Gutenberg Articles

Appearance

Excerpt ​

Excerpt from Self Help; with Illustrations of Conduct and Perseverance, by Samuel Smiles

While still struggling with poverty and difficulties, Heilmann’s wife
died, believing her husband ruined; and shortly after he proceeded to
England and settled for a time at Manchester, still labouring at his
machine. He had a model made for him by the eminent machine-makers,
Sharpe, Roberts, and Company; but still he could not make it work
satisfactorily, and he was at length brought almost to the verge of
despair. He returned to France to visit his family, still pursuing his
idea, which had obtained complete possession of his mind. While sitting
by his hearth one evening, meditating upon the hard fate of inventors and
the misfortunes in which their families so often become involved, he
found himself almost unconsciously watching his daughters coming their
long hair and drawing it out at full length between their fingers. The
thought suddenly struck him that if he could successfully imitate in a
machine the process of combing out the longest hair and forcing back the
short by reversing the action of the comb, it might serve to extricate
him from his difficulty. It may be remembered that this incident in the
life of Heilmann has been made the subject of a beautiful picture by Mr.
Elmore, R.A., which was exhibited at the Royal Academy Exhibition of
1862.

Upon this idea he proceeded, introduced the apparently simple but really
most intricate process of machine-combing, and after great labour he
succeeded in perfecting the invention. The singular beauty of the
process can only be appreciated by those who have witnessed the machine
at work, when the similarity of its movements to that of combing the
hair, which suggested the invention, is at once apparent. The machine
has been described as “acting with almost the delicacy of touch of the
human fingers.” It combs the lock of cotton at both ends, places the
fibres exactly parallel with each other, separates the long from the
short, and unites the long fibres in one sliver and the short ones in
another. In fine, the machine not only acts with the delicate accuracy
of the human fingers, but apparently with the delicate intelligence of
the human mind.

The chief commercial value of the invention consisted in its rendering
the commoner sorts of cotton available for fine spinning. The
manufacturers were thereby enabled to select the most suitable fibres for
high-priced fabrics, and to produce the finer sorts of yarn in much
larger quantities. It became possible by its means to make thread so
fine that a length of 334 miles might be spun from a single pound weight
of the prepared cotton, and, worked up into the finer sorts of lace, the
original shilling’s worth of cotton-wool, before it passed into the hands
of the consumer, might thus be increased to the value of between 300_l.
and 400_l. sterling.

Explanation ​

Detailed Explanation of the Excerpt from Self-Help by Samuel Smiles ​

Context of the Source ​

Samuel Smiles’ Self-Help; with Illustrations of Conduct and Perseverance (1859) is a seminal Victorian-era self-improvement book that champions individual effort, perseverance, and moral character as the keys to success. Written during the Industrial Revolution, it reflects the era’s belief in progress through hard work, ingenuity, and resilience. The book features biographical sketches of inventors, scientists, and industrialists—like James Watt, Richard Arkwright, and Heilmann (likely Edmé-Jean Leclaire, though some sources suggest Heilmann may refer to a lesser-known inventor)—to illustrate how determination overcomes adversity.

This excerpt tells the story of an unnamed inventor (referred to as Heilmann) who, despite repeated failures and personal tragedy, persists in perfecting a machine-combing device for cotton, inspired by an everyday observation of his daughters combing their hair. The passage exemplifies Smiles’ core themes: perseverance, observation, and the transformative power of simple ideas.

Themes in the Excerpt ​

  1. Perseverance in the Face of Adversity

    • Heilmann’s journey is marked by poverty, personal loss (his wife’s death), and repeated failure. Yet, he refuses to abandon his invention, even when "brought almost to the verge of despair."
    • The text emphasizes that success is not immediate—Heilmann travels between England and France, consults experts (Sharpe, Roberts, and Company), and endures years of struggle before his breakthrough.
    • Smiles uses this to reinforce his broader argument: great achievements require relentless effort, not just talent or luck.

  2. The Power of Observation and Simple Ideas

    • The eureka moment comes not from abstract theory but from mundane domestic life—watching his daughters comb their hair.
    • This aligns with Smiles’ belief that genius lies in noticing the ordinary and applying it in extraordinary ways. The passage suggests that innovation often stems from attentiveness to everyday phenomena.
    • The machine’s design mimics the human act of combing, showing how nature and simple actions can inspire mechanical solutions.

  3. The Intersection of Art and Industry

    • The mention of Mr. Elmore’s painting (exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1862) highlights how Heilmann’s story became a cultural symbol of Victorian ingenuity.
    • The artistic representation elevates the inventor’s struggle to a mythic, almost heroic status, reinforcing the Victorian ideal of the self-made man.

