Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Moral Emblems, by Robert Louis Stevenson

‘Fanny, I shall have to write to my father.’

It served to make the little boy very precocious about money. In a
family perennially short of it he learned its essentialness early. He
knew too, that he was a dreadfully expensive child. His stepfather paid
forty pounds for his winter’s tutoring, not to speak of an additional
outlay on a dying Prussian officer who taught him German with the aid of
a pocket-knife stuck down his throat to give him the right accent. It
was with consternation that he once heard his stepfather say in a voice
of tragedy: ‘Good Heavens, Fanny, we are spending ten pounds a week on
food alone!’

The little boy, under the stress of this financial urgency, decided to go
into business, finding a capital opening in the Hotel Belvidere, where a
hundred programmes were required weekly for the Saturday night concerts.
A gentleman with a black beard, who was in charge of these arrangements,
willingly offered to pay two francs fifty centimes for each set of
programmes. The little boy was afraid of the gentleman with the black
beard; he was a formidable gentleman, with a formidable manner, and he
was very exacting about spelling. The gentleman with the black beard
attached an inordinate importance to spelling. The gentleman with the
black beard was wholly unable to make allowances for the trifling
mistakes that will occur in even the best-managed of printing-offices.
If the little boy printed: ‘’Twas in Trofolgar’s Bay . . . sung by Mr.
Edwin Smith,’ the black-bearded gentleman had no mercy in sending that
poor little boy back to do it all over again. But he paid promptly—a
severe man, but extremely honourable. There were charity-bazaars too,
public invitations, announcements, letter-heads, all bringing grist to
the mill. The ‘Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers’ was brought out, and sold
for a penny. Once there was a colossal order for a thousand lottery
tickets.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Moral Emblems by Robert Louis Stevenson ​

This passage from Robert Louis Stevenson’s Moral Emblems (1882) is a semi-autobiographical reflection on childhood, financial hardship, and the precociousness forced upon a young boy by economic necessity. While Moral Emblems is a collection of short, moralistic vignettes (some in verse, some in prose), this excerpt reads like a memoiristic sketch, blending humor, irony, and social commentary. Below is a close analysis of the text, focusing on its themes, literary devices, and deeper significance.

Context & Background ​

  • Robert Louis Stevenson (1850–1894) was a Scottish writer best known for Treasure Island, Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and Kidnapped. His own childhood was marked by illness (he suffered from tuberculosis) and a strained relationship with his father, Thomas Stevenson, a strict and successful lighthouse engineer.
  • Moral Emblems was published in 1882, a collection of short pieces that often carry didactic or satirical undertones. This excerpt, though not explicitly moralistic, reflects Stevenson’s wry observations on money, labor, and the loss of childhood innocence.
  • The passage is likely based on Stevenson’s own early experiences. His family was wealthy but frugal, and his father disapproved of his literary ambitions, pushing him toward engineering. The financial anxiety described here mirrors Stevenson’s own tensions with his father over career choices.

Summary of the Excerpt ​

The passage describes a young boy (likely a stand-in for Stevenson himself) growing up in a family perpetually short of money. He becomes acutely aware of his own financial burden—his education is expensive, and even his language tutoring involves bizarre measures (a Prussian officer with a knife in his throat to perfect his German accent). Overhearing his stepfather’s despair over household expenses ("ten pounds a week on food alone!"), the boy, driven by necessity, decides to go into business. He finds work printing programs for a hotel’s Saturday concerts, dealing with a terrifying, perfectionist client (the "gentleman with the black beard") who demands flawless spelling. Despite the stress, the boy takes on more jobs—printing charity bazaar announcements, lottery tickets, and even his own poetic work (Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers). The tone is a mix of dark humor, irony, and pathos, highlighting the absurdity of a child being thrust into adult responsibilities.

Key Themes ​

  1. The Loss of Childhood Innocence

    • The boy is forced into precocious adulthood by financial necessity. Instead of playing, he is calculating costs, negotiating with clients, and obsessing over spelling errors.
    • The mention of his "Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers" (a real poem Stevenson wrote as a child) is poignant—it suggests a child’s creativity being commodified (sold for a penny).
    • The absurdity of his German tutor (a dying officer with a knife in his throat) underscores how even his education is a grotesque, economically driven affair.

  2. Economic Anxiety & Family Struggle

    • The family’s financial strain is palpable: the stepfather’s exclamation ("Good Heavens, Fanny, we are spending ten pounds a week on food alone!") is delivered with "a voice of tragedy," framing basic survival as a crisis.
    • The boy internalizes this anxiety, seeing himself as a "dreadfully expensive child." His response is not rebellion but industry—he tries to alleviate the burden by working.

  3. The Harshness of Capitalism & Labor

    • The "gentleman with the black beard" is a symbol of unyielding capitalist expectations. He is "formidable," "exacting," and "wholly unable to make allowances"—qualities that mirror the impersonal cruelty of market demands.
    • The boy’s labor is exploited (he is paid meagerly for meticulous work), yet he is also learning the value of discipline and prompt payment ("a severe man, but extremely honourable").
    • The list of his jobs (programs, bazaars, lottery tickets) suggests the fragmented, precarious nature of gig work, even in childhood.

