Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Round-Up: A Romance of Arizona; Novelized from Edmund Day's Melodrama, by John Murray

Rendered thirsty by his exertions, Lane remembered the canteen in the
bisnaga, which he had forgotten among his other preparations for
defense. He cautiously reached his hand over the ledge, and secured
the precious vessel, but, as he was withdrawing it, PING! came a bullet
through the canteen, knocking it out of his hand. As it fell clattering
down the side of the ledge, he groaned: "Damned good shooting! They've
probably left their best marksman below with the ponies. No hope for
escape on that side. Well, there's some consolation in the thought that
they'll undoubtedly finish me before I get too damned thirsty. Glad it
wasn't my hand."

Although the period he spent waiting for the attack was less than an
hour by his watch, it seemed to last so long that he had hopes that the
Rurales would appear in time to rescue him. His spirits rose with the
prospect. Looking about him at the walls, the fireplace, and the red
cross, he reflected: "I am not the first man, or even the first white
man, that has withstood an attack in this place." In imagination he
constructed the history of the fort. Here, in ages remote, a tribe of
Indians, defeated and driven to the mountains had constructed an
outpost against their enemies of the plain, but these had captured the
stronghold, and fortified it against its former occupants. Later, a
band of Spanish gold-seekers had made a stand here against natives whom
they had roused against them by oppression. Or, perhaps, as indicated
by the cross, it had afforded refuge to the Mission Fathers, those
heroic souls who had faced the horrors of the infernolike desert in
their saintly efforts to convert its fiendish inhabitants.

With the symbol of Christianity in his mind, Lane turned toward the
giant cactus, which he had heretofore regarded chiefly in the aspect of
a flagpole, and saw in its columnar trunk and opposing branches a
distinct resemblance to a cross. The plant was dead, and dry as punk.
Suddenly there flashed into his mind a hideous suggestion. More cruel
than even the Romans, the inventors of crucifixion, the Apaches are
wont to bind their captives to these dead cacti, which supply at once
scourging thorns, binding stake, and consuming fuel, and, kindling a
fire at the top, leave it to burn slowly down to the victim, and, long
before it despatches him, to twist his body and limbs into what appear
to the Apache sense of humor to be exquisitely ludicrous contortions.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Round-Up: A Romance of Arizona ​

Context of the Source ​

The Round-Up: A Romance of Arizona (1908) is a novelization of Edmund Day’s melodrama, adapted by John Murray. Set in the late 19th-century American Southwest, the story follows cowboys, outlaws, and lawmen in the rugged Arizona Territory, blending adventure, romance, and frontier violence. The excerpt focuses on a moment of intense suspense as the protagonist, Lane, is trapped in an old fort, besieged by hostile forces (likely Apaches or Mexican Rurales—government-mounted police).

The novel reflects the Western genre’s preoccupations with survival, masculinity, and the myth of the "noble frontier." It also draws on historical tensions between white settlers, Native Americans, and Mexican authorities, often portraying Indigenous peoples as savage antagonists—a trope common in early 20th-century Western literature.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. Survival and Desperation

    • Lane’s immediate struggle is for water and life, symbolized by the destroyed canteen. His dry humor ("Glad it wasn’t my hand") masks his vulnerability, reinforcing the stoic cowboy archetype.
    • The psychological toll of waiting is emphasized: time distorts ("less than an hour... seemed to last so long"), and his mind wanders to rescue fantasies (Rurales arriving) and historical musings to distract from his predicament.

  2. Colonial Violence and Historical Erasure

    • Lane’s imagined history of the fort reflects the layered violence of the Southwest:
      • Native conflicts (tribes warring over the fort)
      • Spanish conquest (gold-seekers and missionary oppression)
      • Apache resistance (implied in the "fiendish inhabitants" line)
    • The red cross symbolizes both Christian martyrdom and colonial imposition, framing Indigenous resistance as "fiendish" while glorifying European suffering.
    • The cactus crucifixion anecdote reinforces savage vs. civilized binaries, a racist trope used to justify white expansion.

  3. Fate and Irony

    • Lane’s dark humor ("they’ll finish me before I get too damned thirsty") underscores his acceptance of death, a common Western trope where men face mortality with grit.
    • The cactus as a cross is a grotesque irony: a symbol of salvation becomes an instrument of torture, mirroring the hypocrisy of colonial "civilization."

