Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Complete Works of James Whitcomb Riley — Volume 10, by James Whitcomb Riley

She was a woman of certainly not less than forty
years of age. But the figure, and the rounded grace
and fulness of it, together with the features and the
eyes, completed as fine a specimen of physical and
mental health as ever it has been my fortune to
meet; there was something so full of purpose and
resolve--something so wholesome, too, about the
character--something so womanly--I might almost
say manly, and would, but for the petty prejudice
maybe occasioned by the trivial fact of a locket
having dropped from her bosom as she knelt; and
that trinket still dangles in my memory even as it
then dangled and dropped back to its concealment
in her breast as she arose. But her face, by no
means handsome in the common sense of the word,
was marked with a breadth and strength of outline
and expression that approached the heroic--a face
that once seen is forever fixed in memory--a personage
once met one must know more of. And so it
was, that an hour later, as I strolled with the old
man about his farm, looking, to all intents, with the
profoundest interest at his Devonshires, Shorthorns,
Jerseys, and the like, I lured from him something
of an outline of his daughter's history.

"There're no better girl 'n Marthy!" he said,
mechanically answering some ingenious allusion to
her worth. "And yit," he went on reflectively,
stooping from his seat in the barn door and with
his open jack-knife picking up a little chip with the
point of the blade--"and yit--you wouldn't believe
it--but Marthy was the oldest o' three daughters,
and hed--I may say--hed more advantages o' marryin'--
and yit, as I was jest goin' to say, she's the
very one 'at didn't marry. Hed every advantage--
Marthy did. W'y, we even hed her educated--her
mother was a-livin' then--and we was well enough
fixed to afford the educatin' of her, mother allus
contended--and we was--besides, it was Marthy's
notion, too, and you know how women is thataway
when they git their head set. So we sent Marthy
down to Indianop'lus, and got her books and put
her in school there, and paid fer her keepin' and
ever'thing; and she jest--well, you may say, lived
there stiddy fer better'n four year. O' course
she'd git back ever' once-an-a-while, but her visits
was allus, some-way-another, onsatisfactory-like,
'cause, you see, Marthy was allus my favorite, and
I'd allus laughed and told her 'at the other girls
could git marrid ef they wanted, but SHE was goin'
to be the 'nest-egg' of our family, and 'slong as I
lived I wanted her at home with me. And she'd
laugh and contend 'at she'd as li'f be an old maid as
not, and never expected to marry, ner didn't want
to.

"But she had me sceart onc't, though! Come
out from the city one time, durin' the army, with
a peart-lookin' young feller in blue clothes and gilt
straps on his shoulders. Young lieutenant he was
--name o' Morris. Was layin' in camp there in the
city som'er's. I disremember which camp it was
now adzackly--but anyway, it 'peared like he had
plenty o' time to go and come, fer from that time
on he kep' on a-comin'--ever' time Marthy 'ud
come home, he'd come, too; and I got to noticin' 'at
Marthy come home a good 'eal more'n she used to
afore Morris first brought her. And blame' ef the
thing didn't git to worryin' me! And onc't I spoke
to mother about it, and told her ef I thought the
feller wanted to marry Marthy I'd jest stop his
comin' right then and there. But mother she sort o'
smiled and said somepin' 'bout men a-never seein'
through nothin'; and when I ast her what she meant,
w'y, she ups and tells me 'at Morris didn't keer
nothin' fer Marthy, ner Marthy fer Morris, and
then went on to tell me that Morris was kind o'
aidgin' up to'rds Annie--she was next to Marthy,
you know, in p'int of years and experience, but
ever'body allus said 'at Annie was the purtiest one
o' the whole three of 'em. And so when mother
told me 'at the signs p'inted to'rds Annie, w'y, of course, I
hedn't no particular objections to that,
'cause Morris was of good fambly enough it turned
out, and, in fact, was as stirrin' a young feller as
ever I' want fer a son-in-law, and so I hed nothin'
more to say--ner they wasn't no occasion to say
nothin', 'cause right along about then I begin to
notice 'at Marthy quit comin' home so much, and
Morris kep' a-comin' more.

Explanation ​

Analysis of the Excerpt from The Complete Works of James Whitcomb Riley – Volume 10 ​

James Whitcomb Riley (1849–1916) was an American writer known as the "Hoosier Poet" for his dialect poetry and rustic, sentimental depictions of rural Indiana life. His works often blended humor, nostalgia, and regional color, capturing the speech, customs, and social dynamics of 19th-century Midwestern America. This excerpt, likely from a short story or character sketch, introduces Marthy, a strong-willed, unmarried woman in her forties, through the perspective of an unnamed narrator and her father’s recollections.

