Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Cruise of the Jasper B., by Don Marquis

Cleggett--Old Clegg, the copyreader--Clegg, the commonplace--C. J.
Cleggett, the Brooklynite-this person whom young reporters conceived of
as the staid, dry prophet of the dusty Fact--was secretly a mighty
reservoir of unwritten, unacted, unlived, unspoken romance. He ate it,
he drank it, he breathed it, he dreamed it. The usual copyreader, when
he closes his eyes and smiles upon a pleasant inward vision, is
thinking of starting a chicken-farm in New Jersey. But Cleggett--with
gray sprinkled in his hair, sober of face and precise of manner, as the
world knew him--lived a hidden life which was one long, wild adventure.

Nobody had ever suspected it. But his room might have given to the
discerning a clue to the real man behind the mask which he
assumed--which he had been forced to assume in order to earn a living.
When he reached the apartment, a few minutes after his encounter on the
bridge, and switched the electric light on, the gleams fell upon an
astonishing clutter of books and arms....

Stevenson, cavalry sabers, W. Clark Russell, pistols, and Dumas; Jack
London, poignards, bowie knives, Stanley Weyman, Captain Marryat, and
Dumas; sword canes, Scottish claymores, Cuban machetes, Conan Doyle,
Harrison Ainsworth, dress swords, and Dumas; stilettos, daggers,
hunting knives, Fenimore Cooper, G. P. R. James, broadswords, Dumas;
Gustave Aimard, Rudyard Kipling, dueling swords, Dumas; F. Du
Boisgobey, Malay krises, Walter Scott, stick pistols, scimitars,
Anthony Hope, single sticks, foils, Dumas; jungles of arms, jumbles of
books; arms of all makes and periods; arms on the walls, in the
corners, over the fireplace, leaning against the bookshelves, lying in
ambush under the bed, peeping out of the wardrobe, propping the windows
open, serving as paper weights; pictures, warlike and romantic prints
and engravings, pinned to the walls with daggers; in the wardrobe,
coats and hats hanging from poignards and stilettos thrust into the
wood instead of from nails or hooks. But of all the weapons it was the
rapiers, of all the books it was Dumas, that he loved. There was Dumas
in French, Dumas in English, Dumas with pictures, Dumas unillustrated,
Dumas in cloth, Dumas in leather, Dumas in boards, Dumas in paper
covers. Cleggett had been twenty years getting these arms and books
together; often he had gone without a dinner in order to make a payment
on some blade he fancied. And each weapon was also a book to him; he
sensed their stories as he handled them; he felt the personalities of
their former owners stirring in him when he picked them up. It was in
that room that he dreamed; which is to say, it was in that room that he
lived his real life.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Cruise of the Jasper B. by Don Marquis ​

Context of the Source ​

Don Marquis (1878–1937) was an American journalist, humorist, and author best known for creating the fictional characters Archy and Mehitabel—a cockroach and a cat whose poetic musings appeared in newspaper columns. The Cruise of the Jasper B. (1916) is a lesser-known but charming novel that blends adventure, satire, and character study. The story follows a group of misfits—including journalists, poets, and dreamers—who embark on a chaotic voyage aboard a decrepit ship. The novel pokes fun at journalistic culture, romantic idealism, and the contrast between outward conformity and inner fantasy.

This excerpt introduces C. J. Cleggett, a seemingly mundane copyreader (a newspaper editor who checks articles for errors and style) who harbors a secret, vibrant inner life filled with swashbuckling romance and adventure.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. The Duality of Human Nature (Appearance vs. Reality)

    • Cleggett is perceived as "the staid, dry prophet of the dusty Fact"—a boring, by-the-book professional. Yet, his true self is a "mighty reservoir of unwritten, unacted, unlived, unspoken romance."
    • The contrast between his public persona (a sober Brooklynite) and his private world (a fantasy of swords, pirates, and derring-do) highlights how people often conceal their passions to fit societal expectations.
    • This theme resonates with Marquis’ broader satire of journalistic culture, where creativity is stifled by routine, and dreamers must suppress their imaginations to survive in a practical world.

  2. The Power of Imagination and Escapism

    • Cleggett’s apartment is a physical manifestation of his inner world—a chaotic, weapon-filled sanctuary where he "lived his real life."
    • The books and arms symbolize his longing for adventure, a desire to escape the monotony of his job. The fact that he "ate, drank, breathed, dreamed" romance suggests that his imagination is not just a hobby but a necessity for survival.
    • The repetition of Dumas (a 19th-century French novelist known for The Three Musketeers and The Count of Monte Cristo) reinforces Cleggett’s obsession with swashbuckling heroism—a world far removed from his desk job.

