Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Oliver Twist, by Charles Dickens

by Charles Dickens

Contents

I TREATS OF THE PLACE WHERE OLIVER TWIST WAS BORN AND OF THE
CIRCUMSTANCES ATTENDING HIS BIRTH
II TREATS OF OLIVER TWIST’S GROWTH, EDUCATION, AND BOARD
III RELATES HOW OLIVER TWIST WAS VERY NEAR GETTING A PLACE WHICH
WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN A SINECURE
IV OLIVER, BEING OFFERED ANOTHER PLACE, MAKES HIS FIRST ENTRY
INTO PUBLIC LIFE
V OLIVER MINGLES WITH NEW ASSOCIATES. GOING TO A FUNERAL FOR THE
FIRST TIME, HE FORMS AN UNFAVOURABLE NOTION OF HIS MASTER’S
BUSINESS
VI OLIVER, BEING GOADED BY THE TAUNTS OF NOAH, ROUSES INTO
ACTION, AND RATHER ASTONISHES HIM
VII OLIVER CONTINUES REFRACTORY
VIII OLIVER WALKS TO LONDON. HE ENCOUNTERS ON THE ROAD A STRANGE
SORT OF YOUNG GENTLEMAN
IX CONTAINING FURTHER PARTICULARS CONCERNING THE PLEASANT OLD
GENTLEMAN, AND HIS HOPEFUL PUPILS
X OLIVER BECOMES BETTER ACQUAINTED WITH THE CHARACTERS OF HIS
NEW ASSOCIATES; AND PURCHASES EXPERIENCE AT A HIGH PRICE.
BEING A SHORT, BUT VERY IMPORTANT CHAPTER, IN THIS HISTORY
XI TREATS OF MR. FANG THE POLICE MAGISTRATE; AND FURNISHES A
SLIGHT SPECIMEN OF HIS MODE OF ADMINISTERING JUSTICE
XII IN WHICH OLIVER IS TAKEN BETTER CARE OF THAN HE EVER WAS
BEFORE. AND IN WHICH THE NARRATIVE REVERTS TO THE MERRY OLD
GENTLEMAN AND HIS YOUTHFUL FRIENDS.
XIII SOME NEW ACQUAINTANCES ARE INTRODUCED TO THE INTELLIGENT
READER, CONNECTED WITH WHOM VARIOUS PLEASANT MATTERS ARE
RELATED, APPERTAINING TO THIS HISTORY
XIV COMPRISING FURTHER PARTICULARS OF OLIVER’S STAY AT MR.
BROWNLOW’S, WITH THE REMARKABLE PREDICTION WHICH ONE MR.
GRIMWIG UTTERED CONCERNING HIM, WHEN HE WENT OUT ON AN ERRAND
XV SHOWING HOW VERY FOND OF OLIVER TWIST, THE MERRY OLD JEW AND
MISS NANCY WERE
XVI RELATES WHAT BECAME OF OLIVER TWIST, AFTER HE HAD BEEN CLAIMED
BY NANCY
XVII OLIVER’S DESTINY CONTINUING UNPROPITIOUS, BRINGS A GREAT MAN
TO LONDON TO INJURE HIS REPUTATION
XVIII HOW OLIVER PASSED HIS TIME IN THE IMPROVING SOCIETY OF HIS
REPUTABLE FRIENDS
XIX IN WHICH A NOTABLE PLAN IS DISCUSSED AND DETERMINED ON
XX WHEREIN OLIVER IS DELIVERED OVER TO MR. WILLIAM SIKES
XXI THE EXPEDITION
XXII THE BURGLARY
XXIII WHICH CONTAINS THE SUBSTANCE OF A PLEASANT CONVERSATION
BETWEEN MR. BUMBLE AND A LADY; AND SHOWS THAT EVEN A BEADLE
MAY BE SUSCEPTIBLE ON SOME POINTS
XXIV TREATS ON A VERY POOR SUBJECT, BUT IS A SHORT ONE, AND MAY BE