  4. Nature as Adversary

    • The Arizona desert is a hostile, biblical landscape ("infernolike desert"), where survival is a test of endurance.
    • The dead cactus symbolizes decay and cruelty, contrasting with Lane’s initial practical view of it as a "flagpole."

Literary Devices ​

  1. Imagery & Symbolism

    • The canteen: Represents hope and its destruction—Lane’s last lifeline is shattered by a bullet, foreshadowing his doom.
    • The red cross: Ambiguous symbol—faith, sacrifice, or colonial violence? Its presence invites Lane (and the reader) to romanticize missionary "heroism" while ignoring Indigenous perspectives.
    • The cactus: Transforms from a practical object (flagpole) to a tool of torture, embodying the duality of the frontier (beauty and brutality).

  2. Foreshadowing & Suspense

    • The bullet through the canteen hints at the precision of his enemies, raising tension.
    • Lane’s historical reverie slows the pace, building dread before the horrific revelation of Apache torture methods.

  3. Irony

    • Situational irony: Lane finds "consolation" in dying quickly—only to then imagine a slow, agonizing death by fire.
    • Dramatic irony: The reader knows (or suspects) Lane’s fate is grim, while he clings to fleeting hope (Rurales rescue).

  4. Stream of Consciousness

    • The passage shifts from immediate action (the bullet) to Lane’s meandering thoughts, mimicking how the mind escapes trauma through distraction (history, dark humor).

  5. Melodramatic Tone

    • The over-the-top description of Apache torture ("exquisitely ludicrous contortions") fits the sensationalist style of early Westerns, designed to shock and titillate readers.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. Frontier Mythmaking

    • The excerpt glorifies white endurance while demonizing Indigenous resistance, reinforcing the manifest destiny narrative.
    • Lane’s historical imagination erases Native agency, framing the fort as a site of white suffering (Spanish, missionaries) rather than Indigenous defense.

  2. Psychological Realism in Westerns

    • Unlike later, more nuanced Westerns (e.g., Cormac McCarthy’s works), this passage romanticizes stoicism but also captures the terror of isolation.
    • Lane’s gallows humor and morbid curiosity (imagining torture) humanize him beyond a simple hero archetype.

  3. Colonial Horror

    • The cactus crucifixion anecdote serves as propaganda, portraying Apaches as inhumanly cruel to justify their displacement.
    • The cross imagery ties Indigenous violence to biblical savagery, a tactic used to moralize conquest.

  4. Genre Conventions

    • The siege scenario, last-stand mentality, and desert as a character are staples of Western fiction, influencing later works like High Noon or The Searchers.
    • The blend of action and introspection keeps the reader engaged while deepening the atmosphere of dread.

Close Reading of Key Lines ​

  1. "Damned good shooting! They've probably left their best marksman below..."

    • Tone: Darkly admiring—Lane respects his enemy’s skill, a code of the West where even foes earn grudging praise.
    • Foreshadowing: If the best shooter is below, Lane is truly trapped; escape is impossible.

  2. "I am not the first man... that has withstood an attack in this place."

    • Historical weight: Lane mythologizes himself by connecting to past defenders, but his imagined history is biased—he sees only white/Spanish victims, not Native resilience.

  3. "More cruel than even the Romans... the Apaches are wont to bind their captives to these dead cacti..."

    • Hyperbole: Compares Apaches to ancient torturers, framing them as worse than historical villains.
    • Purpose: Justifies violent retribution against Native peoples in the reader’s mind.

  4. "Twist his body and limbs into... exquisitely ludicrous contortions."

    • Grotesque humor: The Apache "sense of humor" is portrayed as sadistic, dehumanizing them further.
    • Reader’s reaction: Intended to shock and repulse, reinforcing the us-vs-them dynamic.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This excerpt encapsulates the contradictions of the Western genre:

  • Heroism vs. Brutality: Lane is both a resourceful survivor and a product of colonial ideology.
  • Romance vs. Reality: The mythic desert hides real historical violence against Indigenous peoples.
  • Adventure vs. Propaganda: The thrilling siege distracts from the racist subtext of Apache demonization.

While The Round-Up is a pulp adventure, this passage reveals how early Westerns shaped American perceptions of the frontier—as a place of noble struggle for whites and savage resistance from others. Modern readers can critique its biased lens while appreciating its narrative tension and psychological depth.

Would you like a deeper dive into any specific aspect (e.g., historical accuracy of Apache torture, comparisons to other Western works)?