The passage is rich in characterization, dialect, irony, and social commentary, particularly regarding gender roles, marriage, and individual agency in rural America. Below is a detailed breakdown of the text, focusing on its themes, literary devices, and significance while closely examining the language and structure.

1. Context & Setting ​

  • Rural Indiana, likely post-Civil War era (given references to the "army" and a lieutenant in "blue clothes," suggesting Union forces).
  • The narrator encounters Marthy, a middle-aged woman of striking presence, while visiting her father’s farm.
  • The father’s dialogue reveals Marthy’s backstory: she was the eldest of three daughters, educated in Indianapolis, and remained unmarried despite having "advantages" (suitor opportunities).
  • The social expectation of the time was that women married young; Marthy’s unmarried status is notable, even scandalous, in this context.

2. Themes ​

A. Female Agency & Defiance of Social Norms ​

  • Marthy is unconventional—she is educated, independent, and content in her singlehood, rejecting the expected path of marriage.
  • Her father admits she was his "nest-egg" (a term for a valuable asset kept at home), suggesting he preferred her to stay unmarried to care for him, while her sisters were free to marry.
  • The locket incident (a traditionally feminine, sentimental object) contrasts with her "manly" resolve, highlighting the tension between societal expectations of femininity and her own strength.
  • Her rejection of Lieutenant Morris (who instead courts her sister Annie) subverts the romantic trope of the eldest daughter marrying first.

B. The Illusion of Choice vs. Social Pressure ​

  • While Marthy claims she "didn’t want to marry," her father’s narrative suggests external pressures shaped her fate:
    • Her education (rare for women then) may have made her "too independent" for rural suitors.
    • Her father’s favoritism ("I wanted her at home with me") implies she was discouraged from leaving.
    • The Lieutenant Morris episode reveals that even when a suitor appeared, he was redirecting toward her sister, reinforcing that Marthy was not the "ideal" marital choice (perhaps due to age, personality, or her father’s influence).
  • The irony is that while Marthy appears to have chosen singlehood, her options were limited by gender norms and her father’s control.

C. The Idealization of the "Old Maid" ​

  • Riley challenges the stereotype of the pitiful "old maid." Marthy is strong, memorable, and respected—her father calls her the "best girl" despite her unmarried status.
  • Her "heroic" face and purposeful demeanor suggest she is more than her marital status; she embodies intellectual and emotional strength.
  • Yet, the narrator’s fascination with her (and the locket’s symbolic femininity) hints at society’s lingering discomfort with a woman who defies expectations.

D. Generational & Gender Dynamics ​

  • The father’s dialect ("hed," "git," "a-livin’") contrasts with the narrator’s more formal prose, emphasizing the class and educational divide between rural and urban perspectives.
  • The mother’s insight ("men a-never seein’ through nothin’") suggests women understand romantic dynamics better, while the father is oblivious to the Lieutenant’s true intentions.
  • The sisters’ differing fates (Annie, the "purtiest," marries; Marthy does not) reinforces beauty as a marital commodity, while Marthy’s intellect and strength go unrewarded in the marriage market.

3. Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

A. Dialect & Regionalism ​

  • Riley authentically reproduces rural Indiana speech (e.g., "hed," "git," "a-comin’"), immersing the reader in the setting and social class.
  • The father’s vernacular makes his bias and limited perspective clear—he sees Marthy’s singlehood as a personal preference, not a societal constraint.
  • The narrator’s standard English acts as a neutral frame, allowing the father’s dialect to reveal his character (proud, traditional, somewhat blind to his daughter’s sacrifices).

B. Imagery & Symbolism ​

  • The Locket:
    • A feminine, intimate object, its dropping and concealment symbolize Marthy’s hidden emotional life—she may have romantic or sentimental sides despite her strong exterior.
    • The narrator’s fixation on it suggests society’s obsession with women’s private lives, especially regarding love and marriage.
  • Marthy’s Face:
    • Described as "not handsome… but heroic", it defies conventional beauty standards, aligning her with strength rather than delicacy.
    • The "breadth and strength" of her features suggest intellectual and moral fortitude.
  • The Farm & Cattle (Devonshires, Shorthorns, Jerseys):
    • Represent traditional rural life, where women’s roles are domestic and reproductive.
    • Marthy’s absence from this framework (she is educated, unmarried) makes her an outsider in her own home.

