Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Editorials from the Hearst Newspapers, by Arthur Brisbane

CONTENTS
Why Are All Men Gamblers?
No Man Understands Iron
We Long for Immortal Imperfection--We Can't Have It.
Three Water-Drops Converse
Did We Once Live on the Moon?
William Henry Channing's Symphony
The Existence of God--Parable of the Blind Kittens
Have the Animals Souls?
Jesus' Attitude Toward Children
Study of the Character of God
The Fascinating Problem of Immortality
Discontent the Motive Power of Progress
The Automobile Will Make Us More Human
Let Us Be Thankful
The Harm That Is Done by Our Friends
Shall We Tame and Chain the Invisible Microbe As We Now Chain
Niagara?
The Elephant That Will Not Move Has Better Excuses Than We Have
for Folly Displayed
Let Us Be Thankful
What Will 999 Years Mean to the Human Race?
The Azores--A Small Lost World in a Universe of Water
No Napoleonic Chess Player on an Air Cushion
A Girl's Face in the Gaslight
The "Criminal" Class
The Wonderful Magnet
Who Is Independent? Nobody
When We Begin Using Land Under the Oceans
Where Your Body Came From
How Marriage Began
Man's Willingness to Work
The Human Brain Beats the Coal Mines
How the Other Planets Will Talk to Us
Shall We Do Without Sleep Some Day?
The Three Best Things in the World
The Value of Solitude
There Should Be a Monument to Time
A Mother's Work and Her Hopes
Your Work Is Your Brain's Gymnasium
The Steeple, Moving Like the Hand of a Clock
Cultivate Thought-Teach Your Brain to Work Early
The Wind Does Not Rule Your Destiny
One of the Many Corpses in the Johnstown Mine
"Limiting the Amount of a Day's Work"
Catching a Red-Hot Bolt
The Trusts and the Union--How Do They Differ?
France Has Learned Her Lesson
Union Men as Slave Owners
Again the Limited Day's Work
To the Merchants
What About the Chinese, Kind Sir?
150 against 150,000--We Favor the 150,000
To-day's World-Struggle
White-Rabbit Millionaires and Other Things
No Happiness Save in Mental and Physical Activity
The Owner of a Golden Mountain
The Human Weeds in Prison
Crime Is Dying Out
The Value of Poverty to the World
600 Teachers Now, 600,000 Good Americans in the Future
Education--The First Duty of Government
Poverty Is the Father of Vice, Crime and Failure
The Importance of Education Proved in Lincoln's Case
Knowledge Is Growth
A Whiskey Bottle
Those Who Laugh at a Drunken Man
Law Cannot Stop Drunkenness--Education Can
The Drunkard's Side of It
Drink a Slow Poison
To Those Who Drink Hard--You Have Slipped the Belt
Try Whiskey on Your Friend's Eyeball
What Are the Ten Best Books?
The Marvelous Balance of the Universe--A Lesson in the Texas Flood
The Earth Is Only a Front Yard
Last Week's Baby Will Surely Talk Some Day
The Good That Is Done by the Trusts
Trusts and the Senate
The Promising Toad's Head
Trusts Will Drive Labor Unions Into Politics
The Trusts Are National School Teachers
A Woman to Be Pitied
When Will Woman's Mental Life Begin?
The Cow That Kicks Her Weaned Calf Is All Heart
Respectable Women Who Listen to "Faust"
Why Women Should Vote
Astronomy- Woman's Future Work
Woman's Vanity Is Useful
To Editorial Writers--Adopt Ruskin's Main Idea
Imagination Without Dreaming the Secret of Material Success
The One Who Needs No Statue
The Vast Importance of Sleep
Woman Sustains, Guides and Controls the World
The Story of the Complaining Diamond
Don't Be in a Hurry, Young Gentlemen
hen the Baby Changed Into a Fourteen-year-old
The Eye That Weighs a Ton
What Animal Controls Your Spirit?
From Mammoths to Mosquitoes--From Murder to Hypocrisy
The Monkey and the Snake Fight
Too Little and Too Much
Do You Feel Discouraged?
Two Kinds of Discontent
What the Bartender Sees
What Should Be a Man's Object in Life?
Cruel Frightening of Children
It Is Natural for Children to Be Cruel
Two Thin Little Babies Are Left
A Baby Can Educate a Man

The articles in this book were published originally in the
editorial columns of the various Hearst newspapers throughout the
country.