  4. Absurdity & Dark Humor

    • Stevenson uses irony to highlight the ridiculousness of the boy’s situation:
      • A dying Prussian officer teaching German with a knife in his throat is grotesquely comedic.
      • The black-bearded gentleman’s obsession with spelling (rejecting "'Twas in Trofolgar’s Bay") is pedantic to the point of absurdity.
      • The boy’s "colossal order" for lottery tickets (a gamble, ironically) underscores the randomness of economic survival.

  5. The Artist’s Struggle

    • The passage subtly critiques the tension between art and commerce. The boy’s creative work (Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers) is reduced to a penny transaction.
    • Stevenson himself faced this conflict—his father wanted him to be an engineer, but he chose writing, a far less stable profession. The excerpt reflects his own early struggles to reconcile creativity with financial reality.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Irony & Understatement

    • The boy’s situation is dire, but Stevenson describes it with detached humor:
      • "a capital opening in the Hotel Belvidere" – "capital" here is ironic, as the work is grueling.
      • "a gentleman with a black beard" – the repetition of this phrase makes him seem like a mythical ogre, emphasizing the boy’s fear.
    • The stepfather’s lament about spending "ten pounds a week on food alone!" is darkly comic—it’s a lot of money, but the exclamation makes it seem like an impossible luxury.

  2. Repetition for Emphasis

    • The phrase "the gentleman with the black beard" is repeated four times, making him a looming, almost monstrous figure. This repetition mirrors the boy’s dread and the inescapable nature of his client’s demands.
    • The listing of jobs ("charity-bazaars too, public invitations, announcements, letter-heads") creates a sense of relentless, fragmented labor.

  3. Juxtaposition

    • The boy’s youthful creativity (Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers) is placed alongside his mundane, commercial work (lottery tickets, programs). This contrast highlights how childhood is being eroded by economic necessity.
    • The Prussian officer’s bizarre teaching method (a knife in the throat) juxtaposes the seriousness of education with the absurdity of the family’s financial desperation.

  4. Symbolism

    • The Black-Bearded Gentleman: Represents the impersonal, unforgiving nature of capitalism. His exacting standards (especially about spelling) symbolize how the boy is being molded into a precise, efficient worker—stripped of childlike errors.
    • The Pocket-Knife in the Throat: A grotesque symbol of the extreme measures taken to "perfect" the boy (both linguistically and economically). It also foreshadows the "choking" of his childhood freedom.

  5. Tone: Wry, Satirical, Yet Melancholic

    • Stevenson’s tone is light and humorous on the surface, but there’s an undercurrent of sadness. The boy’s industriousness is admirable, but it’s also tragic that he must work so hard so young.
    • The passage ends on a note of exhausted triumph—the "colossal order" for lottery tickets is both a victory and a sign of how deeply he’s entangled in the adult world of commerce.

Significance & Broader Connections ​

  1. Autobiographical Echoes

    • Stevenson’s own father was a domineering figure who disapproved of his literary ambitions. The financial anxiety in the passage mirrors Stevenson’s real-life tensions with his family over his career choice.
    • The boy’s printing business parallels Stevenson’s own early writing—both are attempts to prove his worth and gain independence.

  2. Victorian Attitudes Toward Childhood & Labor

    • The Victorian era romanticized childhood innocence, but in reality, many children (especially in working-class families) labored from a young age. Stevenson subverts this ideal by showing a middle-class boy forced into precocious industry.
    • The passage critiques the hypocrisy of a society that idealizes childhood while economically exploiting it.

  3. The Artist’s Dilemma

    • The excerpt foreshadows Stevenson’s later themes (e.g., Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde’s duality). Here, the boy is both a creative child and a tiny capitalist, torn between art and survival.
    • The "Elegy for Some Lead Soldiers" (a real poem Stevenson wrote at age 6) symbolizes the commodification of art—something pure being sold for a penny.

  4. Economic Determinism

    • The boy’s fate seems predetermined by his family’s financial struggles. His creativity is channeled into labor, suggesting that talent is often shaped (or stifled) by economic circumstances.
    • This theme resonates with later writers like Charles Dickens (e.g., David Copperfield), where childhood is marked by financial hardship and early employment.

Conclusion: A Bitterly Funny Portrait of Childhood Under Capitalism ​

This excerpt from Moral Emblems is a masterful blend of humor, irony, and social critique. Stevenson uses the voice of a child to expose the absurdities and cruelties of economic necessity, showing how financial pressure warps childhood into a miniature adulthood. The passage is both a personal reflection (drawing on Stevenson’s own upbringing) and a universal commentary on how money shapes identity, creativity, and even education.

The boy’s story is tragicomic—his industriousness is impressive, but the cost is his childhood. The "gentleman with the black beard" looms as a symbol of the unforgiving world the boy must navigate, where even a misplaced apostrophe (Trofolgar’s) can mean failure. In the end, the passage leaves us with a sense of both admiration for the boy’s resilience and sorrow for what he has lost.