Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Kreutzer Sonata and Other Stories, by graf Leo Tolstoy

Travellers left and entered our car at every stopping of the train.
Three persons, however, remained, bound, like myself, for the farthest
station: a lady neither young nor pretty, smoking cigarettes, with a
thin face, a cap on her head, and wearing a semi-masculine outer
garment; then her companion, a very loquacious gentleman of about forty
years, with baggage entirely new and arranged in an orderly manner;
then a gentleman who held himself entirely aloof, short in stature,
very nervous, of uncertain age, with bright eyes, not pronounced in
color, but extremely attractive,—eyes that darted with rapidity from
one object to another.

This gentleman, during almost all the journey thus far, had entered
into conversation with no fellow-traveller, as if he carefully avoided
all acquaintance. When spoken to, he answered curtly and decisively,
and began to look out of the car window obstinately.

Yet it seemed to me that the solitude weighed upon him. He seemed to
perceive that I understood this, and when our eyes met, as happened
frequently, since we were sitting almost opposite each other, he turned
away his head, and avoided conversation with me as much as with the
others. At nightfall, during a stop at a large station, the gentleman
with the fine baggage—a lawyer, as I have since learned—got out with
his companion to drink some tea at the restaurant. During their absence
several new travellers entered the car, among whom was a tall old man,
shaven and wrinkled, evidently a merchant, wearing a large
heavily-lined cloak and a big cap. This merchant sat down opposite the
empty seats of the lawyer and his companion, and straightway entered
into conversation with a young man who seemed like an employee in some
commercial house, and who had likewise just boarded the train. At first
the clerk had remarked that the seat opposite was occupied, and the old
man had answered that he should get out at the first station. Thus
their conversation started.

Explanation ​

This excerpt from The Kreutzer Sonata and Other Stories by Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) is a masterful example of his later, more psychologically intense and morally probing style. The passage comes from the novella The Kreutzer Sonata (1889), a dark exploration of marriage, jealousy, and human hypocrisy, told through the confessional monologue of Pozdnyshev, a man who murders his wife in a fit of rage. The excerpt here, however, is from the framing narrative—the opening scene in which an unnamed narrator (likely a stand-in for Tolstoy himself) observes his fellow train passengers, setting the stage for Pozdnyshev’s disturbing story.

Tolstoy’s work often dissects human behavior with surgical precision, and this passage is no exception. Below is a detailed breakdown of the text, focusing on its themes, literary devices, character dynamics, and significance within the broader work.

1. Context & Setting ​

The scene takes place on a Russian train, a microcosm of society where strangers are forced into close proximity, revealing their personalities through small interactions. The train setting is significant for several reasons:

  • Transience & Isolation: The constant arrival and departure of passengers mirrors the fleeting nature of human connections. The three remaining travelers (later revealed to include Pozdnyshev) are "bound for the farthest station," symbolizing a journey—both literal and metaphorical—toward an inevitable, perhaps grim, destination.
  • Social Stratification: The train car becomes a cross-section of Russian society—lawyers, merchants, clerks, and the enigmatic Pozdnyshev—each representing different classes and moral outlooks.
  • Confinement & Tension: The enclosed space heightens the psychological tension, forcing characters into unwanted intimacy, much like the suffocating dynamics of marriage that The Kreutzer Sonata critiques.

2. Character Sketches & Psychological Depth ​

Tolstoy introduces three key figures (later narrowed to two when the lawyer leaves), each sketched with economical yet revealing details:

A. The "Semi-Masculine" Lady ​

  • Description:
    • "Neither young nor pretty"
    • "Smoking cigarettes" (a scandalous habit for women in 19th-century Russia)
    • "Thin face," "cap on her head," "semi-masculine outer garment"
  • Significance:
    • Her androgynous appearance challenges traditional gender norms, hinting at Tolstoy’s critique of social roles and hypocrisy (a major theme in The Kreutzer Sonata).
    • Her smoking suggests defiance or world-weariness, possibly a woman who has rejected conventional femininity.
    • She is paired with the loquacious lawyer, implying a dynamic of superficial sociability—both are types Tolstoy often satirizes (the chattering intellectual and the emancipated but hollow woman).

B. The Loquacious Lawyer ​

  • Description:
    • "Very loquacious gentleman of about forty"
    • "Baggage entirely new and arranged in an orderly manner"
  • Significance:
    • His excessive talkativeness contrasts with Pozdnyshev’s silence, representing the emptiness of social conventions.
    • His orderly baggage symbolizes a life of artificial control, masking inner chaos (a theme Tolstoy explores in Pozdnyshev’s later confession).
    • Lawyers in Tolstoy’s works often embody moral corruption—they traffic in words rather than truth.