These articles may have some interest for the student of modern
happenings, because of the fact that the newspapers publishing
them have an aggregate daily circulation of two millions of
copies, and are read each day by no fewer than five millions of
men and women. Such wide circulation of identical opinions on
current events, in different parts of the country, is a new
feature of our national life. The character of such writings, and
their probable influence upon the public mind, whatever their
lack of intrinsic merit, may be of sufficient importance to
justify the publication of this collection of ephemeral writings.

Explanation ​

Arthur Brisbane’s Editorials from the Hearst Newspapers (1911) is a collection of short, provocative essays originally published in the early 20th century under the banner of William Randolph Hearst’s vast media empire. These editorials reflect the populist, sensationalist, and often moralizing tone of Hearst’s newspapers, which shaped public opinion on politics, science, social issues, and philosophy. Brisbane, Hearst’s star editor, was known for his punchy, aphoristic style—blending folksy wisdom, speculative science, and social commentary to engage a mass audience.

The table of contents alone reveals the eclectic, sometimes contradictory, and always attention-grabbing nature of Brisbane’s work. Below is a detailed breakdown of the themes, literary devices, context, and significance of the collection, with a focus on how the titles and structure themselves convey meaning.

1. Context: The Hearst Empire and Early 20th-Century Journalism ​

  • William Randolph Hearst was a media mogul who pioneered "yellow journalism"—sensational, emotionally charged reporting designed to sell papers. His newspapers (e.g., New York Journal, San Francisco Examiner) reached millions, making them a powerful force in shaping American thought.
  • Arthur Brisbane was Hearst’s right-hand man, a master of concise, punchy prose that mixed moral lessons, scientific curiosity, and social critique. His editorials were designed to be accessible, thought-provoking, and sometimes inflammatory, reflecting Hearst’s strategy of blending entertainment with opinion.
  • The early 1900s were a time of rapid industrialization, labor struggles, scientific discovery (e.g., relativity, psychology), and social reform (women’s suffrage, temperance, education movements). Brisbane’s topics mirror these concerns, often framing them in dramatic, personal, or allegorical terms.

2. Themes in the Editorials ​

The titles alone reveal Brisbane’s broad intellectual curiosity and his tendency to anthropomorphize, moralize, and speculate. Key themes include:

A. Human Nature and Psychology ​

  • "Why Are All Men Gamblers?" – Explores risk-taking as an innate trait, possibly linking it to capitalism or evolutionary behavior.
  • "Discontent the Motive Power of Progress" – A classic Brisbane thesis: dissatisfaction drives innovation (a proto-Nietzschean or capitalist idea).
  • "It Is Natural for Children to Be Cruel" – A Darwinian take on childhood behavior, possibly reflecting early psychological theories (e.g., Freud’s Civilization and Its Discontents).
  • "What Animal Controls Your Spirit?" – Suggests that human behavior is governed by primal instincts (a theme in early 20th-century psychology).

B. Science, Technology, and Futurism ​

  • "Did We Once Live on the Moon?" – Speculative science (possibly influenced by early astronautical theories or H.G. Wells).
  • "The Automobile Will Make Us More Human" – A paradoxical claim that technology enhances humanity (contrasting with later critiques of dehumanization).
  • "When We Begin Using Land Under the Oceans" – Futuristic musings on human expansion, akin to Jules Verne.
  • "How the Other Planets Will Talk to Us" – Reflects early 20th-century fascination with extraterrestrial communication (e.g., Marconi’s radio experiments).

C. Social and Political Commentary ​

  • "The 'Criminal' Class" – Likely a discussion on nature vs. nurture in crime, possibly influenced by Lombroso’s criminal anthropology.
  • "Trusts and the Union—How Do They Differ?" – A direct engagement with labor vs. corporate power, a major issue in the Progressive Era.
  • "Poverty Is the Father of Vice, Crime and Failure" – A deterministic view of poverty’s role in society, possibly critiquing laissez-faire economics.
  • "Woman’s Vanity Is Useful" – A mix of traditional gender roles and early feminist arguments, reflecting the era’s debates on women’s rights.