C. Irony & Foreshadowing ​

  • Dramatic Irony:
    • The father believes Marthy chose singlehood, but the reader senses external forces (his own possessiveness, societal expectations) played a role.
    • His pride in her education contrasts with the fact that it may have made her "unmarriageable" in rural society.
  • Situational Irony:
    • The Lieutenant Morris, who seems interested in Marthy, is actually courting Annie, the "purtiest" sister—reinforcing that beauty, not intellect, was valued in a wife.
    • Marthy’s education, meant to elevate her, may have isolated her from traditional rural life.

D. Characterization Through Contrast ​

  • Marthy vs. Annie:
    • Marthy: Strong, educated, independent, "heroic" but unmarried.
    • Annie: "Purtiest," conventional, marries the lieutenant—fits the ideal feminine role.
  • Father vs. Mother:
    • Father: Traditional, sees daughters as assets ("nest-egg"), oblivious to emotional nuances.
    • Mother: More perceptive, understands romantic dynamics better than her husband.

4. Significance & Historical Context ​

  • Women’s Education & Marriage in the 19th Century:
    • Marthy’s education in Indianapolis was uncommon for rural women, who were typically expected to marry young.
    • Her singlehood would have been stigmatized—she is either admired as an exception or pitied as a failure.
  • Post-Civil War Gender Roles:
    • The Lieutenant Morris represents the mobile, modern man (urban, military), while Marthy is rooted in rural tradition—yet she doesn’t conform to it.
    • The father’s control over his daughters reflects patriarchal norms, where women’s choices were limited by male authority.
  • Riley’s Subversion of Stereotypes:
    • While Riley often romanticized rural life, this passage critiques its limitations, particularly for intelligent, independent women.
    • Marthy is not a tragic figure but a complex, memorable one, challenging the sentimental "old maid" trope.

5. Close Reading of Key Passages ​

A. The Narrator’s First Impression of Marthy ​

"She was a woman of certainly not less than forty years of age. But the figure, and the rounded grace and fulness of it, together with the features and the eyes, completed as fine a specimen of physical and mental health as ever it has been my fortune to meet…"

  • Physical & Mental Health: Marthy is vibrant, not faded—defying the stereotype of the "aged spinster."
  • "Rounded grace and fulness": Suggests maturity and strength, not the youthful slenderness idealized in women.
  • "Heroic" face: Aligns her with mythic or legendary figures, not ordinary women.

B. The Locket’s Symbolism ​

"something so womanly—I might almost say manly… but for the petty prejudice maybe occasioned by the trivial fact of a locket having dropped from her bosom…"

  • The locket (a sentimental, feminine object) contradicts her "manly" resolve, showing that she is not entirely free from traditional femininity.
  • Its concealment suggests hidden emotions—perhaps unfulfilled romantic longings or a private, tender side.

C. The Father’s Revelation About Lieutenant Morris ​

"And yit—you wouldn’t believe it—but Marthy was the oldest o’ three daughters, and hed—I may say—hed more advantages o’ marryin’—and yit, as I was jest goin’ to say, she’s the very one ‘at didn’t marry."

  • "More advantages": Implies she had suitors but didn’t take them—or that her education and age made her less desirable.
  • The repetition of "yit" (yet) emphasizes the unexpectedness of her singlehood.

"W’y, we even hed her educated—her mother was a-livin’ then—and we was well enough fixed to afford the educatin’ of her…"

  • Education was a privilege, but it didn’t lead to marriage—suggesting that intellect was not valued in a wife.

"I got to noticin’ ‘at Marthy come home a good ‘eal more’n she used to afore Morris first brought her."

  • Morris’s visits coincide with Marthy’s increased trips home—implying she may have had feelings for him, but he chose Annie instead.
  • The father’s obliviousness ("mother she sort o’ smiled and said somepin’ ‘bout men a-never seein’ through nothin’") highlights male ignorance of female emotions.

6. Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is a nuanced portrayal of a woman who defies expectations while still being shaped by them. Riley presents Marthy as:

  • A symbol of female resilience in a restrictive society.
  • A critique of rural gender norms, where education and independence could be liabilities for women.
  • A complex character who is neither wholly free nor wholly trapped—her strength is both admired and misunderstood.

The father’s dialect and limited perspective contrast with the narrator’s more observant tone, inviting readers to question how much of Marthy’s life was truly her choice. The locket, the lieutenant, and the farm all serve as symbols of the tensions between tradition and individuality.

Ultimately, Riley challenges the reader to see Marthy not as a failed wife, but as a remarkable woman whose life transcends the narrow roles assigned to her. In doing so, he elevates the "old maid" from a figure of pity to one of quiet dignity and strength.