Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Complete Works of James Whitcomb Riley — Volume 10, by James Whitcomb Riley

All who knew Mr. Clark intimately, casually,
or by sight alone, smiled always, meeting
him, and thought, "What an odd man he is!" Not
that there was anything extremely or ridiculously
obtrusive in Mr. Clark's peculiarities either of
feature, dress, or deportment, by which a graded
estimate of his really quaint character might aptly be
given; but rather, perhaps, it was the curious
combination of all these things that had gained
for Mr. Clark the transient celebrity of being a
very eccentric man.

And Mr. Clark, of all the odd inhabitants of the
busy metropolis in which he lived, seemed least
conscious of the fact of his local prominence. True
it was that when familiarly addressed as "Clark,
old boy," by sportive individuals he never recollected
having seen before, he would oftentimes stare
blankly in return, and with evident embarrassment;
but as these actions may have been attributable to
weak eyes, or to the confusion consequent upon
being publicly recognized by the quondam associates
of bacchanalian hours, the suggestive facts only
served to throw his eccentricities in new relief.

And in the minds of many, that Mr. Clark was somewhat given to
dissipation, there was but little
doubt; for, although in no way, and at no time,
derelict in the rigid duties imposed upon him as
an accountant in a wholesale liquor house on South
John Street, a grand majority of friends had long
ago conceded that a certain puffiness of flesh and
a soiled-like pallor of complexion were in nowise
the legitimate result of over-application simply in
the counting-room of the establishment in which he
found employment; but as to the complicity of Mr.
Clark's direct associates in this belief, it is only
justice to the gentleman to state that by them
he was held above all such suspicion, from the
gray-haired senior of the firm, down to the pink-
nosed porter of the warerooms, who, upon every
available occasion, would point out the eccentric
Mr. Clark as "the on'y man in the biznez 'at never
sunk a 'thief' er drunk a drop o' 'goods' o' any
kind, under no consideration!"

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Complete Works of James Whitcomb Riley — Volume 10 ​

This passage introduces Mr. Clark, an eccentric yet intriguing figure in an unnamed bustling city. Written in the late 19th or early 20th century by James Whitcomb Riley—a poet and writer known for his humorous, dialect-heavy, and often nostalgic depictions of rural and small-town life—this excerpt blends social observation, irony, and character study to paint a vivid portrait of an outsider who defies easy categorization.

Riley’s work often explores human quirks, local color, and the gap between appearance and reality, and this passage is no exception. Below is a breakdown of the text’s themes, literary devices, and significance, with a focus on close reading.

1. Context & Source ​

James Whitcomb Riley (1849–1916) was a Hoosier poet (from Indiana) whose writing often celebrated rural Americana, dialect humor, and eccentric characters. While he is best known for poems like "Little Orphant Annie" and "The Raggedy Man," his prose—such as this excerpt—also captures urban oddities and social dynamics with a mix of wit and pathos.

This passage likely comes from a short story or sketch in Volume 10 of Riley’s complete works, which includes prose pieces alongside poetry. The setting appears to be a late 19th-century American city, where industrialization and urbanization created new social types—including the eccentric office worker, a figure both familiar and mysterious to his peers.

2. Summary of the Excerpt ​

The passage describes Mr. Clark, an accountant in a wholesale liquor house, who is widely regarded as an odd, eccentric man—though not in any overtly ridiculous way. His strangeness stems from a combination of subtle traits (appearance, mannerisms, and behavior) rather than any single defining quirk.

Key observations about Mr. Clark:

  • He is recognizable yet unassuming, inspiring smiles from acquaintances but remaining oblivious to his local "celebrity."
  • He is socially awkward, reacting with confusion when strangers address him familiarly (e.g., "Clark, old boy").
  • Despite working in the liquor trade, he is suspected of dissipation (drunkenness) by many, though his coworkers vehemently defend his sobriety.
  • His physical appearance (puffy flesh, pale complexion) fuels rumors, but his professional reliability contradicts them.

The excerpt ends with the porter’s emphatic defense of Clark, declaring him the only man in the business who never stole or drank on the job—a twist that undermines the gossip while reinforcing his eccentricity.

3. Major Themes ​

A. The Eccentric as an Urban Archetype ​

  • The busy metropolis is a place where individuality is both celebrated and scrutinized. Mr. Clark stands out not because he is flamboyant, but because he is subtly, inexplicably different.
  • His eccentricity is collectively constructed—people project their own interpretations onto him (e.g., assuming he drinks because of his pallor, when in reality, he may just be naturally pale).
  • This reflects a 19th-century fascination with "character types" in literature (e.g., Dickens’ oddballs, Poe’s obsessives). Riley’s Clark is a mild, everyday eccentric, not a grotesque or villain.