D. Religion, Morality, and Existential Questions ​

  • "The Existence of God—Parable of the Blind Kittens" – Uses allegory to discuss faith, possibly critiquing organized religion.
  • "Jesus’ Attitude Toward Children" – Moralizing piece, likely contrasting purity with adult corruption.
  • "The Fascinating Problem of Immortality" – Engages with spiritualism and scientific immortality theories (e.g., metaphysical movements of the time).
  • "Drink a Slow Poison" – Temperance movement propaganda, framing alcohol as both a personal and societal ill.

E. Education and Self-Improvement ​

  • "Your Work Is Your Brain’s Gymnasium" – A self-help mantra, reflecting the era’s emphasis on industrial efficiency and mental discipline.
  • "Cultivate Thought—Teach Your Brain to Work Early" – Echoes the Protestant work ethic and the rise of scientific management (Taylorism).
  • "Knowledge Is Growth" – A Progressive Era belief in education as the key to social mobility (see also: "Education—The First Duty of Government").

F. Whimsy, Allegory, and Anthropomorphism ​

  • "Three Water-Drops Converse" – A fable-like piece, possibly discussing unity or the interconnectedness of nature.
  • "The Cow That Kicks Her Weaned Calf Is All Heart" – Uses animal behavior as a metaphor for human emotions (a common Brisbane tactic).
  • "The Story of the Complaining Diamond" – A satirical or moral allegory, possibly critiquing human ingratitude or materialism.

3. Literary Devices and Stylistic Techniques ​

Brisbane’s writing is short, punchy, and designed for mass appeal. Key devices include:

A. Provocative Titles ​

  • Many titles are questions, paradoxes, or dramatic statements designed to hook the reader:
    • "No Man Understands Iron" (mystery)
    • "Shall We Tame and Chain the Invisible Microbe?" (science + power)
    • "The Human Weeds in Prison" (metaphor + social critique)
  • Some are allegorical or fable-like:
    • "Parable of the Blind Kittens"
    • "The Monkey and the Snake Fight"

B. Anthropomorphism & Personification ​

  • Brisbane often gives human traits to animals, objects, or abstract concepts:
    • "Three Water-Drops Converse" (nature as sentient)
    • "The Steeple, Moving Like the Hand of a Clock" (time as a physical force)
    • "The Cow That Kicks Her Weaned Calf Is All Heart" (animal emotions as human-like)

C. Juxtaposition & Contrast ​

  • Many titles pair opposites to create tension:
    • "Too Little and Too Much"
    • "From Mammoths to Mosquitoes—From Murder to Hypocrisy"
    • "The Good That Is Done by the Trusts" (contrasting with their usual villainy in Progressive discourse)

D. Rhetorical Questions & Direct Address ​

  • Brisbane engages the reader directly, making them feel part of a conversation:
    • "What Will 999 Years Mean to the Human Race?"
    • "What Are the Ten Best Books?"
    • "To the Merchants" (direct appeal)

E. Allegory & Parable ​

  • Many pieces use simple stories to convey complex ideas:
    • "The Parable of the Blind Kittens" (faith vs. reason)
    • "The Story of the Complaining Diamond" (human dissatisfaction)

F. Sensationalism & Hyperbole ​

  • Hearst’s newspapers thrived on dramatic language:
    • "One of the Many Corpses in the Johnstown Mine" (graphic, emotional)
    • "Try Whiskey on Your Friend’s Eyeball" (shock value for temperance message)

4. Significance of the Collection ​

A. Reflection of Early 20th-Century Thought ​

  • The editorials capture the optimism, anxieties, and contradictions of the Progressive Era:
    • Faith in science and technology ("How the Other Planets Will Talk to Us")
    • Fear of industrialization’s dehumanizing effects ("The Harm That Is Done by Our Friends")
    • Debates on labor, capitalism, and social reform ("Trusts Will Drive Labor Unions Into Politics")
    • Moral panics (temperance, crime, education)

B. Mass Media as a Shaper of Public Opinion ​

  • Hearst’s newspapers democratized ideas—for better or worse. Brisbane’s editorials were not deep philosophy, but they made complex topics accessible to millions.
  • The repetition of themes (e.g., education, work ethic, temperance) suggests propaganda-like reinforcement of certain values.

