Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Raffles: Further Adventures of the Amateur Cracksman, by E. W. Hornung

“You don’t understand, Bunny, old chap; but if you like you shall. I
always meant to tell you some day, but never felt worked up to it
before, and it’s not the kind of thing one talks about for talking’s
sake. It isn’t a nursery story, Bunny, and there isn’t a laugh in it
from start to finish; on the contrary, you have often asked me what
turned my hair gray, and now you are going to hear.”

This was promising, but Raffles’s manner was something more. It was
unique in my memory of the man. His fine face softened and set hard by
turns. I never knew it so hard. I never knew it so soft. And the same
might be said of his voice, now tender as any woman’s, now flying to
the other extreme of equally unwonted ferocity. But this was toward the
end of his tale; the beginning he treated characteristically enough,
though I could have wished for a less cavalier account of the island of
Elba, where, upon his own showing, he had met with much humanity.

“Deadly, my dear Bunny, is not the word for that glorified snag, or for
the mollusks, its inhabitants. But they started by wounding my vanity,
so perhaps I am prejudiced, after all. I sprung myself upon them as a
shipwrecked sailor—a sole survivor—stripped in the sea and landed
without a stitch—yet they took no more interest in me than you do in
Italian organ-grinders. They were decent enough. I didn’t have to pick
and steal for a square meal and a pair of trousers; it would have been
more exciting if I had. But what a place! Napoleon couldn’t stand it,
you remember, but he held on longer than I did. I put in a few weeks in
their infernal mines, simply to pick up a smattering of Italian; then
got across to the mainland in a little wooden timber-tramp; and
ungratefully glad I was to leave Elba blazing in just such another
sunset as the one you won’t forget.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Raffles: Further Adventures of the Amateur Cracksman ​

1. Context of the Source ​

E.W. Hornung’s Raffles series (1899–1909) follows the adventures of A.J. Raffles, a charming, aristocratic gentleman thief, and his loyal accomplice and narrator, Harry "Bunny" Manders. The stories blend crime, wit, and psychological depth, often exploring themes of morality, class, and the duality of human nature.

This excerpt comes from Further Adventures of the Amateur Cracksman (1901), a sequel to the original collection. Here, Raffles prepares to reveal a dark, personal story to Bunny—one that explains why his hair turned gray. The tone shifts from their usual lighthearted banter to something far more serious, hinting at a traumatic past.

2. Themes in the Excerpt ​

  • Trauma and Memory – Raffles rarely discusses his past, suggesting deep emotional scars. His reluctance ("not the kind of thing one talks about for talking’s sake") implies that this story is painful, not just dramatic.
  • Isolation and Alienation – His time on Elba (a real island where Napoleon was exiled) is described as dehumanizing. The inhabitants treat him with indifference, reinforcing his sense of being an outsider.
  • Class and Dignity – Raffles, usually a master of charm, is reduced to a "shipwrecked sailor," stripped of his identity. His disdain for the islanders ("mollusks") reflects his pride—he expects better treatment, even in hardship.
  • Survival and Resilience – Despite the hardship, he adapts (learning Italian, working in mines) and escapes, showing his resourcefulness.

3. Literary Devices & Stylistic Analysis ​

  • Foreshadowing & Suspense – The opening lines ("what turned my hair gray") create intrigue. Raffles’ uncharacteristic emotional intensity ("his fine face softened and set hard by turns") signals that this is no ordinary tale.
  • Contrast & Juxtaposition –
    • Tone Shift: The usual witty, detached Raffles is replaced by a man oscillating between tenderness and ferocity, suggesting repressed trauma.
    • Elba vs. Raffles’ Expectations: He expected sympathy as a castaway but was treated with indifference ("no more interest than you do in Italian organ-grinders").
  • Irony & Understatement –
    • "They were decent enough" – A dry understatement; they gave him food and clothes, but the lack of human connection wounds him more.
    • "Napoleon couldn’t stand it, but he held on longer than I did" – A darkly humorous comparison, positioning Raffles (a thief) alongside a historical giant in shared misery.
  • Imagery & Sensory Language –
    • Elba as a "glorified snag" (a jagged, worthless rock) and its people as "mollusks" (slow, unfeeling creatures) paint a bleak, dehumanizing picture.
    • The sunset (mentioned in the last line) may symbolize both beauty and finality—his relief at leaving, but also the lingering memory of suffering.

4. Significance of the Passage ​

  • Character Depth – This moment humanizes Raffles. Usually a cool, controlled figure, here he is vulnerable, revealing that his charming exterior masks deep pain.
  • Narrative Function – The story he’s about to tell (likely involving betrayal, imprisonment, or loss) will explain his cynicism and moral ambiguity in later adventures.
  • Reader Engagement – By breaking the usual lighthearted tone, Hornung deepens the stakes, making the reader invest more in Raffles’ backstory.
  • Historical & Psychological Realism – The reference to Napoleon’s exile grounds the story in history, while Raffles’ psychological reaction (pride wounded, trauma repressed) adds realism to his character.

5. Close Reading of Key Lines ​

  • "It isn’t a nursery story, Bunny, and there isn’t a laugh in it from start to finish" → Not entertainment, but confession. Raffles warns Bunny (and the reader) that this is raw, unfiltered truth, not one of their usual witty capers.

  • "I sprung myself upon them as a shipwrecked sailor—a sole survivor—stripped in the sea and landed without a stitch" → Symbolic nakedness—he is literally and metaphorically exposed, stripped of his gentleman thief persona.

  • "But what a place! Napoleon couldn’t stand it, you remember, but he held on longer than I did." → Dark humor + historical parallel. Raffles, though a criminal, compares himself to Napoleon, suggesting his pride and endurance—yet also his limits.

  • "ungratefully glad I was to leave Elba blazing in just such another sunset as the one you won’t forget." → Ambiguity: The sunset could be beautiful (a fond memory) or oppressive (a symbol of his suffering). The phrase "you won’t forget" implies Bunny (and the reader) has shared a similar moment of relief or escape.

6. Conclusion: Why This Matters ​

This excerpt is a pivotal moment in the Raffles series because it:

  1. Breaks the fourth wall—Raffles speaks directly to Bunny (and the reader), creating intimacy.
  2. Reveals his humanity—His trauma explains why he lives by his own rules, distrusting society.
  3. Sets up future tension—Whatever happened on Elba (or after) likely shaped his moral code, making his later heists more personal than just thrill-seeking.

Hornung uses this passage to transition from adventure to psychology, showing that even a master thief has scars—and that those scars drive his actions. The contrast between Raffles’ usual charm and his raw emotion here makes the moment unforgettable, deepening the series beyond mere crime stories into a study of a complex, flawed man.