FOUND OF IMPORTANCE IN THIS HISTORY
XXV WHEREIN THIS HISTORY REVERTS TO MR. FAGIN AND COMPANY
XXVI IN WHICH A MYSTERIOUS CHARACTER APPEARS UPON THE SCENE; AND
MANY THINGS, INSEPARABLE FROM THIS HISTORY, ARE DONE AND
PERFORMED
XXVII ATONES FOR THE UNPOLITENESS OF A FORMER CHAPTER; WHICH
DESERTED A LADY, MOST UNCEREMONIOUSLY
XXVIII LOOKS AFTER OLIVER, AND PROCEEDS WITH HIS ADVENTURES
XXIX HAS AN INTRODUCTORY ACCOUNT OF THE INMATES OF THE HOUSE, TO
WHICH OLIVER RESORTED
XXX RELATES WHAT OLIVER’S NEW VISITORS THOUGHT OF HIM
XXXI INVOLVES A CRITICAL POSITION
XXXII OF THE HAPPY LIFE OLIVER BEGAN TO LEAD WITH HIS KIND FRIENDS
XXXIII WHEREIN THE HAPPINESS OF OLIVER AND HIS FRIENDS, EXPERIENCES A
SUDDEN CHECK
XXXIV CONTAINS SOME INTRODUCTORY PARTICULARS RELATIVE TO A YOUNG
GENTLEMAN WHO NOW ARRIVES UPON THE SCENE; AND A NEW ADVENTURE
WHICH HAPPENED TO OLIVER
XXXV CONTAINING THE UNSATISFACTORY RESULT OF OLIVER’S ADVENTURE;
AND A CONVERSATION OF SOME IMPORTANCE BETWEEN HARRY MAYLIE AND
ROSE
XXXVI IS A VERY SHORT ONE, AND MAY APPEAR OF NO GREAT IMPORTANCE IN
ITS PLACE, BUT IT SHOULD BE READ NOTWITHSTANDING, AS A SEQUEL
TO THE LAST, AND A KEY TO ONE THAT WILL FOLLOW WHEN ITS TIME
ARRIVES
XXXVII IN WHICH THE READER MAY PERCEIVE A CONTRAST, NOT UNCOMMON IN
MATRIMONIAL CASES
XXXVIII CONTAINING AN ACCOUNT OF WHAT PASSED BETWEEN MR. AND MRS.
BUMBLE, AND MR. MONKS, AT THEIR NOCTURNAL INTERVIEW
XXXIX INTRODUCES SOME RESPECTABLE CHARACTERS WITH WHOM THE READER IS
ALREADY ACQUAINTED, AND SHOWS HOW MONKS AND THE JEW LAID THEIR
WORTHY HEADS TOGETHER
XL A STRANGE INTERVIEW, WHICH IS A SEQUEL TO THE LAST CHAMBER
XLI CONTAINING FRESH DISCOVERIES, AND SHOWING THAT SUPRISES, LIKE
MISFORTUNES, SELDOM COME ALONE
XLII AN OLD ACQUAINTANCE OF OLIVER’S, EXHIBITING DECIDED MARKS OF
GENIUS, BECOMES A PUBLIC CHARACTER IN THE METROPOLIS
XLIII WHEREIN IS SHOWN HOW THE ARTFUL DODGER GOT INTO TROUBLE
XLIV THE TIME ARRIVES FOR NANCY TO REDEEM HER PLEDGE TO ROSE
MAYLIE. SHE FAILS.
XLV NOAH CLAYPOLE IS EMPLOYED BY FAGIN ON A SECRET MISSION
XLVI THE APPOINTMENT KEPT
XLVII FATAL CONSEQUENCES
XLVIII THE FLIGHT OF SIKES
XLIX MONKS AND MR. BROWNLOW AT LENGTH MEET. THEIR CONVERSATION, AND
THE INTELLIGENCE THAT INTERRUPTS IT
L THE PURSUIT AND ESCAPE
LI AFFORDING AN EXPLANATION OF MORE MYSTERIES THAN ONE, AND
COMPREHENDING A PROPOSAL OF MARRIAGE WITH NO WORD OF
SETTLEMENT OR PIN-MONEY
LII FAGIN’S LAST NIGHT ALIVE
LIII AND LAST