  3. The Romanticization of the Past

    • The weapons (sabers, claymores, krises, rapiers) and books (Stevenson, Kipling, Scott) evoke a nostalgic, idealized past—one of duels, pirates, and chivalry.
    • Cleggett doesn’t just collect these items; he feels their stories, imagining the lives of their former owners. This suggests a yearning for a time when life was grander, more dangerous, and more heroic than his own.
    • The rapiers and Dumas are singled out as his favorites, reinforcing his love for elegant, dramatic conflict—the opposite of his mundane reality.

  4. Sacrifice for Passion

    • The line "often he had gone without a dinner in order to make a payment on some blade he fancied" shows that Cleggett prioritizes his dreams over basic needs.
    • This sacrifice underscores how deeply he values his inner world—even at the cost of comfort. It also adds a tragicomic element: a man so devoted to fantasy that he neglects his own well-being.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Juxtaposition & Irony

    • The opening description of Cleggett as "the commonplace" and "sober of face" is immediately undercut by the revelation of his secret life.
    • The dry, journalistic tone ("the staid, dry prophet of the dusty Fact") contrasts with the exuberant, almost manic listing of weapons and books, creating humorous irony.

  2. Cataloging & Repetition (Anaphora & Polysyndeton)

    • The long, breathless lists of weapons and authors ("Stevenson, cavalry sabers, W. Clark Russell, pistols, and Dumas…") create a sense of overwhelming abundance, mirroring Cleggett’s obsessive, all-consuming passion.
    • The repetition of "Dumas" (appearing six times in the passage) acts like a refrain, emphasizing its centrality in Cleggett’s life.
    • The lack of commas in some lists ("jungles of arms, jumbles of books") makes the prose feel chaotic and immersive, as if the reader is stepping into Cleggett’s cluttered mind.

  3. Personification & Sensory Imagery

    • The weapons are described as if they have lives of their own:
      • "lying in ambush under the bed"
      • "peeping out of the wardrobe"
      • "propping the windows open"
    • This animates the inanimate, making the room feel like a living extension of Cleggett’s imagination.
    • The tactile imagery ("he sensed their stories as he handled them") suggests that Cleggett doesn’t just see these objects—he feels their history.

  4. Symbolism

    • Weapons = Adventure, conflict, heroism (the life Cleggett wishes he lived).
    • Books (especially Dumas) = Escapism, romance, the power of storytelling.
    • The cluttered room = The chaos of creativity, contrasting with the orderly, sterile world of his job.

  5. Hyperbole & Exaggeration

    • The sheer volume of weapons and books is comically excessive—sword canes, Scottish claymores, Malay krises, etc.—suggesting that Cleggett’s passion is almost pathological.
    • The idea that he "felt the personalities of their former owners stirring in him" is dramatically romantic, bordering on the supernatural.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. A Critique of Modern Life & Work

    • Marquis, a journalist himself, uses Cleggett to satirize the drudgery of office work and the suppression of creativity in professional environments.
    • Cleggett’s double life reflects the tension between conformity and individuality—a theme still relevant today.

  2. The Romantic vs. the Realist

    • Cleggett embodies the Romantic idealist trapped in a realist’s world. His love for Dumas and rapiers represents a rejection of modernity in favor of a more dramatic, heroic past.
    • The passage mocks yet sympathizes with dreamers who refuse to let go of their fantasies, even when reality offers little reward.

  3. The Power of Hidden Lives

    • The excerpt suggests that everyone has a secret self—one that may be far more interesting than their public persona.
    • This idea challenges judgments based on appearances, a recurring theme in literature (e.g., The Great Gatsby, Fight Club).

  4. A Love Letter to Adventure Stories

    • Marquis, who wrote for newspapers, clearly adored pulpy, romantic literature. This passage is both a celebration and a parody of that genre.
    • The over-the-top descriptions mimic the style of Dumas and Stevenson, making the reader feel the same thrill Cleggett does.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Resonates ​

This excerpt is funny, poignant, and deeply relatable because it captures the universal human desire to escape—whether into books, daydreams, or hobbies. Cleggett is everyman’s secret hero: the quiet, unassuming person who, behind closed doors, lives a life of wild imagination.

Marquis’ vivid, exaggerated prose makes the passage visually and emotionally striking, while the themes of hidden passion and sacrifice give it depth. It’s a celebration of the dreamer, a critique of mundane existence, and a reminder that the most interesting lives are often the ones we never see.

Would you like any further analysis on specific aspects, such as comparisons to other works or deeper psychological interpretations?