Scientific Disenchantment
- Stacpoole, as a doctor, had witnessed too many births and deaths—they had become clinical, not miraculous.
- The novel is a rejection of Enlightenment rationalism; he longs for a world where mystery still exists, where humans can feel wonder rather than analyze.
- The island is a counterpoint to industrialized England—a place where time is cyclical (like nature), not linear and progressive (like modernity).
Gender and Nature
- The naming of the child "Hannah" (a female name for a boy) is an example of Stacpoole’s playful subversion of gender norms.
- The novel suggests that in a state of nature, gender roles are fluid—Emmeline and Dicky share labor, nurturing, and survival without rigid societal expectations.
- Emmeline’s unconscious childbirth (she wakes to find the baby already born) reinforces the idea that nature, not culture, dictates human experience.
The Inevitability of Expulsion from Paradise
- Like Adam and Eve, the Lestranges are eventually forced to leave their Eden, suggesting that innocence cannot last forever.
- The novel implies that civilization will always reassert itself, destroying the purity of the natural state.

Literary Devices and Stylistic Choices

Symbolism
- The Blue Lagoon = A paradise, but also a womb-like space (water as a symbol of birth and rebirth).
- Paddy Button’s corpse = The first intrusion of death and decay into their Eden, foreshadowing their eventual expulsion.
- The jungle = Both a nurturing mother and a threatening force (nature is beautiful but indifferent).
Allegory
- The novel functions as an allegory for human development—childhood innocence → sexual awakening → parenthood → expulsion from paradise.
- It also critiques colonialism (the island is an untouched Eden until "civilized" forces intervene).
Romanticism vs. Realism
- Stacpoole romanticizes primitivism—the children’s lives are idealized, despite the harsh realities of survival.
- Yet, there is realism in their confusion and fear (e.g., their reaction to Paddy’s death).
Irony
- The title calls it a "Romance", but the story is also tragic—their paradise is doomed.
- The gender reversal (Hannah) is ironic, given the novel’s otherwise traditional views on nature and innocence.
Pastoral Tradition
- The novel fits within the pastoral tradition (idealized rural life), but with a dark twist—nature is not just peaceful but also mysterious and sometimes cruel.

Significance of the Novel

Influence on Later Works
- The Blue Lagoon inspired multiple film adaptations (1923 silent film, 1949 and 1980 versions), each interpreting the themes differently (the 1980 version, for example, is more eroticized).
- It prefigures later "lost paradise" narratives like Lord of the Flies (1954), though Stacpoole’s vision is optimistic rather than dystopian.
Cultural and Historical Context
- Written during the height of British imperialism, the novel both romanticizes and critiques colonialism—the island is a fantasy of escape, but also a place that cannot remain untouched.
- Reflects fin-de-siècle anxieties about industrialization, urbanization, and the loss of spiritual connection to nature.
Psychological and Philosophical Depth
- Explores Freudian ideas of instinct vs. repression—the children act on natural urges without societal constraints.
- Raises questions about what it means to be human—are we defined by culture or by nature?
Stacpoole’s Personal Catharsis
- For Stacpoole, writing the novel was therapeutic—it allowed him to re-experience wonder through his characters.
- His medical background informs the novel’s preoccupation with birth, death, and the body.

Conclusion: Why This Excerpt (and Novel) Matters

The passage provided sets up the novel’s central tension: modernity has killed wonder, and only by returning to a state of primal innocence can humanity rediscover magic. The Blue Lagoon is not just a romantic adventure but a philosophical meditation on the cost of knowledge.

Stacpoole’s island is both a fantasy and a critique—it offers an escape from the alienation of industrial society, but it also cannot last. The novel forces readers to ask:

Is ignorance truly bliss?
Can humanity ever return to Eden, or is expulsion inevitable?
What do we lose when we explain away the mysteries of life?

In an era where science and technology dominate, Stacpoole’s work remains provocative—a plea for reclaiming awe in a disenchanted world.

Would you like a deeper analysis of a specific passage from the novel itself, or an exploration of how later adaptations (like the films) interpret these themes differently?

Questions

Question 1

The passage suggests that Stacpoole’s decision to write The Blue Lagoon was fundamentally an act of:

A. existential re-enchantment through vicarious primal experience.
B. escapist fantasy to evade the pressures of professional medical practice.
C. calculated commercial strategy to capitalize on the popularity of Robinsonade narratives.
D. autobiographical confession masking his dissatisfaction with rural English life.
E. satirical critique of Darwinian evolution by depicting instinctual human behavior as superior to learned civilization.

Question 2

The naming of the child "Hannah" serves primarily as:

A. a subversive literary device to destabilize conventional gender binaries within a "natural" state.
B. an ironic commentary on the children’s inability to distinguish biological sex due to their ignorance.
C. a biblical allusion reinforcing the Edenic parallels of the island as a pre-lapsarian paradise.
D. a narrative contrivance to emphasize the children’s cognitive regression to a pre-linguistic state.
E. a metaphor for the fluid, ungendered innocence of childhood before societal conditioning.

Question 3

The passage’s description of Emmeline’s childbirth—where she "loses consciousness and awakes to find a baby boy on the ground near her"—is most effectively interpreted as:

A. a primal mythologization of birth that strips the event of cultural mediation, restoring its status as an ineffable mystery.
B. an implausible plot device intended to heighten the novel’s melodramatic tension and emotional payoff.
C. a Freud-inflected allegory of the unconscious mind, where reproductive instincts operate beyond rational awareness.
D. a critique of patriarchal medical practices that exclude women from active participation in their own parturition.
E. a Darwinian affirmation of natural selection, where survival depends on instinctual rather than learned behavior.

Question 4

Stacpoole’s envy of the "caveman" who marvels at "sunsets and thunderstorms" as "nameless wonders" primarily reflects a:

A. Romantic rejection of Enlightenment rationalism’s demystification of the sublime in nature.
B. nostalgic longing for pre-industrial agrarian societies where labor was communal and meaningful.
C. professional burnout stemming from his medical training, which reduced human suffering to clinical detachment.
D. aesthetic preference for the picturesque, where nature’s beauty is enhanced by its perceived threat.
E. philosophical alignment with existentialism, where meaning is derived from confronting the absurd.

Question 5

The passage’s assertion that Stacpoole "hadn’t ballast on board in those days to stand up to the gale of success" is best understood as:

A. a modest disclaimer to preempt critical reappraisals of his early work’s artistic merits.
B. a confession of imposter syndrome, revealing his fear of being exposed as a fraudulent writer.
C. an admission of financial irresponsibility during his formative years as a struggling author.
D. a metaphorical justification for his later rejection of commercial literary trends in favor of avant-garde experimentation.
E. a retrospective framing of his early failures as providential, sparing him the corrupting influence of premature acclaim.

Solutions and Explanations

1) Correct answer: A

Why A is most correct: The passage explicitly states that Stacpoole conceived The Blue Lagoon after envying the caveman’s capacity for wonder—a wonder he, as a modern doctor, had lost. Writing the novel allowed him to "experience the wonders of life and death vicariously through his characters," which aligns with existential re-enchantment (restoring meaning/mystery to a disenchanted world). The act is vicarious (through the children) and primal (their ignorance mirrors the caveman’s awe).