C. Brisbane’s Unique Voice ​

  • His style blends:
    • Folksy wisdom ("Let Us Be Thankful")
    • Pseudo-scientific speculation ("Did We Once Live on the Moon?")
    • Moralizing ("Cruel Frightening of Children")
    • Satire ("The Owner of a Golden Mountain")
  • This eclecticism made him both influential and criticized—some saw him as a populist thinker, others as a sensationalist hack.

D. Influence on Later Journalism & Op-Ed Culture ​

  • Brisbane’s short, opinionated, engaging style foreshadows modern op-eds, blogging, and even social media hot takes.
  • His mix of fact, speculation, and moralizing is seen today in clickbait journalism and partisan media.

5. Close Reading of Select Titles (Examples) ​

To demonstrate how Brisbane’s titles alone convey meaning:

"No Man Understands Iron" ​

  • Possible Meaning: Iron symbolizes industrialization, strength, and cold rationality. The title suggests that humans are at the mercy of forces they don’t fully grasp (technology, fate, or their own creations).
  • Literary Device: Metonymy (iron = industrialization) + paradox (we use iron daily but don’t "understand" it).
  • Context: Early 20th-century fear/awe of machinery (cf. Charlie Chaplin’s Modern Times).

"The Automobile Will Make Us More Human" ​

  • Possible Meaning: Cars free us from physical limits, fostering connection and progress. (Contrasts with later critiques of cars as isolating.)
  • Literary Device: Paradox (technology as humanizing).
  • Context: The Model T (1908) was transforming society; Brisbane frames it as liberating.

"Poverty Is the Father of Vice, Crime and Failure" ​

  • Possible Meaning: A deterministic view of poverty as the root of social ills, possibly arguing for welfare or education reform.
  • Literary Device: Metaphor (poverty as a "father" = causative force).
  • Context: Progressive Era debates on inequality (cf. Jacob Riis’ How the Other Half Lives).

"The Cow That Kicks Her Weaned Calf Is All Heart" ​

  • Possible Meaning: Maternal love is tough but necessary—a defense of discipline as care.
  • Literary Device: Anthropomorphism + irony (violent act framed as loving).
  • Context: Reflects Victorian/Edwardian ideals of parenting (strictness = love).

"Try Whiskey on Your Friend’s Eyeball" ​

  • Possible Meaning: A shock tactic to show alcohol’s harm—imagine the pain!
  • Literary Device: Hyperbole + visceral imagery.
  • Context: Temperance movement (early 1900s, leading to Prohibition in 1920).

6. Criticisms and Limitations ​

While Brisbane’s work was widely read, it was also criticized for:

  • Over-simplification: Complex issues reduced to catchy phrases.
  • Sensationalism: Prioritizing drama over depth.
  • Contradictions: E.g., praising trusts in one editorial ("The Good That Is Done by the Trusts") while critiquing them in another.
  • Moralizing Tone: Sometimes preachy or judgmental (e.g., on drunkenness, parenting).

7. Conclusion: Why This Collection Matters ​

Brisbane’s editorials are a time capsule of early 1900s American thought, blending:

  • Scientific curiosity (space, microbes, the brain)
  • Social reform (labor, education, temperance)
  • Moral storytelling (parables, allegories)
  • Populist rhetoric (direct, emotional, accessible)

While not high literature, they exemplify how mass media shapes public discourse—a precursor to today’s opinion journalism, TED Talks, and viral think pieces. The titles alone reveal a mind obsessed with big questions, even if the answers were often simplistic or sensational.

For modern readers, the collection offers:

  • A window into Progressive Era debates.
  • A study in persuasive writing techniques.
  • A warning about media’s power to influence—for better or worse.

Would you like a deeper dive into any specific editorial from the list?