Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Arizona Sketches, by J. A. Munk

A stranger on first entering Arizona is impressed with the newness and
wildness that surrounds him. Indeed, the change is so great that it
seems like going to sleep and waking up in a new world. Everything
that he sees is different from the familiar objects of his home, and he
is filled with wonder and amazement at the many curious things that are
brought to his notice. Judging the country by what is common back
east, the average man is disappointed and prejudiced against what he
sees; but, estimated on its merits, it is found to be a land of many
attractions and great possibilities.

A hasty trip through the country by rail gives no adequate idea of its
intrinsic value, as such a limited view only affords a superficial
glimpse of what should be leisurely and carefully examined to be
properly understood or appreciated. At the first glance it presents
the appearance of a desert, but to one who is acquainted with its
peculiarities it is by no means desolate. It furnishes a strong
contrast to the rolling woodlands of the far east, and to the boundless
prairies of the middle west; and, though it may never develop on the
plan of the older states, like California, it has an individuality and
charm of its own; and its endowment of natural wealth and beauty
requires no borrowing from neighbors to give it character or success.

It has grand scenery, a salubrious climate, productive soil, rich
mineral deposits and rare archaeological remains. It also has a
diversified fauna and flora. The peccary, Gila monster, tarantula,
centipede, scorpion and horned toad are specimens of its strange animal
life; and, the numerous species of cacti, yucca, maguey, palo verde and
mistletoe are samples of its curious vegetation. It is, indeed, the
scientist's Paradise where much valuable material can be found to
enrich almost every branch of natural science.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Arizona Sketches by J. A. Munk ​

Context of the Source ​

Arizona Sketches (1909) by Jacob A. Munk is a collection of observational essays and descriptions of Arizona’s landscape, wildlife, and culture during the early 20th century. Munk, a naturalist and writer, sought to document the unique characteristics of the Arizona Territory (which became a state in 1912) at a time when it was still largely unfamiliar to most Americans. His work reflects the Romantic and Naturalist traditions of American frontier literature, blending scientific observation with an appreciation for the sublime and unusual.

This excerpt serves as an introductory impression of Arizona, contrasting it with the more familiar landscapes of the eastern and midwestern U.S. Munk’s perspective is that of an outsider-turned-advocate, initially struck by the region’s strangeness but ultimately convinced of its hidden beauty and value.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. The Shock of the Unfamiliar & First Impressions

    • Munk emphasizes the disorienting contrast between Arizona and the "familiar objects" of the East. The stranger experiences a dreamlike transformation ("like going to sleep and waking up in a new world"), suggesting both wonder and disorientation.
    • The prejudice of the "average man"—who judges Arizona by eastern standards—highlights a common theme in frontier literature: the misunderstanding of arid landscapes as barren or worthless until properly examined.

  2. The Deceptive Nature of Appearances

    • Arizona is not a true desert in the sense of lifelessness, but its unfamiliarity makes it seem desolate to outsiders. Munk argues that superficial observation (e.g., a "hasty trip by rail") fails to reveal its true nature.
    • The land’s individuality is key—it does not conform to eastern models of fertility (rolling woodlands, prairies) but has its own unique beauty and potential.

  3. Natural Wealth and Scientific Value

    • Munk presents Arizona as a treasure trove for scientists and explorers, listing its geological, biological, and archaeological riches:
      • Grand scenery (likely referring to the Grand Canyon, canyons, and mesas)
      • Salubrious (healthful) climate (dry air, low humidity—often praised for therapeutic benefits)
      • Productive soil (contradicting the "desert" stereotype—areas like the Salt River Valley were fertile with irrigation)
      • Mineral deposits (copper, silver, gold—key to Arizona’s economic growth)
      • Archaeological remains (Ancestral Puebloan, Hohokam, and other Indigenous sites)
      • Biodiversity (unique flora and fauna, some found nowhere else)

  4. The Sublime and the Strange

    • Munk’s description of Arizona’s odd and sometimes frightening wildlife (Gila monsters, tarantulas, scorpions) and bizarre plant life (cacti, yucca) evokes the American sublime—a mix of awe, fear, and fascination with the untamed.
    • The land is not just different but alien to eastern sensibilities, reinforcing the idea that Arizona defies easy categorization.

  5. Self-Sufficiency and Distinct Identity

    • Unlike California (which Munk implies borrowed from eastern models of development), Arizona’s character is inherent—it does not need to mimic other regions to be valuable.
    • This reflects regional pride and a rejection of the idea that the West must conform to eastern expectations.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Contrast & Juxtaposition

    • East vs. West: Munk repeatedly contrasts Arizona with the "rolling woodlands of the far east" and "boundless prairies of the middle west" to emphasize its uniqueness.
    • Superficial vs. Deep Observation: A "hasty trip by rail" vs. "leisurely and carefully examined" underscores that true understanding requires immersion.