  4. Technological Progress and Economic Impact

    • The machine’s practical value is stressed: it revolutionizes cotton processing by separating long and short fibers, enabling finer, more valuable yarn.
    • The economic transformation is quantified:
      • A single pound of cotton could be spun into 334 miles of thread.
      • A shilling’s worth of raw cotton could become £300–400 in lace, demonstrating how technology multiplies wealth.
    • This reflects the Industrial Revolution’s impact—small innovations could have massive commercial consequences.

  5. The Humanization of Machinery

    • The machine is described with almost poetic admiration:
      • It works with the "delicacy of touch of the human fingers" and "delicate intelligence of the human mind."
    • This anthropomorphism (giving human traits to a machine) serves two purposes:
      1. It elevates the inventor’s achievement—his machine is not just functional but artistic and intelligent.
      2. It reassures readers that technology can be harmonious with human skill, countering fears of industrial dehumanization.

Literary Devices and Stylistic Choices ​

  1. Narrative Structure: The Hero’s Journey

    • The excerpt follows a classic underdog narrative:
      • Struggle (poverty, failure, despair)
      • Divine inspiration (the combing observation)
      • Triumph (perfecting the machine, economic success)
    • This structure makes the story morally instructive—readers are meant to see Heilmann as a model of resilience.

  2. Imagery and Sensory Language

    • Visual imagery:
      • The picture by Mr. Elmore (reinforcing the scene’s emotional weight).
      • The machine’s movements described as resembling human combing.
    • Tactile imagery:
      • The machine’s "delicacy of touch" and "human fingers" create a sensory connection between technology and humanity.

  3. Contrast and Juxtaposition

    • Failure vs. Success:
      • Early descriptions of despair and ruin contrast with the later economic triumph.
    • Simplicity vs. Complexity:
      • The invention seems "simple" (based on combing hair) but is "most intricate" in execution.

  4. Hyperbole and Exaggeration (for Emphasis)

    • The economic impact is dramatically quantified:
      • "334 miles of thread from a pound of cotton"
      • "£300–400 from a shilling’s worth of cotton"
    • These staggering numbers emphasize the transformative power of invention.

  5. Allusion to Art (Elmore’s Painting)

    • By referencing the Royal Academy exhibition, Smiles legitimizes Heilmann’s story as culturally significant, not just a technical footnote.

Significance of the Passage ​

  1. Victorian Values and Self-Help Philosophy

    • The excerpt embodies Smiles’ central thesis: success comes from perseverance, not privilege.
    • Heilmann is not a genius in the traditional sense—he is an everyman who succeeds through observation and grit, making his story relatable and inspirational to Smiles’ middle-class audience.

  2. The Romanticization of the Inventor

    • The passage mythologizes the inventor as a lonely, struggling visionary who overcomes all odds.
    • This romanticized portrayal was common in 19th-century literature (e.g., Edison, Watt) and served to glorify industrial progress.

  3. The Relationship Between Nature and Technology

    • The machine’s design mimics a natural human action, suggesting that the best inventions are those that work in harmony with nature.
    • This was a reassuring idea in an era where industrialization was often seen as disruptive and dehumanizing.

  4. Economic Optimism and Industrial Progress

    • The passage reflects the Victorian belief in unlimited progress—that technology could continuously improve human life.
    • The exponential increase in value (from a shilling to hundreds of pounds) symbolizes the wealth-creating power of industry.

  5. The Role of Serendipity and the "Aha!" Moment

    • The story reinforces the myth of the sudden breakthrough, a trope still popular in narratives about innovation (e.g., Newton’s apple, Archimedes’ bath).
    • However, Smiles does not downplay the labor—Heilmann’s success comes after "great labour," not just a flash of insight.

Critical Perspective: Strengths and Limitations ​

While the passage is uplifting and illustrative of Smiles’ themes, a modern reader might critique:

  • Over-simplification of success: The story ignores systemic barriers (class, access to capital) that many inventors faced.
  • Romanticization of struggle: The glorification of hardship can be seen as Victorian moralizing, where suffering is framed as noble rather than systemic.
  • Gender roles: The women (Heilmann’s wife and daughters) are passive figures—his wife dies in despair, and his daughters are unwitting muses, not active participants in the invention.

Despite these critiques, the excerpt remains a powerful illustration of how small observations can lead to world-changing innovations, a message that resonates even today.

Conclusion: Why This Passage Matters ​

Samuel Smiles’ account of Heilmann’s invention is more than just a success story—it is a manifesto of Victorian self-help philosophy. By focusing on perseverance, observation, and the transformative power of simple ideas, Smiles crafts a narrative that is both instructive and inspiring. The passage also reflects the optimism of the Industrial Revolution, where human ingenuity and machinery were seen as forces for progress.

For modern readers, the story serves as a reminder that innovation often comes from unexpected places and that failure is not the end, but a step toward success. However, it also invites reflection on how we mythologize inventors and whether we sometimes overlook the broader social and economic contexts that shape their journeys.