Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from The Black Arrow: A Tale of the Two Roses, by Robert Louis Stevenson

At the shore end of the pier, for perhaps a minute, Dick held his own
with a handful; one or two were wounded upon either side; steel crossed
steel; nor had there been the least signal of advantage, when in the
twinkling of an eye the tide turned against the party from the ship.
Someone cried out that all was lost; the men were in the very humour to
lend an ear to a discomfortable counsel; the cry was taken up. "On
board, lads, for your lives!" cried another. A third, with the true
instinct of the coward, raised that inevitable report on all retreats:
"We are betrayed!" And in a moment the whole mass of men went surging
and jostling backward down the pier, turning their defenceless backs on
their pursuers and piercing the night with craven outcry.

One coward thrust off the ship's stern, while another still held her by
the bows. The fugitives leaped, screaming, and were hauled on board, or
fell back and perished in the sea. Some were cut down upon the pier by
the pursuers. Many were injured on the ship's deck in the blind haste
and terror of the moment, one man leaping upon another, and a third on
both. At last, and whether by design or accident, the bows of the Good
Hope were liberated; and the ever-ready Lawless, who had maintained his
place at the helm through all the hurly-burly by sheer strength of body
and a liberal use of the cold steel, instantly clapped her on the proper
tack. The ship began to move once more forward on the stormy sea, its
scuppers running blood, its deck heaped with fallen men, sprawling and
struggling in the dark.

Thereupon, Lawless sheathed his dagger, and turning to his next
neighbour, "I have left my mark on them, gossip," said he, "the yelping,
coward hounds."

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from The Black Arrow: A Tale of the Two Roses by Robert Louis Stevenson ​

Context of the Source ​

The Black Arrow (1888) is a historical adventure novel by Robert Louis Stevenson, set during the Wars of the Roses (1455–1487), a civil war between the rival factions of the House of Lancaster (red rose) and the House of York (white rose). The story follows Dick Shelton, a young knight who becomes entangled in political intrigue, betrayal, and revenge after his guardian, Sir Daniel Brackley, is revealed to be a traitor.

The excerpt depicts a chaotic naval battle—likely a skirmish between Dick’s forces and those of his enemies. The scene is fast-paced, violent, and morally ambiguous, showcasing Stevenson’s skill in action writing and his exploration of courage, cowardice, and survival in war.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. Cowardice vs. Bravery

    • The passage contrasts panicked retreat with steadfast resolve.
    • The majority of the men abandon discipline, crying "We are betrayed!"—a classic excuse for cowardice in battle.
    • Lawless, however, remains unshaken, holding his position at the helm and even mocking the fleeing men ("the yelping, coward hounds").
    • Stevenson suggests that true courage is rare, and most men crumble under pressure.

  2. Chaos and Futility of War

    • The battle is senseless and brutal—men are cut down, trampled, or drowned in their desperation.
    • The phrase "the ship’s scuppers running blood" is a grim visual of war’s cost.
    • The sudden shift in momentum ("the tide turned against the party from the ship") reflects how battles (and wars) can be decided by luck as much as skill.

  3. Betrayal and Distrust

    • The cry "We are betrayed!" is a recurring motif in war literature—soldiers often blame treachery rather than their own failures.
    • This moment undermines morale, turning a structured fight into a rout (a disorderly retreat).

  4. Survival and Ruthlessness

    • Lawless is a moral gray character—he is brutal but effective, using "cold steel" (likely a dagger) to maintain control.
    • His line "I have left my mark on them" suggests pride in violence, reinforcing the novel’s realistic portrayal of medieval warfare, where survival often depends on ruthlessness.

Literary Devices & Stylistic Analysis ​

  1. Sensory & Kinetic Imagery

    • Stevenson immerses the reader in chaos through vivid, rapid descriptions:
      • "steel crossed steel" (the clash of weapons)
      • "surging and jostling backward" (the panic of the retreat)
      • "scuppers running blood" (the gruesome aftermath)
      • "sprawling and struggling in the dark" (the helplessness of the wounded)
    • The short, punchy sentences ("Someone cried out. The men were in the very humour to lend an ear.") mimic the suddenness of battle.

  2. Metaphor & Simile

    • "the tide turned against the party from the ship" – The tide is both literal (they’re on a pier) and metaphorical (their luck shifts).
    • "the yelping, coward hounds" – Lawless dehumanizes the fleeing men, comparing them to dogs, emphasizing his contempt.

  3. Irony & Dark Humor

    • The "true instinct of the coward" is ironically framed as an instinct—suggesting cowardice is natural, while bravery is learned or forced.
    • The absurdity of the retreat—men leaping on each other, some drowning, others being cut down—is almost darkly comedic in its chaos.

  4. Sound Devices (Onomatopoeia & Alliteration)

    • "steel crossed steel" – The harsh "s" and "t" sounds mimic the clang of swords.
    • "piercing the night with craven outcry" – The alliteration ("piercing," "craven," "cry") enhances the shrill, desperate tone of the retreat.

  5. Foreshadowing & Suspense

    • The sudden shift from a stalemate to a rout keeps the reader on edge.
    • The fate of the Good Hope (the ship) is left uncertain—will it escape? Will Dick survive? This propels the narrative forward.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. Realism in Historical Fiction

    • Stevenson avoids romanticizing war—instead, he shows fear, betrayal, and brutality.
    • Unlike chivalric tales where knights fight honorably, this battle is messy, desperate, and morally ambiguous.

  2. Characterization Through Action

    • Lawless is not a hero, but a survivor—his cynicism and violence make him a compelling antihero.
    • The fleeing soldiers represent human weakness, making the scene psychologically realistic.

  3. Political & Social Commentary

    • The Wars of the Roses were marked by shifting loyalties—this scene reflects how quickly alliances collapse under pressure.
    • The accusation of betrayal mirrors real historical paranoia in civil wars, where distrust was rampant.

  4. Stevenson’s Adventure Style

    • The excerpt is classic Stevenson—fast-paced, visually striking, and morally complex.
    • It blends action with psychological depth, a hallmark of his works (Treasure Island, Kidnapped).

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

This battle scene is more than just action—it’s a microcosm of war itself:

  • Courage is rare, cowardice is contagious.
  • Loyalty is fragile, betrayal is an easy excuse.
  • Violence is chaotic, survival is brutal.

Stevenson doesn’t glorify combat—he exposes its ugliness, making The Black Arrow a gripping, morally nuanced adventure rather than a simple tale of heroism. The excerpt captures the terror and unpredictability of battle, leaving the reader both thrillled and unsettled—a testament to Stevenson’s mastery of historical fiction.