  2. Imagery & Sensory Language

    • Visual: "newness and wildness," "curious things," "grand scenery"
    • Tactile/Implied: The mention of Gila monsters, tarantulas, and scorpions evokes a visceral reaction—fear, curiosity, or disgust—making the land feel alive in an unsettling way.
    • Olfactory/Gustatory (implied): While not explicit, the mention of mistletoe, palo verde, and cacti suggests a distinct, earthy, sometimes harsh sensory experience.

  3. Metaphor & Simile

    • "Like going to sleep and waking up in a new world" → The dream metaphor suggests both disorientation and wonder, as if Arizona exists in a different reality.
    • "Scientist’s Paradise" → Frames Arizona as a land of discovery, not just a frontier to be tamed but a laboratory of nature.

  4. Enumeration (Listing)

    • Munk catalogs Arizona’s attributes (scenery, climate, soil, minerals, archaeology, fauna, flora) to overwhelm the reader with evidence of its richness. This accumulation of detail reinforces his argument that Arizona is far more than a desert.

  5. Personification & Anthropomorphism

    • The land has "individuality and charm"—it is almost alive, with a personality of its own.
    • The implication that Arizona "requires no borrowing from neighbors" gives it a defiant, independent character.

  6. Tone Shift

    • Begins with astonishment and slight defensiveness ("the average man is disappointed") but shifts to pride and enthusiasm as Munk lists its virtues.
    • The persuasive tone suggests he is countering stereotypes—Arizona is not a wasteland but a land of opportunity.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. Challenging Eastern Perceptions of the West

    • Munk’s essay reflects a broader 19th-20th century debate about the American West: Was it a barren desert or a land of hidden potential?
    • His work aligns with boosters (promoters of western settlement) who argued that regions like Arizona were undervalued due to ignorance.

  2. Naturalism & Early Environmentalism

    • While not an environmentalist in the modern sense, Munk’s detailed observations prefigure later ecological appreciation of deserts.
    • His scientific curiosity contrasts with the exploitative mindset of many frontier narratives, which saw the West only for its resources.

  3. Regional Identity & Statehood

    • Written just before Arizona’s statehood (1912), this passage advocates for Arizona’s uniqueness as a reason for its inclusion in the Union.
    • The insistence that Arizona has "an individuality and charm of its own" is a political statement—it deserves recognition on its own terms.

  4. The Myth of the "Empty" West

    • Munk subverts the idea of the West as an empty canvas by highlighting its rich Indigenous history ("archaeological remains") and complex ecosystems.
    • This counters the Manifest Destiny narrative, which often depicted the West as waiting to be "filled" by settlers.

  5. Literary Influence

    • Munk’s style echoes earlier frontier writers like John Muir (naturalist wonder) and Mark Twain (humorous yet sharp observations) but with a more scientific bent.
    • His work also foreshadows Southwestern literature (e.g., Mary Austin, Edward Abbey), which celebrates the harsh beauty of deserts.

Line-by-Line Breakdown of Key Sections ​

  1. "A stranger on first entering Arizona is impressed with the newness and wildness that surrounds him."

    • First impression = overwhelming difference. The word "wildness" carries both negative (untamed, dangerous) and positive (free, natural) connotations.

  2. "Judging the country by what is common back east, the average man is disappointed and prejudiced against what he sees..."

    • Critique of eastern bias—people expect familiar landscapes (forests, prairies) and dismiss Arizona when it doesn’t conform.
    • "Prejudiced" suggests ignorance, not objective judgment.

  3. "At the first glance it presents the appearance of a desert, but to one who is acquainted with its peculiarities it is by no means desolate."

    • Key argument: Deserts are not lifeless—they are different ecosystems.
    • "Peculiarities" implies strangeness, but also uniqueness.

  4. "It furnishes a strong contrast to the rolling woodlands of the far east, and to the boundless prairies of the middle west..."

    • Tripartite division of America:
      • East = forests (civilization, history)
      • Midwest = prairies (agriculture, expansion)
      • West = deserts (mystery, potential)
    • Arizona doesn’t fit either model, so it must be judged differently.

  5. "The peccary, Gila monster, tarantula, centipede, scorpion and horned toad are specimens of its strange animal life..."

    • List of "monstrous" creatures—some dangerous, some merely odd—evokes fear and fascination.
    • The horned toad (actually a lizard) was a symbol of the West, often mythologized in frontier tales.

  6. "It is, indeed, the scientist's Paradise where much valuable material can be found to enrich almost every branch of natural science."

    • Final persuasive flourish: Arizona is not just scenic or economically valuable—it is intellectually vital.
    • "Paradise" = utopian language, framing Arizona as a land of knowledge and discovery.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

Munk’s excerpt is more than a travelogue—it is a defense of Arizona’s worth against eastern skepticism. By contrasting perception with reality, he argues that true understanding requires patience and an open mind. His blend of scientific detail and poetic appreciation makes the passage both informative and evocative, capturing the paradox of the desert: harsh yet beautiful, strange yet rich, empty yet teeming with life.

In the broader context of American frontier literature, Munk’s work bridges the gap between romanticized wilderness narratives and modern environmentalism, offering a nuanced view of a land that defies easy categorization. His writing invites the reader to look closer—to see not just a desert, but a world of its own.