B. Appearance vs. Reality ​

  • The contradiction between perception and truth drives the passage:
    • Outsiders assume Clark is a drinker because of his job and looks.
    • Coworkers know he is teetotaling and honest, yet still find him odd.
  • His puffiness and pallor could be from overwork, poor health, or natural features, but people prefer a dramatic explanation (dissipation).
  • The porter’s defense ("never sunk a thief er drunk a drop") is ironic—it confirms Clark’s virtue but also his permanent outsider status (even his defenders call him "eccentric").

C. Social Judgment & Gossip ​

  • The passage critiques how society labels people based on superficial traits.
  • Clark’s awkward reactions (staring blankly when addressed) are misinterpreted—some assume he’s hiding drunkenness, others think he’s just nearsighted.
  • The liquor house setting adds irony: in an industry associated with vice, the one man who doesn’t drink is the one people suspect the most.

D. The Loneliness of the Misfit ​

  • Clark is unaware of his fame, suggesting social isolation. He doesn’t play into his reputation, nor does he try to correct it.
  • His embarrassment when recognized hints at discomfort with attention, reinforcing his detachment from the social world around him.

4. Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

A. Irony & Paradox ​

  • Situational Irony: Clark works in liquor but is the one man who doesn’t drink—yet people assume he does.
  • Dramatic Irony: The reader (and coworkers) knows Clark is sober and honest, but the general public misjudges him.
  • Verbal Irony: The porter’s hyperbolic praise ("the on’y man in the biznez") is backhanded—it highlights Clark’s oddity even while defending him.

B. Characterization Through Contradiction ​

  • Clark is both ordinary and extraordinary:
    • Ordinary: He’s a quiet accountant, not a flamboyant dandy.
    • Extraordinary: His subtle quirks make him locally famous.
  • His physical description is vague yet suggestive ("puffiness of flesh," "soiled-like pallor"), inviting reader speculation.

C. Dialect & Colloquialism ​

  • Riley uses regional dialect (e.g., the porter’s speech: "'at never sunk a 'thief' er drunk a drop") to:
    • Ground the story in a specific time/place (likely a working-class urban setting).
    • Contrast formal narration with informal speech, adding authenticity and humor.
  • The porter’s voice is uneducated but authoritative, making his defense of Clark more compelling (and funny).

D. Free Indirect Discourse ​

  • The narration blends objective description with subjective interpretation:
    • "What an odd man he is!" → Collective opinion (not the narrator’s direct judgment).
    • "a certain puffiness of flesh... were in nowise the legitimate result of over-application" → Gossipy speculation presented as fact.
  • This technique immerses the reader in the community’s perspective, making Clark’s eccentricity a shared social construct.

E. Repetition & Emphasis ​

  • "Odd" and "eccentric" are repeated, reinforcing Clark’s inescapable label.
  • The porter’s declaration is emphatic and rhythmic, making it memorable and conclusive.

5. Significance & Possible Interpretations ​

A. A Study in Human Quirkiness ​

  • Riley celebrates the oddball, suggesting that eccentricity is a natural part of human diversity.
  • Clark is not a villain or a fool—just a man who doesn’t fit neatly into expectations.

B. Critique of Social Assumptions ​

  • The passage exposes how quickly people judge others based on appearance, profession, or rumors.
  • The liquor house setting is key—it symbolizes temptation, yet Clark resists it, making the gossip about him even more unjust.

C. The Isolation of the Individual in a Crowd ​

  • Clark is surrounded by people but fundamentally alone—his coworkers defend him, but they still see him as different.
  • His lack of self-awareness (not realizing he’s famous) suggests a man out of sync with his environment.

D. Humor & Pathos ​

  • The comic elements (the porter’s speech, the absurdity of the rumors) soften the critique.
  • Yet there’s pathos in Clark’s confusion and isolation—he’s a misfit in a world that doesn’t understand him.

6. Connection to Riley’s Broader Work ​

  • Riley often wrote about outsiders and underdogs, whether in rural Indiana or urban settings.
  • His use of dialect and humor makes serious themes more accessible.
  • Like many of his character sketches, this passage blends realism with gentle satire, poking fun at society while sympathizing with the oddball.

7. Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt is a masterclass in character study, using subtle details, irony, and social commentary to explore:

  • How eccentricity is constructed by others.
  • The gap between reputation and reality.
  • The loneliness of being misunderstood.

Riley doesn’t explain Clark—he presents him, letting the contradictions and rumors build a rich, ambiguous portrait. The passage invites readers to question their own assumptions about people who don’t fit in, making it both entertaining and thought-provoking.

In the end, Mr. Clark remains an enigma—and that’s exactly what makes him fascinating.