Explanation ​

Since you haven’t provided a specific excerpt from Oliver Twist, I’ll analyze Chapter II ("TREATS OF OLIVER TWIST’S GROWTH, EDUCATION, AND BOARD") as a representative passage, as it is one of the most thematically rich and stylistically characteristic sections of the novel. Below is a detailed breakdown of the chapter’s content, themes, literary devices, and significance, with a focus on close textual analysis.

Excerpt for Analysis: Oliver Twist, Chapter II ​

(Summary of key passages for context—full text can be found in public domain editions.) The chapter describes Oliver’s early years in the workhouse, where he and other orphaned children are starved, neglected, and subjected to brutal "education" by the parish authorities. The most famous moment occurs when Oliver, driven by hunger, dares to ask for "more" gruel—an act that shocks the overseers and leads to his punishment.

Key Passages for Close Reading: ​

  1. The Workhouse System and Child Neglect:

    "The members of this board were very sage, deep, philosophical men; and when they came to turn their attention to the workhouse, they found out at once, what ordinary folks would never have discovered—the poor people liked it! It was a regular place of public entertainment for the poorer classes; a tavern where there was nothing to pay; a public breakfast, dinner, tea, and supper all the year round; a brick and mortar elysium, where it was all play and no work. 'Oho!' said the board, looking very knowing; 'we are the fellows to set this to rights; we’ll stop it all, in no time.'"

  2. The Starvation of the Children:

    "The boys polished the bowls with their spoons till they shone again; and when they had performed this operation (which never took very long, the spoons being nearly as large as the bowls), they would sit staring at the copper, with such eager eyes, as if they could have devoured the very bricks of which it was composed; employing themselves, meanwhile, in sucking their fingers most assiduously, with the view of catching up any stray splashes of gruel that might have been cast thereon."

  3. Oliver’s Rebellion:

    "'Please, sir,' replied Oliver, 'I want some more.'The master was a fat, healthy man; but he turned very pale. He gazed in stupefied astonishment on the small rebel for some seconds, and then clung for support to the copper. The assistants were paralysed with wonder; the boys with fear.'What!' said the master at length, in a faint voice.'Please, sir,' replied Oliver, 'I want some more.'"

Detailed Explanation ​

1. Context and Background ​

  • Historical Context: Oliver Twist (1838) was Dickens’ second novel, written during the Victorian era, when England’s Poor Laws (1834) forced destitute people into workhouses—institutions designed to be so harsh that only the truly desperate would seek relief. Dickens, who had experienced poverty as a child, critiques this system’s cruelty.
  • Literary Context: The novel is a social protest novel and a Bildungsroman (coming-of-age story), blending satire, melodrama, and realism. This chapter establishes the hypocrisy of authority and the plight of the poor, key themes throughout the book.

2. Themes in the Excerpt ​

A. The Brutality of Institutional Power ​
  • The parish board (local government officials) are portrayed as willfully ignorant and cruel. Their belief that the poor "like" the workhouse is darkly ironic—Dickens exposes their delusional logic to justify starvation.
  • The master’s reaction to Oliver’s request ("turned very pale," "clung for support") suggests that the system is so oppressive that even a child’s plea for food is seen as a threat to authority.
B. Childhood Innocence vs. Systemic Corruption ​
  • Oliver is not yet corrupted by the world’s cruelty—his request is instinctive, not rebellious. The adults, however, interpret it as defiance, showing how institutions criminalize basic human needs.
  • The other boys’ fear ("paralysed with wonder") highlights how the system has already broken their spirits.
C. Hunger as a Metaphor for Social Injustice ​
  • The gruel symbolizes the meager, dehumanizing rations given to the poor. The boys’ desperation (licking bowls, sucking fingers) is a physical manifestation of societal neglect.
  • Oliver’s "more" is not just about food—it’s a demand for dignity, making it a radical act in this context.