C. The Nervous, Isolated Gentleman (Pozdnyshev) ​

  • Description:
    • "Short in stature, very nervous, of uncertain age"
    • "Bright eyes... not pronounced in color, but extremely attractive"
    • "Darted with rapidity from one object to another"
    • "Avoided all acquaintance," answered "curtly and decisively"
    • "Solitude weighed upon him"
  • Significance:
    • This is Pozdnyshev, the novella’s tormented protagonist. His physical restlessness mirrors his psychological turmoil.
    • His eyes are a window into his intensity and instability—they are "attractive" yet unsettling, suggesting a man who is both compelling and dangerous.
    • His isolation is self-imposed but painful, hinting at guilt and self-loathing (later revealed to stem from his wife’s murder).
    • The narrator’s observation that "solitude weighed upon him" is crucial—it suggests Pozdnyshev craves connection but fears it, a paradox that drives the novella’s tragedy.

3. Themes ​

A. Alienation & the Failure of Human Connection ​

  • The train car is a space of forced proximity but emotional distance.
  • Pozdnyshev’s refusal to engage contrasts with the lawyer’s empty chatter, showing two extremes of failed communication.
  • The narrator’s attempts to connect (through eye contact) are rebuffed, emphasizing the loneliness of modern life.

B. Hypocrisy & Social Masks ​

  • The lawyer’s orderly baggage and the lady’s defiant smoking are performative—they present a facade while hiding inner emptiness.
  • Pozdnyshev’s avoidance of conversation is itself a mask, concealing his violent past.

C. The Unreliability of Perception ​

  • The narrator interprets Pozdnyshev’s behavior but doesn’t yet know his story. This dramatic irony (the reader later learns the truth) underscores how appearances deceive.
  • Tolstoy often uses limited perspective to show how we misjudge others.

D. Fate & Inevitability ​

  • The passengers are "bound for the farthest station," suggesting a journey toward doom (for Pozdnyshev, this is his confession and moral reckoning).
  • The merchant’s arrival disrupts the dynamic, foreshadowing how chance encounters can alter lives (as Pozdnyshev’s marriage does).

4. Literary Devices ​

A. Realism & Psychological Detail ​

  • Tolstoy’s precise, unadorned prose creates a sense of immediacy.
  • Small details (the lawyer’s new baggage, the lady’s cap) reveal character and social status without explicit commentary.

B. Symbolism ​

  • The Train: Represents life’s journey, with its stops, departures, and inevitable destination (death or moral crisis).
  • Eyes: Pozdnyshev’s darting, attractive eyes symbolize his unsettled mind and hidden passion.
  • Baggage: The lawyer’s orderly luggage vs. Pozdnyshev’s emotional baggage.

C. Foil Characters ​

  • The lawyer (talkative, superficial) vs. Pozdnyshev (silent, intense) highlight contrasting approaches to human interaction.
  • The merchant and clerk’s casual conversation contrasts with Pozdnyshev’s isolated brooding, showing different layers of society.

D. Foreshadowing ​

  • Pozdnyshev’s nervousness and avoidance hint at his guilt and instability.
  • The merchant’s intrusion foreshadows how external forces disrupt lives (as Pozdnyshev’s jealousy disrupts his marriage).

5. Significance in The Kreutzer Sonata ​

This excerpt serves as the framing device for Pozdnyshev’s confession. Its significance lies in:

  1. Establishing Pozdnyshev’s Character: His isolation and intensity prepare the reader for his shocking story.
  2. Contrasting Social Types: The lawyer and lady represent the hypocritical, chattering classes that Tolstoy critiques, while Pozdnyshev embodies raw, destructive passion.
  3. Setting the Tone: The claustrophobic, tense atmosphere mirrors the suffocating dynamics of Pozdnyshev’s marriage.
  4. Dramatic Irony: The narrator (and reader) doesn’t yet know Pozdnyshev’s crime, making his avoidance of eye contact eerily significant in hindsight.

6. Broader Tolstoyan Themes ​

  • Critique of Modern Marriage: Tolstoy, in his later years, became obsessed with sexual morality and saw marriage as a source of suffering (a theme central to The Kreutzer Sonata).
  • The Search for Truth: The narrator’s attempt to understand Pozdnyshev reflects Tolstoy’s belief that true human connection requires brutal honesty.
  • Moral Responsibility: Pozdnyshev’s self-imposed isolation is both a punishment and a failure to confront his sins.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is a masterclass in character study and atmospheric tension. Tolstoy uses minimal dialogue and maximum observation to:

  • Introduce a deeply troubled man without revealing his crime.
  • Critique social hypocrisy through contrasting characters.
  • Foreshadow the novella’s themes of isolation, passion, and moral collapse.

The train car becomes a stage where human nature is laid bare—some hide behind chatter and convention, others behind silence and rage. Pozdnyshev’s unsettling presence lingers, making the reader uneasy long before his confession begins. This is Tolstoy at his most psychologically penetrating, using everyday realism to explore the darkest corners of the soul.

Would you like a deeper dive into any specific aspect, such as Tolstoy’s views on marriage or the novella’s controversial reception?