3. Literary Devices ​

A. Irony and Satire ​
  • Verbal Irony: The board’s claim that the poor "like" the workhouse is mocking their hypocrisy.
  • Situational Irony: The idea that a starving child asking for food is treated as a shocking crime.
  • Satire of Authority: The over-the-top reactions of the master and board members expose their absurdity.
B. Imagery and Symbolism ​
  • Gruel as a Symbol: The watery, insufficient gruel represents the empty promises of the welfare system.
  • Animalistic Imagery: The boys are described like starving animals ("sucking their fingers," "devoured the very bricks"), emphasizing their dehumanization.
  • Light/Dark Contrast: The shining bowls (from polishing) vs. the dark, hungry eyes of the children highlights the harshness of their reality.
C. Repetition and Rhythm ​
  • The repetition of "more" in Oliver’s request makes it unforgettable—a simple word that becomes a powerful indictment of the system.
  • The short, clipped sentences during the master’s reaction ("What! ... Please, sir ... I want some more.") create dramatic tension.
D. Narrative Voice and Tone ​
  • Dickens’ third-person omniscient narrator is sarcastic and moralizing, guiding the reader to condemn the system.
  • The tone shifts from dark humor to horror—the board’s absurdity gives way to the tragic reality of Oliver’s punishment.

4. Significance of the Excerpt ​

A. Oliver as a Symbol of Resistance ​
  • Oliver’s "more" is one of the most iconic moments in literature—it represents the first spark of defiance against oppression.
  • Unlike later characters (like the Artful Dodger or Fagin), Oliver is pure and uncorrupted, making his suffering more poignant.
B. Critique of Victorian Society ​
  • Dickens exposes the failures of the Poor Laws, arguing that poverty is not a moral failing but a systemic one.
  • The chapter humanizes the poor, countering the Victorian belief that they were lazy or undeserving.
C. Foreshadowing Oliver’s Journey ​
  • This moment sets up Oliver’s future struggles—his innocence will be tested as he enters the criminal underworld.
  • The harsh punishment for his request foreshadows how society will continue to fail him.
D. Cultural Impact ​
  • The phrase "Please, sir, I want some more" has entered popular culture as a shorthand for oppression and resistance.
  • The chapter influenced social reform movements, helping shift public opinion on child labor and welfare.

5. Connection to the Rest of the Novel ​

  • Contrast with Fagin’s World: Later, Oliver is taken in by Fagin’s gang, where he is exploited but also shown false kindness. This chapter establishes that even the workhouse was preferable to the criminal underworld.
  • Mr. Brownlow as a Counterpoint: The kindly Mr. Brownlow (who later helps Oliver) is the antithesis of the workhouse master, showing that individual compassion can exist amid systemic cruelty.
  • Nancy’s Redemption: Nancy, a product of the same system, becomes a complex figure—both a victim and an enabler of corruption, unlike Oliver’s untainted innocence.

Conclusion: Why This Chapter Matters ​

Chapter II is not just an introduction to Oliver’s suffering—it’s a microcosm of Dickens’ entire social critique. Through sharp satire, vivid imagery, and a heartbreakingly simple request for "more," Dickens:

  1. Exposes the hypocrisy of authority,
  2. Humanizes the poor,
  3. Sets up Oliver as a symbolic figure of resistance, and
  4. Lays the groundwork for the novel’s central conflict: innocence vs. corruption.

This excerpt remains powerful today because it challenges systemic injustice—a theme that resonates whenever society fails its most vulnerable.

Would you like a close analysis of a different chapter or passage? I can provide the same level of detail for any other excerpt from Oliver Twist.